BloatedGuppy said:
Ryotknife said:
Not sure how it was OP , ferals could do that for close to a decade and they were one of the most underpowered specs in pve and pvp, at least till the end of wotlk which is where i stopped.
That change alone destroys any and all desire i had to play my druid if i came back. And feral was my main spec.
Ferals were underpowered in Vanilla, overpowered at the beginning of BC
im guessing you are talking about the first few weeks? Ferals scaled well with levels, but scaled like crap with gear (which is the opposite of warriors who scale like crap with levels and become gods with gear). Even by the end of the first raid (karazhan, T4) ferals went from top dps spec to near the bottom before the nerfs went through. Feral dps became worthless by the beginning of T5 and their only niche in raiding was as an offtank (ie, tanks for a bit of the fight, then becomes a crappy dps). Even that niche became worthless by T6 and ferals ceased to exist.
The same thing happened in vanilla. Ferals were great, overpowered even, pre level 60, but once you hit the max level they were worthless in raids and a free kill to everyone in pvp.
In pvp, even in season 1 ferals were one of the worst specs. out of 12+ million players, there were around 5 feral gladiators. To this day i can still name 3 of them. Deep, Plato, Hafu. And i cant even remember the birthdays of my family.
and then over-nerfed, and then hilariously OP all throughout WOTLK. I played a feral exclusively during that expansion, and while I have a generally high opinion of my abilities I like to think I can admit when a class I'm playing is over-tuned. Being able to snap from MT to top 10 DPS in my raid without even changing spec or gear was over the top, never mind trying to balance around that in PvP.
Blizzard wants their tanking, healing and DPS fairly well delineated. I can see people complaining that this takes some of the character away from certain classes, because it does. But I understand the desire for it from a play balance perspective as well. It's one of those situations where no matter which way you go, a body of people are going to be unhappy.
Other than....Freya, i do not recall a single time when feral was considered overpowered in pve in wotlk (because they could dps the boss and aoe the crapton of adds without moving).
http://www.mmo-champion.com/threads/627228-Best-Tanking-Class-in-WotLK
Warrior - 44%
paladins - 35%
druids - 7%
dks - 12.55%
feral pve dps wasnt bad, but melee dps slots in wotlk were scarce and they were worse than their melee counterparts. Balance, although having worse dps, was more viable due to its utility and being ranged. Feral dps was the least viable pve role for druids.
http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/534914-/55886296
I mainly pve as feral in BC, and it was a lot of fun as an Off Tank/dps until we started tier 6 raids when I had to switch to a warlock. BC feral in pvp was the most fun ive ever had, despite the spec being poor in arenas (still a blast in bgs though). In Wotlk, my (and most of the guild's) ferals were sidelined for pve other than the very beginning of WotLK when rogues and warriors were terrible. Keep in mind, our guild leader was an avid feral himself, so its not like he hated ferals, but even he switched to a prot pally because they were better.
The problem i have with the separating the trees is that neither cat nor bear form was designed to be a standalone product. Each form is roughly 1/3 of the class, with roughly 1/3 of the abilities. Bear form will always be a pale imitation of warrior and cat form is a pale imitation of rogue. Which is fine if each form is merely one part of the spec/class. Feral was designed to be a jack of all trades. It would be like removing all of frost mages snares and slows, or affliction warlocks damage over time. It completely negates the reason that spec exists.
Then again, separating the tree is a less grievous offense than what they did to shapeshifting.
Ive played as many classes over the years in wow, but other than ret, feral is perhaps the one blizzard actively messed up the most. Everytime they try to make feral better, they make it significantly worse. It is sad that as a feral i was more fearful of "buffs" to my class than nerfs. At least enh shamans were in the state they were in through neglect.
Seriously, who thought that giving a spec designed around sticking to people and having a high sustained damage should be given burst?