Left 4 Dead 2 Ban Surprised, Saddened Valve

Recommended Videos

Terramax

New member
Jan 11, 2008
3,747
0
0
Amnestic said:
Radeonx said:
How about, instead of zombies and guns, we use unicorns and pillows. Won't that be fun?
Maybe if Left 4 Dead 2 had more rainbows this wouldn't be an issue.



See? No one has an issue with Diablo 3's dark and eeevul themes. It's all down to the rainbows.
Dat iz freaking awesome! Do onez for Manhunt. Plz pretty plz?
 

Amnestic

High Priest of Haruhi
Aug 22, 2008
8,946
0
0
Terramax said:
Amnestic said:
Radeonx said:
How about, instead of zombies and guns, we use unicorns and pillows. Won't that be fun?
Maybe if Left 4 Dead 2 had more rainbows this wouldn't be an issue.

*image snip*

See? No one has an issue with Diablo 3's dark and eeevul themes. It's all down to the rainbows.
Dat iz freaking awesome! Do onez for Manhunt. Plz pretty plz?
Sadly it's not my own original work or I would be happy to oblige. My 'shop skills are severely lacking as well.
 

Treblaine

New member
Jul 25, 2008
8,682
0
0
Byers said:
Treblaine said:
Byers said:
You just have them classify the shipment as a gift. I do it all the time to get around the archaic toll fees that my government wants. And if they won't ship it to your country due to region issues, just get it from a private seller on ebay. There's really not much of a problem for adults to obtain anything, banned or otherwise, online.
That's good to know but it is only a matter of time before this loophole is closed.

And even if it is possible to get the game in Australia, sales will inevitably be much lower than they could be as it is hardly common knowledge how to get past this ban. There just won't be as many L4D2 players from Australia as there could have been.
Err, no. This is not some kind of loophole that will be closed. If people weren't allowed to send each other gifts without the authorities opening your mail for no apparent reason, that would raise all kinds of moral questions, and you'd basically be living in a police state. They only open shipments if they have reasonable suspicions the contents is illegal in nature or something. I've been shopping this way through the internet for, christ, nearly 15 years, with no problems.

Of course it will impede the sales of the games in that region, since it's not gonna be something you can just go to the supermarket and buy. But if you want it enough, you can get it. You'll have to play with people in a different region than you, but I don't think Left for Dead is too strict about regions. Whenever I play the first one, I encounter people from all over the world.
You think the only way the Authorities could detect this transaction is by physically catch it and open it as it is being delivered?


Err, no. The Australian authorities would not even have to bother with opening a package or even looking at any package at all. The only thing they have to do is serve Amazon or any online retailer with a court order demanding they make available their record keeping of all their sales of certain products to Australia. There are international laws in place for this, every transaction MUST be recorded and Australia has the authority to scrutinies those details with an easy to obtain court order.

That would also extend to gifts and it would not take long to figure out if people are merely buying gifts for them self and it would not take much to make the case in court that these were de-facto sales of un-rated games in Australia = illegal, even if utter bullshit.

If Amazon dicks around or tries to hide information then Australia has every right to block ALL internet access to that online retailer and will likely lead to lawsuits or even criminal prosecution if they try to "obstruct justice".

You just have to face the facts that the only real solution is to change the practices of the Australian Censors, particularly allowing an 18+ rating as there is literally (and I mean literally) zero reason at all for Australia to lack consideration of gamers that are 18 years or older.
 

JWAN

New member
Dec 27, 2008
2,725
0
0
SultanP said:
incinerate94 said:
USA lets us have everthing we want here. The only things that are fucked are some of the ideas we get for movies
Yeah, but you guys have sometimes gotten wimpy releases of games. I can't give any specific examples, I've been using my memory for other things lately. But I do remember that you guys have sometimes gotten game versions where the violence is toned down, or where some game mechanics have been swapped out with something less graphic, causing people from the USA to get a hold of a European copy so they won't miss out

So yeah, you get to do what you want, just not how you want it, and not without a bunch of people howling about how immoral everything it, or wanting people to tone stuff down so children's parents won't be offended.

JWAN said:
Where the heck do you think the worlds largest entertainment industry is located?
The USA, but I'd like to refer to my point above.
We can order anything we like using a tool called the "Internet" and with that is something called "Ebay". Its powered by magic.
 

JWAN

New member
Dec 27, 2008
2,725
0
0
CosmicCommander said:
Yahtzee is probably gonnna blow a casket over this...
Gasket (Blow a gasket) a casket is a box where you put dead people, a gasket is something that seals tubing in between lengths to prevent high pressure from escaping.
 

SultanP

New member
Mar 15, 2009
985
0
0
JWAN said:
SultanP said:
incinerate94 said:
USA lets us have everthing we want here. The only things that are fucked are some of the ideas we get for movies
Yeah, but you guys have sometimes gotten wimpy releases of games. I can't give any specific examples, I've been using my memory for other things lately. But I do remember that you guys have sometimes gotten game versions where the violence is toned down, or where some game mechanics have been swapped out with something less graphic, causing people from the USA to get a hold of a European copy so they won't miss out

So yeah, you get to do what you want, just not how you want it, and not without a bunch of people howling about how immoral everything it, or wanting people to tone stuff down so children's parents won't be offended.

JWAN said:
Where the heck do you think the worlds largest entertainment industry is located?
The USA, but I'd like to refer to my point above.
We can order anything we like using a tool called the "Internet" and with that is something called "Ebay". Its powered by magic.
So what was your point about where the largest entertainment industry is? And there was no reason to be an ass. I stand by what I said, I'm happy that I don't live in a country where I'll have to buy things on the internet in order to circumvent the censuring of things such as computer games.
 

Byers

New member
Nov 21, 2008
229
0
0
Treblaine said:
Byers said:
Treblaine said:
Byers said:
You just have them classify the shipment as a gift. I do it all the time to get around the archaic toll fees that my government wants. And if they won't ship it to your country due to region issues, just get it from a private seller on ebay. There's really not much of a problem for adults to obtain anything, banned or otherwise, online.
That's good to know but it is only a matter of time before this loophole is closed.

And even if it is possible to get the game in Australia, sales will inevitably be much lower than they could be as it is hardly common knowledge how to get past this ban. There just won't be as many L4D2 players from Australia as there could have been.
Err, no. This is not some kind of loophole that will be closed. If people weren't allowed to send each other gifts without the authorities opening your mail for no apparent reason, that would raise all kinds of moral questions, and you'd basically be living in a police state. They only open shipments if they have reasonable suspicions the contents is illegal in nature or something. I've been shopping this way through the internet for, christ, nearly 15 years, with no problems.

Of course it will impede the sales of the games in that region, since it's not gonna be something you can just go to the supermarket and buy. But if you want it enough, you can get it. You'll have to play with people in a different region than you, but I don't think Left for Dead is too strict about regions. Whenever I play the first one, I encounter people from all over the world.
You think the only way the Authorities could detect this transaction is by physically catch it and open it as it is being delivered?


Err, no. The Australian authorities would not even have to bother with opening a package or even looking at any package at all. The only thing they have to do is serve Amazon or any online retailer with a court order demanding they make available their record keeping of all their sales of certain products to Australia. There are international laws in place for this, every transaction MUST be recorded and Australia has the authority to scrutinies those details with an easy to obtain court order.

That would also extend to gifts and it would not take long to figure out if people are merely buying gifts for them self and it would not take much to make the case in court that these were de-facto sales of un-rated games in Australia = illegal, even if utter bullshit.

If Amazon dicks around or tries to hide information then Australia has every right to block ALL internet access to that online retailer and will likely lead to lawsuits or even criminal prosecution if they try to "obstruct justice".

You just have to face the facts that the only real solution is to change the practices of the Australian Censors, particularly allowing an 18+ rating as there is literally (and I mean literally) zero reason at all for Australia to lack consideration of gamers that are 18 years or older.
Like I already said. If it turns out to be region restrictions imposed on the bigger outlets, like Amazon, all you have to do is to buy it from a smaller online based store or an Ebay seller.

There are thousands upon thousands of tiny privately run stores found anywhere online, from amazon marketplaces and ebay to countless other smaller sites I won't mention here. Most of which are blissfully unaware of restrictions pertaining to specific merchandise and countries, or couldn't give a rat's ass about it as long as they'll net a profit selling it, since the risk of someone actually being able to prove they've knowingly mislabeled something (or knowingly sold something that's under some kind of arbitrary ban in that specific region) when you're sending it privately as a gift, is light years beyond microscopic.
 

NewGeekPhilosopher

New member
Feb 25, 2009
892
0
0
kawligia said:
People keep saying "doesn't Australia know there are gamers over 18?"

I am more than sure they do. I think it's clear what is really going on. They don't like sex and violence and they don't want ANYONE to see it. "Protecting the children" is nothing more than a disguise.

If T.V. and movies were as new as video games, I would bet all the money I have that they would make an identical rating system. But people are used to TV and movies already. Not allowing people to have something new is much easier than taking away something they already have.
Actually the film Not Quite Hollywood explains that at one point we had no R rating for movies, so there was a massive change in the 1970s where the Australian film industry got an R rating and such classics such as Mad Max and Alvin Purple got made.

That movie reminds me of what's happening NOW in Australia with video games. There was one guy blocking an R rating for movies too, and once we got rid of him, a revival of local film industry took place that hasn't been seen since because of tax issues in the film industry funding here. If you want to learn more about Australian controversies/culture, watch that.
 

Zyxzy

New member
Apr 16, 2009
343
0
0
And yet another game falls victim to the Australian government's ridiculous video game mentality.
 

Pyro Paul

New member
Dec 7, 2007
842
0
0
couple of questions and inconsistances.

"Does Austraila not have +18 rating?"

No. Australias rating system only goes to +15 MA. any rating which is beyond that is not given a rating and thus can not be sold with in the Aulstralian boarders.


"we can side step it with Steam/import/Pirate/Ebay"

No, you can't. Steam games sell Localized based on your IP address. Regardless of how ever which way you get it, it will see that your IP address is incompatable and not allow you to play the game.

this is acctually seen in L4D sold in germany which has its gore and blood content toned down (or rather turned off) even if you where to import the game from the UK, because Steam sees you as 'in germany' it will automatically (and forcably) set the game to 'toned down mode' which can not be changed.


"australia is stupid and backwords!"

Sorta. the current problem with Australian games is that they don't have the proper rating systems to falicitate a game directed AT adults which is where games are currently heading. although the AO rating is in the US is as good as a Ban as most retailers won't carry it, It is still there which allows games to be Sold with an AO rating.
 

Russian_Assassin

New member
Apr 24, 2008
1,849
0
0
I would like to comment on something else, which is not so irrelevant. Ok, everyone says blood and gore are not suitable for people under 18. May I ask why? Do you know many 16 year olds who are pussies and have never seen blood or guts before? Do we really raise our children to be made of fragile glass, believing that the world is nothing but rainbows ponies and candy?

This really boggles my mind. Anyways, poor Ausies etc etc. You can still buy the game on steam you know, or did they ban internet too?
 

saphiren

Full diving
Jul 8, 2009
68
0
0
I would wonder what Yahtzee has to say about this, but then I recall how he didn't particularly care for it and wonder if there's anyone on here from Australia who could maybe flame the ESRB to a well-toasted crisp.

Wait, is the ESRB US only? I forget.
 

bushwhacker2k

New member
Jan 27, 2009
1,587
0
0
Destal said:
I fail to understand why all games must be suitable for under 18, I thought that was the reason for the rating system.

Pacifist Zombie invasion? I'll keep mine the old fashoned way.
Yeah, if they clearly state it's not okay for under-18s then shouldn't they just slap on an M and move on? I'm confused.

But they allowed Left4Dead 1, right? Is there that much of a difference? Sounds like someone in charge is a fucktard.
 

Flos

New member
Aug 2, 2008
504
0
0
bushwhacker2k said:
Destal said:
I fail to understand why all games must be suitable for under 18, I thought that was the reason for the rating system.

Pacifist Zombie invasion? I'll keep mine the old fashoned way.
Yeah, if they clearly state it's not okay for under-18s then shouldn't they just slap on an M and move on? I'm confused.

But they allowed Left4Dead 1, right? Is there that much of a difference? Sounds like someone in charge is a fucktard.
Don't say that! They'll ban L4D1 and then you'll have an entire continent on you!
 

Destal

New member
Jul 8, 2009
522
0
0
bushwhacker2k said:
Destal said:
I fail to understand why all games must be suitable for under 18, I thought that was the reason for the rating system.

Pacifist Zombie invasion? I'll keep mine the old fashoned way.
Yeah, if they clearly state it's not okay for under-18s then shouldn't they just slap on an M and move on? I'm confused.

But they allowed Left4Dead 1, right? Is there that much of a difference? Sounds like someone in charge is a fucktard.
From what I understand it's due to the including of melee weapons that was the big no no.