if you found an nude girl on the gorund (morality question)

Recommended Videos

kickyourass

New member
Apr 17, 2010
1,429
0
0
Well if you want a realistic answer, if I'm in a situation where I'm alone, without my cell phone, too far from someone with a phone to go there for help and it's getting dark, I'm most likely lost. So the best thing I could do for her is wrap her in the blanket, try to get her somewhere reasonable sheltered from the elements and hope that she wakes up.
 

flatten_the_skyline

New member
Jul 21, 2009
97
0
0
1. Speak to
No Response?
Touch Arm.
No Response?
2. Check breath/Pulse (This might be done with your ear close to her face, so you can hear the breath. Also, the ear is very sensitive to streams of air, like breath)
No Breath/Pulse?
--> heart massage, mouth to mouth (yes, some people might find that erotic. Focus on the job!)
No Success?
Run to the next phone IMMEDIATLEY. MAybe she can be saved.

Successful but unconscious? roll her to the side into recovery position. keep her covered by said blanket. Get to the next place to call an ambulance. Also get water, clothes and blankets.

Nobody cares about being seen naked in such a situation.
 

Udyrfrykte

New member
Jun 16, 2008
161
0
0
First, checking her vitals. Most likely I'd call an ambulance, I mean she's not waking up. It's not like I
You shouldn't carry her to the hospital, because if she has a neck injury or something in that direction you could seriously hurt her.

So no, don't "pick her up and carry her to a hospital".
 

Maxman3002

Steampunked
Jul 25, 2009
194
0
0
WolfThomas said:
DRSABCD

Danger? - Why is she on the ground? Gas leak? Loose electrics? TRAP?! Make sure it's safe for me to approach
Response - "Can you hear me?", "Squeeze my hand if you can". See if she's responsive
Send for help - Either call with a mobile (which I can't have due to OT) or try to find someone near by who can get help or phone an ambulance

Airway - Is there anything blocking her throat. Vomit? Clear and open.
Breathing - Listen very closely for any breathing. As I'm doing medical training I'd probably grab a carotid and brachial pulse quickly.
Compressions - If she's not breathing and has no pulse I'll start compressions, I won't do breathes because I'm alone and compressions are more important, plus I really don't want to get Hep A from someones spit.
Defib - not really possible at this point.

As the OP's rules means my chance of help arriving is practically nil, I pretty much do compressions til I physically can do no more and she's cold and obviously dead.

If she is breathing and has a pulse, I'll cover her with the blanket and my coat after assessing for any injuries, cuts or bruises that might indicate the source of her accident. I'd be careful not to move her neck and spine in case she has any spinal injuries. But if it looks like shes going to vomiting, I will move her into the recovery to prevent aspiration. Check pupils with the flashlight on my keys. Eventually if I cannot call or wave down someone to get help then I wrap her in the blanket and my coat and carry her towards a hospital, hoping I can wave down a car. Even someone calling the police would be good, because we can get her there faster.

As for carrying her, I have to balance possible spinal injuries with possible overdose. Its crap but if I really can't get any form of help, I can't physically leave her.
DRSABCD?

Isnt it DRSABC (Danger, Response, Send Help, Airway, Breathing, Circulation) out in the community and then ABCDE (Airway, breathing, circulation, disability, exposure) as a rapid assesment of an acutely ill patient where advanced life support is available? Defib isnt part of any resus that I know (possible it is different in your country?).

Also the OP says there is no phone or way of contact local to you and the risk of death outways spinal damage so first response would be to run off and find help, failing that carrying her would be an option depending on her weight
 

AgentNein

New member
Jun 14, 2008
1,476
0
0
I have no fucking clue what to make of this thread's topic.

It's just...weird. You're weird.
 

badgersprite

[--SYSTEM ERROR--]
Sep 22, 2009
3,820
0
0
In all honesty, chances are I'd walk past her without even noticing she was there. If everyone in this thread was being honest in their answers, homelessness wouldn't be a problem because everyone here would have helped. I'm not saying this out of any sense of superiority. I know chances are I wouldn't even be aware of her existence and wouldn't even see that she was there.
 

PurplePlatypus

Duel shield wielder
Jul 8, 2010
592
0
0
I?d make sure she?s alive, positioned reasonably comfortably and I?d stay with her until she woke up. If she didn?t wake up I?d wait for someone to come along who had a phone or could help me get her to the hospital.
 

Slangeveld

New member
Jun 1, 2010
319
0
0
KaosuHamoni said:
[sub][sub]Where's my season 3!? v.v[/sub][/sub]
Amen, dear sir, Amen.

OP: Well, if she'd be awake that would be something but ... There's obviously something very wrong here. Possibly been drugged?

I have no mobile phone, I can't drive. I would probably move to the nearest house/phone and ask to call 911.
 

Byere

New member
Jan 8, 2009
730
0
0
AccursedTheory said:
Seriously, is there really another answer?
Only to those weird and sick people on /b/

OT: What everyone else has said. Check for breathing and/or a pulse and assuming she still has one, pick her up, carry her to a hospital or my home (whichever is closer) and if it's the latter, call for an ambulance to get her checked up medically.
 

Kortney

New member
Nov 2, 2009
1,960
0
0
AccursedTheory said:
Cover her in jacket, carry to Police Station/Hospital.

Seriously, is there really another answer?
This. I'm kind of alarmed at the amount of people saying they would carry her home.

*shudders*

Not only is that extremely irresponsible and could lead to you being charged as a criminal (especially if she is in ill-health) it's also fucking creepy.
 

Balvarine

New member
Dec 6, 2010
4
0
0
Prob take her to a hospital. (oooh how original :D)

Why do i get the feeling this is because of the new Bleach arc? xD
 

DementedSheep

New member
Jan 8, 2010
2,654
0
0
Check her vitals and drive her to hospital myself since I can't call an ambulance?
If that isn?t an option for some weird reason and I can't get a phone anywhere take her home in the blanket, make sure she is warm, find her some clothes, keep an eye on her and wait for her to wake up.
What kind of question is this? Who in their right mind would do anything different. o_O
 

NathLines

New member
May 23, 2010
689
0
0
Is a gorund some sort of monster? In that case I'll slay the beast D: Or if that monster doesn't wake up either, I'll take the girl to the hospital/police or I'll take her home first if it's nearby and then call the hospital/police.

When I come home with her to my girlfriend - "Can I keep it"?
 

WolfThomas

Man must have a code.
Dec 21, 2007
5,292
0
0
Maxman3002 said:
DRSABCD?

Isnt it DRSABC (Danger, Response, Send Help, Airway, Breathing, Circulation) out in the community and then ABCDE (Airway, breathing, circulation, disability, exposure) as a rapid assesment of an acutely ill patient where advanced life support is available? Defib isnt part of any resus that I know (possible it is different in your country?).

Also the OP says there is no phone or way of contact local to you and the risk of death outways spinal damage so first response would be to run off and find help, failing that carrying her would be an option depending on her weight
May be different (in the UK?) to over here in Australia, but that's the current Australian one as of like a few months ago. They seem pretty similar though. We have defib in the community one simply because of high number of defibs in public places.

Yeah any scenario where you physically can't find someone either in a house or car easily, you're probably best carrying them.
 

Brutal Peanut

This is so freakin aweso-BLARGH!
Oct 15, 2010
1,770
0
0
Bring out the handy-dandy cellphone and call emergency services. I'd probably be far too scared to touch her (let alone pick her up in case of severe neck or back injury), in case I'd make whatever could be wrong with her worse. I may check her vitals however, see if she has a pulse.

I'm not just using the usual answer - I've called emergency services and the police for a naked stranger before. But she was also delirious, belligerent, and doing a weird gyrating and convulsing strip-dance naked in traffic. Trust me, it's not anywhere near as hot as it sounds since she was probably 50 and didn't age particularly well *shudder* They arrived and attended to her. It was probably one of the,... weirdest ....things I've seen in my life.
 

Hinoema

New member
Oct 9, 2010
19
0
0
jamesmax said:
if you found

a very attractive girl,
nude with just a blanket on top off her,
on the gorund outside,
and wont wake up,
you dont have a cell,
your not neer any place you could borrow a phone,
its just you no frends,
its geting late and you know sumone would do sumthing bad to her if you left her ther





just as a joke not part of all this
Your girlfrend is home




what would you do?


i got the ieda for this form bleach ep 317
Not addressing the question right now, just wondering why this place always seems to assume that the entire forum reading audience is straight males. Seriously?
 

SinisterGehe

New member
May 19, 2009
1,456
0
0
Psycho Cat Industries said:
Simple,walk away.It ain't any of my business and since it is a "girl",she'd be like 12 so I am kind of disturbed by the phrasing.I don't know who she is,she could be here by choice.She'd probably run away and more than likely wouldn't want to see such authorities as I could present to help her.Its her choice to be there and I don't know her.What is there to help with if a situation without conflict in such a manner exists?
I don't know about US law, but in Finnish law negligence is a crime, punishable with fines or with prison, depending on the severity of the situation.

I would do a basic first aid check, cover her with my jacket/shirt whatever and carry her to somewhere to get help, I am not really able to carry well due to my hands condition but I got strong left arm so I should manage to carry her somewhere. If I can't I will go and find help.
I am legally bound to do that or to go and find help, since negligence is illegal and I can end up in prison. Even tho I don't like people, I don't want to hate myself for causing death to someone.

Is there are other answer than to help her to safety?