Heh, that was my thought.lizards said:see if guns were legal there wouldnt be that problem....
When would the police have told him this? When he showed up with the gun? It was already too late thenbladester1 said:That is bull shit. The police should have told him that if he would bring in the gun he would get thrown in jail and that he needs to tell them where the gun is so they can go and pick it up...
Fail troll is fail...Krythe said:Take a good hard look, my fellow Americans... This is what Obama's leading us towards...
The point is that he PHONED IN to say he was going to do it. If it was a crime they should have told him there and then, instead of letting him get right there and get arrested.danpascooch said:When would the police have told him this? When he showed up with the gun? It was already too late thenbladester1 said:That is bull shit. The police should have told him that if he would bring in the gun he would get thrown in jail and that he needs to tell them where the gun is so they can go and pick it up...
The guy was pretty stupid, He should have known he cannot just carry around a shotgun because he found it and is turning it in, Criminals could carry around guns all the time, and if caught say "I found this yesterday and was just turning it in!" That would completely ruin the whole system of gun licenses and permits. what he should have done, was call 911 (UK equivalent), tell them where it was, and then stayed there to make sure nobody else picked it up.
That said, it would be nice if he could be let off the hook, after all his intentions were pure, but that said, we can't bend the whole legal system for one guy who did a foolish thing with pure intentions. He did turn it into the police after all, but for all they know, he found this gun, kept it for two years without any sort of permit, then got afraid and turned it in.
Both.Mazty said:Are these cases though of people successfully suing or just dicks wasting court time?BaldursBananaSoap said:Oh well , this thread has now turned into a "Bash the UK legal system," thread.
Do I need to bring out the American stories?
How about the woman who drank too much water when she joined a competition then died? The family won thousands of dollars even though the health risks were displayed clearly.
How about the recent kid who shot himself at a gun show, with a gun given to him by a fifteen year old who worked there?
How about the Judge Roy Pearson who launched a lunatic legal siege on a dry cleaners over a lost pair of pants?
How about the Professor Priya Venkatesan? She hired lawyers to sue members of the class, claiming the way they kept complaining about her inability to teach constituted a "hostile work environment." She also sued her superiors.
How about New York State Supreme Court Justice Jack Battaglia who slipped on a mopped floor and fractured his knee. As a respected member of the community and a seasoned legal professional, he sued the city for 1 million.
Wait, there's more. He also sued the janitor. Yes, a $136,000-a-year judge looking to collect from the lady who literally cleans up after him ... because she got the floor wet while mopping it.
How about The Musical, lawyer Arelia Taveras gambled with client money. In an unsurprising twist, she lost it.
In fact she lost over a million dollars, her legal practice, her home, her parents' home and claims she even tried to kill herself, so she clearly lost at that too.
Of course, none of it is her fault, which is why she sued seven major Atlantic City casinos for a $20 million jackpot because she's addicted to gambling.
You see? They're both completely fucked.
Both but then none of these are good samaratin situations like turning in a device to people who wouldn't use it to rob you.Mazty said:Are these cases though of people successfully suing or just dicks wasting court time?BaldursBananaSoap said:Oh well , this thread has now turned into a "Bash the UK legal system," thread.
Do I need to bring out the American stories?
How about the woman who drank too much water when she joined a competition then died? The family won thousands of dollars even though the health risks were displayed clearly.
How about the recent kid who shot himself at a gun show, with a gun given to him by a fifteen year old who worked there?
How about the Judge Roy Pearson who launched a lunatic legal siege on a dry cleaners over a lost pair of pants?
How about the Professor Priya Venkatesan? She hired lawyers to sue members of the class, claiming the way they kept complaining about her inability to teach constituted a "hostile work environment." She also sued her superiors.
How about New York State Supreme Court Justice Jack Battaglia who slipped on a mopped floor and fractured his knee. As a respected member of the community and a seasoned legal professional, he sued the city for 1 million.
Wait, there's more. He also sued the janitor. Yes, a $136,000-a-year judge looking to collect from the lady who literally cleans up after him ... because she got the floor wet while mopping it.
How about The Musical, lawyer Arelia Taveras gambled with client money. In an unsurprising twist, she lost it.
In fact she lost over a million dollars, her legal practice, her home, her parents' home and claims she even tried to kill herself, so she clearly lost at that too.
Of course, none of it is her fault, which is why she sued seven major Atlantic City casinos for a $20 million jackpot because she's addicted to gambling.
You see? They're both completely fucked.
When would the police have told him this? When he showed up with the gun? It was already too late thenbladester1 said:That is bull shit. The police should have told him that if he would bring in the gun he would get thrown in jail and that he needs to tell them where the gun is so they can go and pick it up...
It doesn't really matter, when he called the police, he ALREADY grabbed the gun, so he had already committed the crime, if we let people go because they phoned the police saying they had a gun they found, my earlier arguments apply, it would destroy the permit systemBillNyeTheColonelGuy said:The point is that he PHONED IN to say he was going to do it. If it was a crime they should have told him there and then, instead of letting him get right there and get arrested.danpascooch said:When would the police have told him this? When he showed up with the gun? It was already too late thenbladester1 said:That is bull shit. The police should have told him that if he would bring in the gun he would get thrown in jail and that he needs to tell them where the gun is so they can go and pick it up...
The guy was pretty stupid, He should have known he cannot just carry around a shotgun because he found it and is turning it in, Criminals could carry around guns all the time, and if caught say "I found this yesterday and was just turning it in!" That would completely ruin the whole system of gun licenses and permits. what he should have done, was call 911 (UK equivalent), tell them where it was, and then stayed there to make sure nobody else picked it up.
That said, it would be nice if he could be let off the hook, after all his intentions were pure, but that said, we can't bend the whole legal system for one guy who did a foolish thing with pure intentions. He did turn it into the police after all, but for all they know, he found this gun, kept it for two years without any sort of permit, then got afraid and turned it in.
It's like gunning down people who surrender in war.