Ogoid said:
Silvanus said:
Just came to see whether that response had been posted. Whedon says it's "horseshit" that feminists chased him off Twitter.
Joss Whedon said:
"[...]Literally the second person to write me to ask if I was OK when I dropped out was [Feminist Frequency founder] Anita [Sarkeesian].?
With that in mind, the thread title is misleading.
That's nice of her.
I wonder if her co-writer and producer also extended his best wishes.
Oh. Guess that's probably a "no", then.
I don't really like the guy, he comes off as a smug critic that loves to stir controversy at the best of times, but you know what I didn't see in that compilation of Tweets: attacks against Joss Whedon himself, personal insults, or death threats.
The closest he got was calling out what he saw as a hypocrisy of the Age of Ultron in criticizing ultra-violence and then unabashedly reveling in it. None of that precludes him thinking that the death threats and personal insults leveled against Joss Whedon were not ok, or even supporting Mr. Whedon's efforts in movie making despite criticizing his movies.
I don't mean to pick at you, but really, I see no reason why, from what you've posted at least, McIntosh wouldn't support Mr. Whedon, this seems like a really weak assumption that because some crazy Twitter feminists ganged up on him, then the usual suspects the internet has a hate boner for must automatically approve of that behavior.
There used to be a poster on this board named Sleekit, I disagreed with nearly everything he said, and he came off as smug and hyperbolic at times, I criticized his posts on multiple occasions. However, that in no way meant that I hated him as a person, or wished for him to leave, be banned, or wishing for his death. Before he got perma-banned he posted some worrying things indicating that he was very depressed, despite my disagreements with him, I do genuinely hope that his banning here didn't cause him to self-harm, and if anyone did personally antagonize him, I would not support that sentiment just because I disagreed with his posts.
Basically, nothing you've posted gives me the impression that Jonathon McIntosh would approve of people telling Joss Whedon to kill himself, or that he should be forced out of making movies, or even just Avengers movies. Maybe he's posted something attacking Joss Whedon himself, I don't know, I don't follow the guys Twitter account, but nothing you've posted really leads me to think that the guy wouldn't still offer his sympathies for the crazier people out there telling Joss to kill himself or stop making movies. Being critical of an artist's work doesn't mean you hate the artist themselves, or even want them to stop making art.