Left 4 Dead 2 Ban Surprised, Saddened Valve

Recommended Videos

MercurySteam

Tastes Like Chicken!
Legacy
Apr 11, 2008
4,950
2
43
shadow moses said:
Wait, is the ESRB US only? I forget.
They're based in America but they also do Australian games.

I think us over here in Aussie should let the BBFC classify our games.
 

MercurySteam

Tastes Like Chicken!
Legacy
Apr 11, 2008
4,950
2
43
Can't they just give it an adults only rating and release it anyways. Though all games given an AO rating have been recalled and redone like the original San Andreas.
 

Zenode

New member
Jan 21, 2009
1,103
0
0
Here is my email i wrote to the OFLC, Hopefully i get a response, then i shall post that aswell

To Whom it may concern.

In the media today we have movies such as Saw and Hostel where people are brutally tortured and killed for entertainment yet attain ratings of MA 15+ , with extreme violence such as people being tortured in brutal manners such as drowing in pig entrails and cutting yourself in pain until you bleed to death. Saw 3 shows someone getting their throat cut by a bansaw yet this only attains an MA 15+ rating!

Why is it then that a video game developed for adults is being refused classification. Left 4 Dead 2 a video game based in the Southern United states of America has been deemed to violent so as such is not allowed to be sold within Australia.
I understand that their may be gore and violence within the video game, but this is common and has no effect on the population whatsoever.

"Limb Dismemberment" is cited as a reason why Left 4 Dead 2 is not being allowed in yet within Saw 1, an MA 15+ MOVIE people being held prisoner are forced to cut off their own limbs, how is it in a virtual world that is obviously not real any different? To many people having an actor in reality would be much more graphic and terrorizing to someone rather than a virtual zombie getting dismemberd.

Gamers in todays society are not all children they are out there but Gaming is not a medium that is targeted at children anymore it encompasses a large range of age groups not just young children. If this game was given an MA 15+ rating the parents of these young children should be looking at what their children are playing or watching. Instead of making a large amount of gamers Australia wide miserable.

Kind Regards
 

Arbitrary Cidin

New member
Apr 16, 2009
731
0
0
Didn't Yathzee, an Australian, purchase and review Gears of War 2? The game where you slice people in half with a chainsaw that's attached to a gun?
 

Therumancer

Citation Needed
Nov 28, 2007
9,909
0
0
Russian_Assassin said:
I would like to comment on something else, which is not so irrelevant. Ok, everyone says blood and gore are not suitable for people under 18. May I ask why? Do you know many 16 year olds who are pussies and have never seen blood or guts before? Do we really raise our children to be made of fragile glass, believing that the world is nothing but rainbows ponies and candy?

This really boggles my mind. Anyways, poor Ausies etc etc. You can still buy the game on steam you know, or did they ban internet too?
Groups like Steam, Google, Gamersgate, and similar things are just as castrated as the actual games industry. Rather than fighting for free speech and distribution they play along with the goverments by cooperating with censorship efforts. If the goverment in a given area doesn't want a game to be sold, these guys aren't going to thumb their noses and do everything they can to render the goverment as powerless as possible. Google is paticularly bad (look at what happened with China), but I also believe Steam has been playing by those "rules" as well.

-

Ratings are a touchy subject, in general PG-13 actually grants a lot of latitude for violence and sex. The whole bit about breast nudity being allowed in PG-13 movies has even been satirized in movies with characters saying "well I won't go all the way tonight, but how about a PG-13 moment" before flashing their breasts or whatever.

Now, the way how people are treating things today they act like gore and breast nudity are "R" rated material, which they are not.

With an "R" rating you can do anything in a movie legally EXCEPT show sexual penetration. Legally, the way things are SUPPOSED to work, there are no real limits unless someone files an obscenity suit (which is something all it's own). This even allows for full frontal nudity of both genders, simulated sex, and the most depraved and detailed violence imagiable.

The thing is that not all movies are designed to wallow in these things and the simple fact that you have to fight at times means that despite having the right Hollywood is gradually becoming more relaxed in how far ir pushes the envelope as long as the potential is there for when they want to.

In theory an "M" rating should be able to get away with anything an "R" rating goes, and at least in the US they can only push for an AO rating if sexual penetration is shown. At least this is how I learned things. However as things stand now the game industry has not fought for their rights to take things as far as they should.

There is also a tendency to over-rate things voluntarily. For example I've seen many movies that were no worse than a PG-13 in content, but carried an "R" rating probably so they could just release the movie quickly and nobody would bother to analyze everything given the latitude that allows.

Voluntarily requesting a higher rating that strictly needed I think has also scewed people's perceptions.

The point of this rant is that blood and gore in general AREN'T going to warp a 16 year old. Legally speaking they should be able to see giant piles of steaming guts anytime they want (actually seeing someone rip those steaming guts out of someone else in clear view is something else entirely though and goes 'R') Not is more or less clean violence (ie people being shot without any excessive violence or cruelty). They are allowed to see things like that, but honestly even with Hollywood's safely defined rights you just see less of an effort being made to give productions the smallest rating possible.

In part I suspect Hollywood cares less about the ratings than they used to is that the "in theater" viewership is increasingly less important than the rentals, digital viewership, and other things. They want a big audience, but are no longer as desperate to literally put as many butts as possible in seats as they can in the shortest period of time.
 

Flying Dagger

New member
Apr 14, 2009
1,344
0
0
Xanadu84 said:
...A Pacifist zombie game actually sounds really cool. Obviously not the zombies being pacifist, but imagine a game where you are outrunning a zombie hoard, boarding up windows, stealthing, hiding, environmental traps, supply hunting, and maybe making a few moral/story choices along the way. And without the reassuring gun or ax in your hand, the game would be scary as hell.
first person tactical experience, as you have to evade being dead ended...
though this sounds heavily like playing left4dead without any guns or special infected... would be a fun mod though.
 

feversk

Senior Member
Jul 20, 2009
111
0
21
I read the title and I went, "Australia again?" - seriously, what's up with that? First banning drugs in Fallout 3 (which was itself ridiculous) and now this? This is so ignorant of them I can't even talk about it seriously. It would be pointless.
 

Blackdoom

New member
Sep 11, 2008
518
0
0
Why did they have to ban one of the few games I was looking forward to?
The Australian Government is afraid of the whole violent gamer thing and are obviously trying there best to stop it but in turn they have caused more violence because I honestly feel like killing something now.

Oh well Steam should still have it.
 

AWC Viper

New member
Jun 12, 2008
1,288
0
0
goddammit i hate my country at time's like these. Stuff this im moving to (country where there is Fast internet and a R 18+ rating system)
 

SimuLord

Whom Gods Annoy
Aug 20, 2008
10,077
0
0
What's the moral of the story? I think it's "Americans, be on your guard, your legislators think the First Amendment doesn't apply to video game content and they would love to have Australia's nanny state censorship system."
 

Sketchy

New member
Aug 16, 2008
761
0
0
Look, don't get me wrong, I love Australia. I've lived there for 16 years, and don't plan to leave.

However, this has me saying: "FUCK YOU AUSTRALIA"

In full capitals.

Also,
Russian_Assassin said:
or did they ban internet too?
They tried/are trying. Or at least censor it. I think.
 

WhiteTiger225

New member
Aug 6, 2009
1,039
0
0
Every time a zombie doesn't die, a Valve employee cries.

Remember children, only YOU, can prevent mutant flesh virus!
 

WhiteTiger225

New member
Aug 6, 2009
1,039
0
0
AWC Viper said:
goddammit i hate my country at time's like these. Stuff this im moving to (country where there is Fast internet and a R 18+ rating system)
*Places a Baseball cap on your head and slaps a hotdog in your hand covered in sugary ketchup* Welcome to America!
 

AWC Viper

New member
Jun 12, 2008
1,288
0
0
WhiteTiger225 said:
AWC Viper said:
goddammit i hate my country at time's like these. Stuff this im moving to (country where there is Fast internet and a R 18+ rating system)
*Places a Baseball cap on your head and slaps a hotdog in your hand covered in sugary ketchup* Welcome to America!

Sweet! when do i get my gun?
 

WhiteTiger225

New member
Aug 6, 2009
1,039
0
0
AWC Viper said:
WhiteTiger225 said:
AWC Viper said:
goddammit i hate my country at time's like these. Stuff this im moving to (country where there is Fast internet and a R 18+ rating system)
*Places a Baseball cap on your head and slaps a hotdog in your hand covered in sugary ketchup* Welcome to America!

Sweet! when do i get my gun?
Once you sign up officially for citizenship. You also have to mandatorily go through a face where you love the latest pop icon for at least a month, but they don't always enforce that.
 

Infernai

New member
Apr 14, 2009
2,605
0
0
*facepalm* Australia's Office of Film and Literature Classification is officially the greatest enemy of gamers here down under (my god, i can't believe i just said the words 'down under'). And yes, im well aware that they are only doing there job and that the real blame is the whole lack of an R18+ Rating for games (I swear, the sooner we get that the better). I don't know where on earth im going with all this...but i guess i just wanted to say is that it just downright sucks that we aren't getting L4D2.
 

y1fella

New member
Jul 29, 2009
748
0
0
As an Australian i am really freaking pissed off! i WANT that game so much.. and will someone explain why they didn't ban the two condemned games which had the most brutal combat ever in a video game yet this game is banned?! the worst part is the ratings classification board is not a bunch of greedy bureaucrats but they think there doing the right thing when all they are doing is pissing off law abiding citizens! i seriously can't emphasize how incredibly pissed off i am!!!!!!!!
 

AWC Viper

New member
Jun 12, 2008
1,288
0
0
WhiteTiger225 said:
AWC Viper said:
WhiteTiger225 said:
AWC Viper said:
goddammit i hate my country at time's like these. Stuff this im moving to (country where there is Fast internet and a R 18+ rating system)
*Places a Baseball cap on your head and slaps a hotdog in your hand covered in sugary ketchup* Welcome to America!

Sweet! when do i get my gun?
Once you sign up officially for citizenship. You also have to mandatorily go through a face where you love the latest pop icon for at least a month, but they don't always enforce that.

well i cant do the pop icon thing but i could do the citizenship test. U.S.A here i come!