This shall be my closing statement on this matter. I personally think it is much more believable that Ashley/Kaidan was overwhelmed at the emotional trauma of having survived a Collector attack and seeing Shepard just suddenly return into their lives now working for the arch enemy of the alliance after believing him/her to be dead. Like I said before, the ability to perfectly straighten out ones thoughts after that is a little bit hard to do given the circumstances and I believe that emotional reaction is a better explanation than indoctrination.blindthrall said:I give the Collectors more credit than having to painstakingly load every colonist one by one before their crappy poison wears off. They certainly aren't in a hurry in the footage from Freedom's Progress. The marine unfreezing on their own makes sense, as Kaiden would know exactly what they did to him, and all Alliance marines have a modest degree of gengineering. But remember about indroctination: it's a slow process, and the best forms of it convince you your actions hurt the Reapers. Benezia from the first game started out as a mole trying to bring Saren down from the inside, and by the time she realized she'd been played it was too late.
Also as I said before both Ashley and Kaidan's emails apologise for their actions and not only express an understanding of why Shepard is working with Cerberus (albeit still a grudging understanding) but also a desire for Shepard to defeat the Collectors and defeat the Reapers as well as the possibility to be together once more.
The fact is, Cerberus is evil and distrusting them is a perfectly valid reaction considering the Alliance and Cerberus history. Granted it is crazy to think that Cerberus is working with the Collectors but again expecting someone to just change their entire perception of the world in three minutes worth of conversation is simply put, ridiculous.
Besides, considering the Illusive Man's interest in Reaper technology and the way he evily smiles if you save the Collector station or the fact that 'The Reapers are your salvation, human' or something to that extent is said by Harbinger or even the fact that the Illusive Man was clearly more interested in that base then he was in saving humans I wouldn't put past the idea that Cerberus, an organisation only really interested in saving humanity if it is in their best interests, might have some long term goal involving the Reapers.
Finally as I said before, Bioware pretty much said that staying faithful to the ME1 LI (god that looks like a licence plate number) will be met with a good ending in Mass Effect 3. I doubt Bioware would piss off a lot of people just so that they could give some kind of explanation to a plothole which I doubt people were really supposed to notice all that much.
Besides any form of indoctrination requires Reaper technology. The Seeker Swarms can only paralyse people for the Collectors to take away and when they take them away they then dissolve them into mush. I doubt they'd make any kind of exception to this rule. Plus it was noted that the process is subtle but that you have to BE exessivley exposed to the effect of Sovereign or indeed any Reaper tech to feel the effects.
Still it was an interesting thought and I certainly don't mean any offence I just personally think there is WAY too much evidence to the contrary both in character, plot and indeed Bioware's need to please the fans, for this to be the case.
But still, thanks for a good conversation and I can certainly see some of your points but I just doubt it somewhat.