Immortality...

Recommended Videos

Aircross

New member
Jun 16, 2011
658
0
0
Being immortal doesn't mean you're invincible right?

I could stand being immortal knowing that I can be killed.
 

immortalfrieza

Elite Member
Legacy
May 12, 2011
2,336
270
88
Country
USA
Frozen Donkey Wheel2 said:
Nope. Not a curse at all. Here are some of the common arguments against it, and why they are wrong.

1. You'll run out of things to do, causing you to lose your appreciation for life, causing your life to become horrible and pointless.
--People who say this don't have any imagination. It's a big world, and it's an IMPOSSIBLY big universe. If I had immortality, I wouldn't stop until I'd seen it all, which would probably never happen. A life of immortality would be fucking fantastic. What's that you say? Space travel hasn't been invented? I'm immortal, you idiot. I can wait.

2. You'll have to watch your friends grow old and die.
--I. AM. IMMORTAL. Nobody THINKS about what that means. I can spend the next trillion years inventing some kind of "Immortality Potion" and then spend another trillion inventing time travel. And don't tell me about paradoxes.[footnote]If I go back in time and make my friends immortal, I won't have a reason to invent immortality/time travel anymore, and won't do it. Paradox![/footnote] I can spend another trillion years inventing a machine that can keep the paradox stable. Like some kind of...Paradox Machine.

3. Nothing lasts forever, everything dies sometime. It's the natural order of things. You can't go against the natural order of things.
--And just why the hell not? Humans can't breathe underwater, but scuba-divers do it anyway every goddamn day. THAT is breaking the natural order of things. Frankly, breaking the natural order of things is what humanity is all about anyway, and I think it's a great system.

Personally, if someone invents robot bodies, I'll be the first in line for conversion.
Yeah, that's the one thing everyone seems to forget, if there are any problems with immortality you'd have an eternity to fix them. In fact, there's a Cracked article (http://www.cracked.com/article_18708_5-reasons-immortality-would-be-worse-than-death.html) that lists a few of these problems, I personally would have them all solved within a millenia tops.

The only real factor in how a person would handle immortality of any sort is how much will to live they have. If someone can barely stand living now, how could they stand it forever? However, if they have a limitless will to live then they wouldn't have any problems whatsoever.
 

Daniel_Rosamilia

New member
Jan 17, 2008
1,110
0
0
immortalfrieza said:
Daniel_Rosamilia said:
I'd love to have immortality, but I'd like to stay at a particular age, and still have the ability to die, temporarily of course, but if I get shot at point-blank in the head, I want to die, and then come back.
This may not technically fall under 'immortality', but that's how I would like it to be.
So... Basically you would want to be a modern Jesus.
To an extent, sure.
Just without the whole getting-stuck-in-a-cave-for-3-days thing, but the walking on water but would be pretty cool.
 

Anthony Abney

New member
Mar 16, 2011
86
0
0
Frozen Donkey Wheel2 said:
2. You'll have to watch your friends grow old and die.
--I. AM. IMMORTAL. Nobody THINKS about what that means. I can spend the next trillion years inventing some kind of "Immortality Potion" and then spend another trillion inventing time travel. And don't tell me about paradoxes.[footnote]If I go back in time and make my friends immortal, I won't have a reason to invent immortality/time travel anymore, and won't do it. Paradox![/footnote] I can spend another trillion years inventing a machine that can keep the paradox stable. Like some kind of...Paradox Machine.
actually, if your friends are immortal with you, they can tell you to invent immortality/time travel so that you go back and give them immortality. paradox averted
 

Loner Jo Jo

New member
Jul 22, 2011
172
0
0
Tanakh said:
Loner Jo Jo said:
In order to truly live, you have to die.
That's a false dichotomy, is like saying that in order to eat you have to be hungry, or that in order to have sexual intercourse you need to be horny. If you have a passion in life you will peruse it no matter what, because it's amazing to chase a dream.

Gimme immortality or give me death!!!1
While I see your point, I would argue life and death are slightly different. One of the distinguishing features of a living organism in biological study is that it is capable of dying. If something cannot die, it is not a living organism. Eating in its definition does not require hunger and sex does not require desire in its definition.
 

Zakarath

New member
Mar 23, 2009
1,244
0
0
I'd want to be immortal as long as I could still die when I eventually got bored. Otherwise, no thanks.
 

Suicideking

New member
Oct 28, 2009
85
0
0
Frozen Donkey Wheel2 said:
2. You'll have to watch your friends grow old and die.
--I. AM. IMMORTAL. Nobody THINKS about what that means. I can spend the next trillion years inventing some kind of "Immortality Potion" and then spend another trillion inventing time travel. And don't tell me about paradoxes.[footnote]If I go back in time and make my friends immortal, I won't have a reason to invent immortality/time travel anymore, and won't do it. Paradox![/footnote] I can spend another trillion years inventing a machine that can keep the paradox stable. Like some kind of...Paradox Machine.
Nah, No Paradox there. Once you go back and change history, a new time line is created. You won't have to create the immortality potion and time travel, but it won't change what would now be the past of you already doing it. The Back to the Future series explained that nicely.


On topic: I'd love to be immortal. Of course, I fully realize that eventually that means I'll end up floating around in space without any ship or suit. Get pulled into a star or 12 and spend countless years waiting for that star to explode. May even get pulled into a black hole. A lot of that sucks. I still would love it.
 

Scorpid

New member
Jul 24, 2011
814
0
0
Depends on the rules of immortality. If it's highlander style immortality or true immortality? IF it's Highlander immortality then yes i absolutely would want that, if its true immortality where nothing can kill you or for simplicity, harm you then no.
Highlander I can keep living until someone cuts off my head, so if i get really bored of it all then I'd just find a guillotine.
If it's true immortality you have so many problems. OH WAIT CRACKED DID A ARTICLE ON JUST THAT.
http://www.cracked.com/article_18708_5-reasons-immortality-would-be-worse-than-death.html
 

Tanakh

New member
Jul 8, 2011
1,512
0
0
StargateSpankyHam said:
Perhaps more interestingly, immortality is actually within our grasp.

With technology advancing as it is, computers will be as intricate and advanced as the human brain by 2029, assuming that human civilization doesn't suffer a socioeconomic meltdown between now and then.

Neuroscience may take a little bit longer to catch up, but when it does, it will be possible to connect with a sufficiently advanced computer and simply 'copy & paste' the entire contents of our brain into it. In this regard, so long as one conducts regular backups of their mind, and can afford a new body, they would be effectively immortal.

Never mind the tantalizing possibility of uploading one's own mind into the computer arrays of something much larger and more specialized...such as a spacecraft. Without the need for life support systems and living quarters, there is no real obstacle to centuries-long flights between star systems.

Call me a futurist...but immortality is going to rock.
There are several problems with this:

- No, won't, if you mean that by 2029 you might be able to do a neural network in a supercomputer with the same amount of nodes as a human brain has neurons? Probably, but that would be like saying a car made of cardboard is an intricate as a last generation porsche.

- Copy what mate? Copy what? Again the topology? Let me ask you this, if you build a skyscraper in the middle of NY and if you do it in the sahara desert, would it do the same? The brain is much more that a connection of neurons, the difference between those, the chemistry, the input and output strata, all of that matters. What you want and might be possible soon is akin to take a bunch of cultivated organs, sewing them together and expect the result to be a "human".
 

Infernai

New member
Apr 14, 2009
2,605
0
0
Is immortality a gift? Yes it can be, but i follow the Alucard Philosophy: You can't just take it, you need to fucking earn it.

Why do i say that? Imagine that annoying dumbass who has done nothing with his life, gets handed everything on a plate and basically does fuck all..would you really want him to have immortality or that smart, humble and hard-working woman who came from nothing and had to work to get absolutely everything they ever had? I know who i would grant immortality to in that case. Plus, it makes sure all those bastards from your Westboro baptist church leaders through to your rapists don't have the capacity to keep going forever without consequence.

So basically, yeah no problems with immortality...but i know i wouldn't want to see it given to the wrong person.
 

Levethian

New member
Nov 22, 2009
509
0
0
Zakarath said:
I'd want to be immortal as long as I could still die when I eventually got bored.
I can't imagine getting bored as long as there's a human civilization manufacturing escapist entertainment.
 

OrokuSaki

New member
Nov 15, 2010
386
0
0
Well, I think I'd choose to be immortal. For several reasons: A.) I don't want to die, I'm a nihilist and I think that dying is the ultimate punishment ever because you utterly cease to exist. B.) I can accept everyone dying, because I'm going to outlive everyone that I care about anyways, so why not go for eternity. C.) I'd like to live to see the future. This "Present" thing seems like we're one evil conspiracy away from the plot of Human Revolution and I'd like to see that end and become something else.
 

Ldude893

Elite Member
Apr 2, 2010
4,114
0
41
I'm only going to post two things. A link:
http://www.cracked.com/article_18708_5-reasons-immortality-would-be-worse-than-death.html

And a video:
<youtube=5L8-FTvSVxs>

I think that's enough to express my opinion on the subject.
 

Blindswordmaster

New member
Dec 28, 2009
3,145
0
0
Oh it's great for a few hundred years, maybe even entertaining to see humanity develop over thousands of years or watch the course of evolution over millions of years, but eternity is a long fucking time. What would you do after 150 million years when the Earth is absorbed by our dying sun? What about the eventual decay of your galaxy. The Universe is approximately 14 billion years old, and with eternity stretched out before you you could possibly exist much longer than that. This universe will eventually die, but you wouldn't. Imagine the whole stretch of time itself, alone. No stars, no matter, no energy, just you. Alone. Forever. Huh, kinda morbid. Okay, a long healthy life is great, say about 300 to 400 years, would be great, but living forever brings some serious considerations.
 

Bealzibob

New member
Jul 4, 2009
405
0
0
People always approach this question with their currently perception of time which would change if you were immortal. But the biggest one is whats the difference between dieing and being eternally trapped somewhere. Both are endless non-existance because being trapped like that without dieing means you would eventually either just sleep or space out till time itself helped you back out into a stimulating enough enviroment to return your consciousness.

I've spent innumerous amount of time doing nothing for extended periods of time (Mostly roadtrips) and I can pass an one to fifteen hours in what feels like a couple of seconds. Time would become alot less relevant after a millenia or two.

Infernai said:
I think this is a bit irrelevant tbh. If this is actually eternal life that we're talking about then people would lose there petty hangups like that. After you've brought planets to ruin simply but outlasting then you would stop caring about picketing soldiers funerals.
 

axlryder

victim of VR
Jul 29, 2011
1,862
0
0
immortality is terrifying. The idea of living forever, with no end, is absolutely terrifying. I used to have constant panic attacks from the prospect of forever. I literally had to shut off that part of my brain to keep myself from having a nervous breakdown (no hyperbole here). That being said, I can't think or talk about it too much. Truly staring down the barrel of eternity, though, a barrel with NO end (the concept of which most humans can't grasp because their brain has unconscious safeguards in place). Well, it's enough to destroy you.

also, there is technically a being which has no definite limit to its lifespan

Under the right conditions, Turritopsis nutricula is potentially immortal. Just an interesting tid-bit.
 

Tanakh

New member
Jul 8, 2011
1,512
0
0
Loner Jo Jo said:
One of the distinguishing features of a living organism in biological study is that it is capable of dying.
This definition irks me for two reasons, it's recursive, so life it's defined by death and death by life (that is the sign of a shitty definition in logic). The second is that virus are freaking alive, "borderline life forms" is crap, sure, they do need a host to function, but we need far more, food, a very specific atmosphere, gravity, air pressure (but not too much or too little), and why do stuff like Conways game isn't even in the discussion for biologists? <youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XcuBvj0pw-E>

When we manage to make a self replicator machine biologist will have a lot of explaining to do :p
 

Ghaleon640

New member
Jan 13, 2011
441
0
0
didn't read others' posts, so if this was already said forgive me.

One day the earth will be swallowed by the sun. Long story short, do you trust mankind to escape earth before that happens? I mean... theoretically, if hell is eternal fire, then getting sucked into a sun is pretty similar. Though who knows, maybe waiting until it explodes may send you somewhere else interesting. Or just floating in space forever.....
..
.
Or just into another sun.
 

chadachada123

New member
Jan 17, 2011
2,310
0
0
Here's the thing about being unable to die: it says nothing about your ability to be in a coma, etc, or if various parts of you can be swapped out for other parts. Simply make my brain able to be put permanently into sleep mode when/if I ever get sick of being forever conscious.