Jordi said:
I hated this. Seriously, they were here on earth (in the ground) for thousands of years and they didn't notice this shit. Aliens that can come up with this kind of tech should be a little smarter than that in my opinion. Hell, even we (with our "can't even put a man on Mars" tech) can figure out that maybe we are not equipped to survive another planet's biosphere.
This one is just moronic. In the book, as far as I know, the aliens simply arrive from Mars and attack. That makes some sense, although you're left wondering why the martians didn't see it coming.
I haven't seen the movie, but if they were actually on Earth (studying us, from what I understand) for so long and didn't manage to grasp that something so basic as a disease could completely screw up their plan... Well, that simply makes no sense.
It's almost as if they wanted to change the beggining story to pass some kind of message but failed to notice that the original ending lost all sense.
Jordi said:
The only thing that was stupider in my opinion were the aliens from Signs. They were allergic to fucking water! And they decided to invade a planet that consists for like two thirds out of the stuff. Hell, they shouldn't even be able to walk around what with all of the water that is in the air at all times...
This one is just plain dumb.
"Hey guys! I have a brilliant idea: Let's invade a planet. The one with the frequent acid rain sounds nice."