in your opinion, which game was been the biggest flop of all time

Recommended Videos

HT_Black

New member
May 1, 2009
2,845
0
0
captainaweshum said:
HT_Black said:
1. It was a Zelda game, which are ostensibly all very good.
2. It had Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask to live up to.
3. It wasn't the second coming of Jesus, and as such was a flop.
Okay that still doesn't add up for why you think ME2 or Lost Odyssey are bad.

You think Lost Odyssey is in the running for worst game of all time? Really? You can't think of anything worse? I wanna be playing whatever you are playing.
ME2--and I can't really pin down why-- just didn't really do it for me. Because I thought the first one was veritably divine, anything that wasn't just as good or even better seemed like a flop to me (although it was hardly bad in any sense of the word). That is, however, entirely opinion; one which I know is not widely held.

Lost Odyssey, on the other hand, suffered from a very definite and very deadly flaw: that is to say, it was boring. The environments were repetitive and oppresively linear; the characters were either annoying or nonentities; the combat system was the very worst of turn-based systems personified; and forty or so minutes of every hour was made up entirely of long-winded cutscenes filled with disinteresting people and stilted acting, which served to further a plot that, while interesting at first, eventually gave way to half-baked attempts at suspense and excercises in narrative tedium. While games like Lair and Geneforge are inferior from a gameplay and graphical perspective, both of those were at least able to string along my interest until they ended; and in my opinion, being interesting is a much more important to a game than being functional.
 

Communist partisan

New member
Jan 24, 2009
1,858
0
0
Fable II, GTA IV, Half Life 2 and ep 1 ep 2, Point lookout (even if that's a DLC), MW2, Assasins creed 1 and 2, Halo reach beta, halo 3, prins of persia (ALL of'em of course!), All ghost recons and many many more.
 

ww666

New member
Feb 18, 2010
117
0
0
I'd say Dante's Inferno, for all the advertising EA was doing, I expected a little more than God of War the revenge of christianism
 

MoNKeyYy

Evidence or GTFO
Jun 29, 2010
513
0
0
I have to say Dragon Age: Origins on this one, and keep in mind this is just my personal biggest disappointment. I found it to be boring, not at all immersive, monotonous, and unintuitive. I loved KOTOR and ME but I just couldn't find myself Getting into Dragon Age.
 

Iwata

New member
Feb 25, 2010
3,333
0
0
I think people are mistaking "biggest flop" with "game you hated"...
 

dark_paladin_Quest

New member
Jun 24, 2010
13
0
0
By Far Hellgate London, i had such high hopes for it, then played it and found it was set in the same two pieces of abandoned tube tunnel and abandoned street....i had fury
 

Clueless Hero

New member
Oct 5, 2009
185
0
0
Advent Rising. The difficulty spiked sky fucking high pretty much right after the tutorial levels and stayed up there the entire game. It was the one game I couldn't beat without cheats (Then again, I played it when I was 10...but still.)

EDIT: Damn, Ninja'd.
 

tricky_tree

New member
Jan 10, 2010
329
0
0
In my humble opinion, FFXIII. It came out on my birthday, I had pre-ordered a game for the first time, really excited and all that, 5 hours in and I threw it away.

Just terrible.
 

Lerxst

New member
Mar 30, 2008
269
0
0
Any MMO where everyone's power-leveled to the end-game and I'm stuck in all the low zones going solo.
 

Brainst0rm

New member
Apr 8, 2010
417
0
0
I was totally underwhelmed by Oblivion. Which is weird, because exploration is my favorite part of any game, but it's more the BioWare kind of exploration. To explore and constantly find things, like the first few hours in the Citadel...GORAM! That's my crack!
 

AyaReiko

New member
Aug 9, 2008
354
0
0
Buddahcjcc said:
Vitor Goncalves said:
HTID Raver said:
spore....


*facepalm*
Indeed, worst disappointment ever, I can't even believe that came from the creator of simcity, he should have done a Simcity 5 instead.
Simcitty MMO instead lol
They tried that. It was called The Sims Online. It bombed. BADLY.

-

I'd pick games that not only failed, but killed the studio too. So obviously my picks are ET, Atari Pac-Man, Daikatana, and DNF.
 

micky

New member
Apr 27, 2009
1,184
0
0
for me it was too human, it looked so cool but looks can be deceiving.
 

EPolleys

New member
May 12, 2010
117
0
0
I'd say Two Worlds, maybe not the biggest flop but definetly one of the most humiliating.
Oblivion killer my ass that game was barely playable.
 

TheHitcher

New member
Sep 9, 2009
332
0
0
Axolotl said:
TheHitcher said:
Fable II wouldn't have been as bad if ol' Pete had kept his piehole shut. Hard to say what the biggest flop was... I actually think MW2 was a flop in the end. It took me several months to realise that I hated it, though. Think I'm gonna go with Dante's Inferno here since it was so hyped up then turned out to be below mediocre.
MW2 was one of the most profitable games of all time. That's not a flop.
I'm sorry, let's go back and read the name of this topic.

"in your opinion, which game was been the biggest flop of all time"

Now, let's focus on the first three words.

"IN YOUR OPINION"

That's exactly what I have given. It doesn't say "Based on factual, qualitative evidence, which game sold the least amount of copies"...

Besides, in a way, you're wrong about that, anyway. While MW2 was indeed profitable, the game eventually lead to the downfall of Infinity Ward with something like over 30 employees being fired. They weren't exactly insignificant staff either...
 

Axolotl

New member
Feb 17, 2008
2,401
0
0
TheHitcher said:
Axolotl said:
TheHitcher said:
Fable II wouldn't have been as bad if ol' Pete had kept his piehole shut. Hard to say what the biggest flop was... I actually think MW2 was a flop in the end. It took me several months to realise that I hated it, though. Think I'm gonna go with Dante's Inferno here since it was so hyped up then turned out to be below mediocre.
MW2 was one of the most profitable games of all time. That's not a flop.
I'm sorry, let's go back and read the name of this topic.

"in your opinion, which game was been the biggest flop of all time"

Now, let's focus on the first three words.

"IN YOUR OPINION"

That's exactly what I have given. It doesn't say "Based on factual, qualitative evidence, which game sold the least amount of copies"...

Besides, in a way, you're wrong about that, anyway. While MW2 was indeed profitable, the game eventually lead to the downfall of Infinity Ward with something like over 30 employees being fired. They weren't exactly insignificant staff either...
But a flop refers directly to finacial failure. Not how mush you like or dislike it. And no saying it's your opinion doesn't change anything. I could say "Civilisation is the best FPS ever in my opinion" and it would be a stupid thing to say because it's not an FPS. Similarly MW2 was not a flop, in fact it's opening was the most profitable of any work of fiction ever made.
 

TjoxYorro

New member
Sep 2, 2009
90
0
0
Rogue Warrior..

Shooting trough empty levels that look like shit, and killing completely AI less enemys.
 

Phoenix09215

New member
Dec 24, 2008
714
0
0
Gilbert Munch said:
HT_Black said:
The worst flop of all time? Twilight Princess, easily. The runner-up is ME2, which is in turn followed closely by KOTOR 2.

The worst game of all time? ^I don't know^, but I thought Lost Odyssey was nothing short of painful.
Hahaha, oh wow.

Sorry, but I don't see how Twilight Princess can be 'easily' considered a flop, by any stretch of the imagination.
Was thinking the same thing... I thought it was pritty good :S

Maby Resident evil 5?? Good gameplay but it totally ruined Albert Wesker's character and detroyed what was left of the storyline...