Aardvaarkman said:
Gilhelmi said:
In the United States, the 2nd Amendment (of the constitution) gives us the right to own weapons. In the state I live in, we have the (state) constitutional right to always carry (assuming, of course, that you can pass your background checks and other legal requirements). Even in California, many people have conceal carry weapons permits. You might be surprised what is actually legal, if you look at the laws on the books.
One of the many problems America currently suffers from.
But still, this right doesn't transfer to private venues, does it? If the law requires private venues or residences to allow firearms, even if the owner doesn't want them there, then that's supremely fucked-up. Don't property owners also have rights over their property?
IF, the private venue puts up a "No-Gun" sign then it is illegal (for non-law enforcement) to carry there. BUT, few places bother with this, usually because they get complaints from customers. Even people who do not carry, still complain about the "Gun-free" signs, especially in my area (I mentioned earlier the state constitutional right, it passed with 90% of the vote in my state).
Sure, a business owner
can ban weapons, but they usually do not. Why ban weapons, when only law-abiding citizens are going to follow the law? Why ban weapons when so many people complain about the ban?
America also has a very rebellious streak in the common citizen, you might not see it in the media much, but many people do not trust the government. I do not mean the normal NSA wire tap rage that the media is covering right now. What I am talking about goes back a lot farther, back before our founding even. How do I say this without too sounding crazy? America was formed by overthrowing a tyrannical government. We are taught of our Abolitionist ancestors who fought against slavery and the former Black slaves who joined the Union Army to fight the Confederate rebels. American history is filled with fighting against a corrupt Government and evil people who oppressed us. So the 2nd Amendment is our guarantee that if the Government does need 'replacing' we would have the means to do so. I guess there is no way to say that without sounding crazy. I
do not want to overthrow the Government, most people do not want to either, we just want to keep the ability to out of fear that if we lose the right to bear arms then the Government will start to abuse its power.
I forget who said it but "The Second Amendment protects the First Amendment." That is very much the culture in a very large part of the United States.
I do not know where you are from, but the United States is HUGH. 300 million people in 50 states. The 50 states have very different cultures from one another, even if the population in is very diverse. There is no such thing as one America culture. This is the hardest part to explain, California is very different from Utah, and Utah is very different from Florida, who is different from Kansas. Every place you go is like another country, every state has its unique flavor to it. The people are even different in temperament. You do not see that in the national media much, they are mostly LA or New York in culture.
Imagine if you went from London to Paris, or any other city in the world. That is what it is like to travel through the United States.
I said all that so you know, I am only talking about parts of America when it comes to firearms. In some areas (like New York state or Colorado) they do not allow people to carry weapons (generally, there are rare exceptions), let alone shoot anyone even in self-defense (or they have extremely high standard to prove self-defense). BUT, in Oklahoma, for example, they allow to to shoot an intruder
in your home. If that person was not there legally, they forfeit their life essentially. 50 states, 51 laws (including federal, who are not suppose to interfere with state rights, but that is another lengthy discussion).
I knew a guy who was shot at by a group of people who did not like the fact that he was white and his wife was black. He took out the engine block of the racists car with one shot. The Sheriff investigated, ruled it justified, and congratulated my friend on the restraint he showed (the Sheriff said he would have shot the racists and did the world a favor). I love .50-cal pistols. Now, how would that story had played out in your country? How would it have played out in New York? How would it have played out in any number of states? 50 states, 50 ways it could have gone.
Sorry for the wall of text but, with the USA being a Democratic Republic, this type of thing gets complicated really FAST. I hope this helps you understand a bit more.