Iron Maiden review: Reviewing a band?! Has Tim jumped the shark?!

Recommended Videos
Nov 28, 2007
10,686
0
0
I'm trying to widen my scope by reviewing a music band this time. Anyways, I'm going to switch up my style by using a review of each band member, then of the band as a whole, past and present. So without further ado...

Steve Harris (played from 1975-)is the bassist of Iron Maiden, and the founding member as well. He is widely considered to be one of the best bassists in the world, and invented a new method of playing bass called "galloping", which is play and eighth note followed by two sixteenth notes, or eighth note triplets with his fingers. He also uses power chords and doesn't use a pick or warm up.

His reputation as an incredible bassist is more than deserved. I have not heard anyone who can play a bass as fast as him and still make it sound good. The fact that he does this all with his fingers is just incredible. Overall, with the exception of Flea, Geddy Lee, and Les Claypool, Steve Harris is possibly the best bassist around.

Dave Murray (1975-)is the second longest lasting member, playing the guitar. He uses a legato based solo style, and frequently uses neck pickups. He is also an incredible guitarist, managing to shred and still make it sound good. He can also play fast without ruining the sound, something several guitarists struggle with. He has been with the band for a long time, and I hope he stays. He is one of the best guitarists I've heard, and I've heard a lot.

Paul Di'Anno (1978-1981) was the original singer for Iron Maiden. He sang on their debut album, named "Iron Maiden", and the follow-up "Killers". He had a very unique voice that served him well on the songs he sang. In fact, 2 of my top 10 Iron Maiden songs, "Wrathchild" and "Killers" had him as the vocalist. Considering he was only in the band for 3 years, that's not too shabby. However, he was overshadowed by his follow-up...

Adrian Smith (1980-89, 1999-) is the rhythm guitarist, and works well enough with Dave Murray to cause people to refer to them as "Murray-Smith", since their guitar lines mesh so well that they sound as one. His premiere album was "Killers", and the change in sound is immediately noticeable. While he is a great guitarist, he honestly doesn't seem to have quite as much of an impact to me as Dave Murray.

Bruce Dickinson (yes, THE Bruce Dickinson) (1981-1993, 1999-) is the vocalist for Iron Maiden. He has pretty much defined the sound of Iron Maiden, obscuring the vocals of Paul Di'Anno from all but true fans. He is definitely one of the best singers in the business today, having a wide vocal range and, in "Number of the Beast", letting out what is quite possibly the best scream recorded in music, extremely high pitched and lasting at least 10 seconds. He has proven to be versatile as well, singing slower songs such as "Sign of the Cross", to heavier songs like "Aces High". He has even gone from one extreme to the other within the same song, such as in "Fear of the Dark". His range, and skill, makes him one of the best singers I've heard, next to Brad Delp and Geddy Lee.

The final current member to join Iron Maiden was Nicko McBrain (1982-), the drummer. Besides having a last name that must have gotten him pantsed at school almost daily, he is one hell of a drummer, in my opinion the third best I've heard, next to Neil Peart and Mike Portnoy. He is fast, clean, and has an awesome last name. What more could you ask for in a drummer? While possibly the least visible of the band members, he is still far better than most in his field.


The band overall has had some ups and downs, including, amusingly enough, "Bring Your Daughter to the Slaughter" which was their only No. 1 hit on England's Singles charts...and here in the United States, got the 1989 Golden Raspberry award for "Worst Original Song", being written for Nightmare on Elm Street 5. However, this is, in my opinion, the best band ever made. They just mesh with each other so well, and have such a wide range of songs, it is impossible to dislike them all, unless you don't like metal. They have a great sound, but more than that, most of their songs have a meaning behind them. They aren't just written to sound good. And that, from a metal band, is more than most people expect. So, up the Irons. They are here to stay.
 
Nov 28, 2007
10,686
0
0
I've had quite a few reviews on this site. Can't expect you to know that since you only joined 8 days ago, but then, maybe you should look around the site before being a jerk.
 

JakubK666

New member
Jan 1, 2008
781
0
0
duckferret post=326.69657.666559 said:
Who are you, and why do we care?
Let's see...he's almost on his 5000th post, you're on your 5th.

He's the one that should be asking this question.
 
Nov 28, 2007
10,686
0
0
Thank you. Felt like doing a review, couldn't think of a game, avoiding movies after the last debacle, so I decided to do a review of something else.
 

BentNeatly

New member
Aug 25, 2008
262
0
0
Dude. sensational review. The whole time i would think something and then you would say it. On the bass thing i was thinking to myself "hey what about les and geddi?!?!" and then you nailed it. Truthfully, you really have a great idea of what your talking about. But im surprised you didnt mention Phantom of the Opera for D'anno... Ive always considered that the greatest work he's ever done, other then get really depressed and eat alot...
 
Nov 28, 2007
10,686
0
0
Phantom of the Opera is...eh...I like the guitar line on it, but I always felt Bruce Dickinson's voice would have suited it more.
 

zombielifecoach

New member
Feb 21, 2008
167
0
0
Hey thebobmaster. Growing up I never really listened to Maiden. Somehow, it just eluded me. Now that Im OLD, I'm going back and checking alot of the originators of metal and punk(see. trying to recapture my youth) You seem to have Iron Maiden down to the wickets, could I trouble you for your choice for their best work. I'll use it for a starting point. If you don't mind that is. I also apologize for my not having gotten into them long ago. Times were hard and my mother loved Manilow...
 
Nov 28, 2007
10,686
0
0
My personal top ten (only ones in order are the first three):

1. Fear of the Dark
2. Aces High
3. Hallowed Be Thy Name
4. Killers
5. Wrathchild
6. Number of the Beast
7. Run to the Hills
8. Flight of the Icarus
9. Wasted Years
10. Two Minutes to Midnight

Honorable mentions: Phantom of the Opera, The Trooper
 

Danny Ocean

Master Archivist
Jun 28, 2008
4,148
0
0
Wow, nice review. Then again, with 5000 posts (5000 already? They grow up so fast *teary eyed*) I'd expect that level of literacy, very well done. I might go and listen to them now, just because of this review.

That's how good I think it is.

*+cookie to: thebobmaster*
 

DarkLordofDevon

New member
May 11, 2008
478
0
0
Good review of the Irons. I like it.

You never mentioned Blaze Bayley. He was no Bruce Dickenson, but he did do some good stuff. Futureal is pretty good and so is Lightning Strikes Twice. Its not up to Maiden's usual standard but its still pretty good for a Metal band. He did alright keeping Maiden ticking over until Dickenson's return.

Some of their albums are older than I am, and they're still going strong. I saw them at Twickenham about a month ago and they can still blow you away.

Maiden is eternal!
 
Nov 28, 2007
10,686
0
0
I'm not a fan of Blaze Bayley. To me, it's like ignoring the Dio period of Black Sabbath. Black Sabbath is Ozzy Osbourne, Iron Maiden is Paul and Bruce. And thanks for the universe. I now own you all.
 

Hippobatman

Resident Mario sprite
Jun 18, 2008
2,026
0
0
Great review. I must agree that I like Di'Anno's voice, almost prefer Di'Anno instead of Dickinson on "Iron Maiden", however, after Bruce's arrival, Maiden grew alot. Also I think it was wise of Maiden to let Di'Anno go, because of his drug and alcohol abuse. That's an image I really like about Maiden, they dont involve themselves with drugs.

I've seen Maiden twice now, and I must say, even though they're all above 50, I've never seen such an energic and enthusiastic performance, ever!

Once again, great review. Good to see that there are people who appreciate music at its best^^