If you had to choose....

[Aesthetical Quietus]

Hm... Somesort of FPS. Probably MW2. [I prefer the online maps and the graphics of the second, but the storyline of the first. Urgh]. AVA, SF and MW are all close competitors. [I could actually pick SF over MW2, mostly because I have more friends in it].

 

[Doclector]

Battlefield bad company 2.

 

[BIGB0SS]

metal gear solid 3
I love this game!

 

[Phoenixlight]

It looks like you stole this idea directly from the IGN UK podcast but I'd probably take Mass Effect 2, it has a lot of different ways to complete the game.

 

[Jonesy911]

Probably Persona 4 because of all the different ways in can pan out

 

[Ben Jamin]

Diablo 3.

I managed to beat Diablo 2 at least 6 times so I think I could get a few months out of it.

 

[FieryTrainwreck]

A sports game. I don't generally play them, but they're probably the least scripted or rigid games. No two games are ever exactly the same. I still see crazy shit for the first time when I pop in an old basketball title on occasion.

 

[nuba km]

I would get the orange box (I love loop holes I mean it is one game it is limited to the 1000(g) of other games and in the gamer profile it is listed as one game).

 

[Ambient]

Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King.

 

[Edorf]

MW2 or Oblivion probably

 

[butternut]

I would also pick Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the cursed king. The game is so bleedin long (Took me 120 hours to complete it first time, not including side quests and extra endgame dungeons) Plus its replayable as all the characters can be trained in 4 different weapons keeping them different each time.

...and not to mention Jessica's jiggle physics...

 

[Decum]

Fallout 3 or Oblivion on PS3, i prefer 360 but with a PS3 i can surf the web...

 

[Baldry]

Urm that's a tough question...A sims game, or a final fantasy one or fallout new Vegas

 

[Bishop23]

Hrmm, I think I'd comfortably waste time on The Sims 3. Got nothing better to do with my own life if I'm stuck on an island...

 

[sheah1]

Monster Hunter Freedom Unite, that game is so ridiculously long that I'd still be trying to take out Tigrexes by the time I get picked up. But can we please go so far into the future that it has worldwide online? Pretty please?

 

[Russel1]

I'd play COD:MW2 and PM my friend to come pick me up to I can come home and play many games =D

 

[Lem0nade Inlay]

Counter Strike: Source.

Even if it didn't have custom modes and servers (like surf or scoutknivez) I think it would still be great fun.

Maybe not if I could only play with bots, because it just feels worse playing against bots.

So if it was only against bots...I wouldn't. Maybe instead...Half-Life 2? Or Fallout 3?

Or a pokemon game (one of the newer ones, like diamond. Purely because it has more stuff to do) Don't judge me! It would give me stuff to do.

 

[avelmen1889]

for me it would be either mass effect 2 (unless 3 would be better i dunno) or team fortress 2

 

[sheah1]

I would also pick Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the cursed king. The game is so bleedin long (Took me 120 hours to complete it first time, not including side quests and extra endgame dungeons) Plus its replayable as all the characters can be trained in 4 different weapons keeping them different each time.

...and not to mention Jessica's jiggle physics...

Just while I have someone here, would you advise getting it now? Because I know a couple places where I could get it really cheaply, and I do love my expansive RPGs.