Mass Effect: ?Traveling makes a man wiser, but less happy.?

Recommended Videos

mjhhiv

New member
Jun 22, 2008
758
0
0
The quote is by Jefferson. He wrote it with the intention of one day it being applied to Mass Effect.

Well... maybe not - but it certainly works magnificently in this scenario.

Mass Effect is Galactic exploration for your average console ?tard. BioWare doesn?t give you a single city to explore; and can rightfully laugh in the face of the scope in GTA 4. BioWare doesn?t give you a country to explore, and can point and laugh at Oblivion. BioWare gives you the entire Milky Way Galaxy.

Apparently, that?s pretty big.

[IMG_inline align="left" height="250" width="250" caption="Just one of the planets in one of the nebulas in one of the galaxies in the universe of Mass Effect."]http://xbox360media.ign.com/xbox360/image/article/834/834650/mass-effect-20071112085806632-000.jpg[/IMG_inline]

Hyped not only for being an incredibly deep and open world RPG but also a shooter, I was ready to have my definition of the genres totally smashed. That was certainly wishful thinking? Mass Effect doesn?t combine the genres like I expected. It?s both genres together, but not intertwined. It leans on neither RPG nor shooter too much, which can be both a complaint and something for which the game can be commended. I tend to view it as a complaint, simply because of how ?meh? the shooting was.

Being fair, the shooting was certainly not ?meh? for an RPG. In fact, it exceeds what would have been my expectations for combat, had it not hyped itself up as a shooter. If Mass Effect were just another linear shooter, with no RPG elements it wouldn?t be awful, I guess. It would be one of the ?Dark Sectors? of the world ? an average TPS that would be fine for a rental, nothing more.

With that little disclaimer tucked away, let?s move along with Mass Effect.

Essentially, there are 4 types of guns - the sniper, the pistol, the assault rifle, and the good ol? shotty. You can also get the abilities to use ?mysterious powers? to pick people up, blow them backwards, and so on. These ?mysterious powers? sound really, really sweet in theory, but in the game you are required to use a true-pause to select them, and then aren?t allowed to actually inflict the powers? affects ? rather, the computer does it and you watch some cool rag-doll afterwards. This really holds back these powers from distinguishing Mass Effect?s combat, and were a bit disappointing in my opinion.

Back to the usual arsenal - The shotgun is probably the most efficient weapon of those four weapons, and I found myself leaning on it for most of my two play-throughs. You can get all sorts of goodies for your guns, and pimp them out to be as effective as you want by the end of the game. There isn?t any ammo for any of the weapons, which was scrapped in favor of an ?overheating system.? If you fire too many shots at once, your weapon overheats and you must wait for it to cool down before you can use it again.

[IMG_inline align="right" height="250" width="250"]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v22/yogurt_fog/mass_effect_1.jpg[/IMG_inline]

I liked the overheating system ? it works well combined with the RPG factors of the game. The rest of the shooting, however, does not work well with RPG elements.

?Immersion? is key for many a game. Games like BioShock, Half-Life, and others don?t even display true cut-scenes because they want you to feel as if you are the character, rather than if you were playing as him. Now, this doesn?t directly correspond to the shooting in Mass Effect, but it suffices as an example of immersion. RPG?s tend to use a different kind of immersion to keep you playing, with complex leveling systems and a wide variety of items to find. Mass Effect has both of those, but still, the shooting was much more controlled by you, the player, rather than what your level was or what gun you were using.

In a struggle to please both shooter and RPG fans, they frustrated both with the combat.

They did not, however, miff both groups of fans in the way the setting was handled.

Now, being your average Earth dwelling non-astrophysicist, I know relatively little of space ? actually, all humans know little of space, not just us under-achievers. Mass Effect preys on the curiosity in all humans, the curiosity to know what lies beyond our own knowledge.

Everything is polished to a shine, to appease our ever-growing curiosity of what lies beyond. There are so many planets in so many solar systems in so many galaxies, it gets to the point where you, even if you search everywhere, will probably miss one of the planets you might have gotten to explore ? which isn?t a complaint at all. Every planet has been given a population, points of interest, people to meet, places to see, etc.

I guess that I do have to point out that the planets can get very repetitive in terms of design, and that you can only visit (usually) one planet in every solar system.

The second mini-complaint isn?t that big of a deal, considering how many solar systems there are, but the first is a legitimate party-pooper. You have your snowy planets, the tropical ones, and so on ? but with so many planets to design, Bioware must have just run out of landscape ideas.

[IMG_inline align="left" height="250" width="250" caption="Sheppard and his team exploring Mars, or one of the numerous other red planets in the game."]http://images.eurogamer.net/assets/articles/a/6/1/1/5/6/masseffect_03_745x440.jpg[/IMG_inline]

Sooner or later, hopefully right about now, you?re going to wonder why my title seems so negative, while most all I?ve said about the game has been positive.

The title is indicative of the grind that the game induces on the player. I shouldn?t have expected it to not have grind, it is an RPG after all, but the game sets itself up for such criticism ? in a good way.

All right, I?ll try to start making sense now that I?ve had my fun.

If you stick to the ?linear? main plot of Mass Effect, you?ll miss out on most everything the game has to offer, but will find yourself still satisfied with the interesting storytelling and decent shooting. If you decide you want to venture away from the main plot, an entire galaxy is waiting to greet you complete with an outrageous number of side-quests.

I?m someone who likes to complete games all the way through, so completing Mass Effect definitely tested my? boredom skills.

A lot of the side-quests involve backtracking or finding a specific object. Backtracking + retrieving objects = falling asleep at the controller and?

Who am I kidding? The main story is just so great that it makes up for whatever I don?t like about the grind.

If you didn?t already know, you play Commander Sheppard ? a ?spectre? charged with one simple task ? protecting the galaxy. It?s not necessarily the overlying plot itself that captures my heart, but the ways in which you can completely customize the story to make, what would be an average sci-fi thriller, your own. Everything that Sheppard says can be changed or altered in some way, to make him say exactly what you want him to say.

[IMG_inline align="right" height="300" width="300"]http://i.cdn.turner.com/gametap/web30/eMagazine/emag_masseffect_x360_080607_1_44c40.jpg[/IMG_inline]

With its branching dialogue options, different ways to handle every scenario, and multiple endings, the Mass Effect ?story? is fantastic.

As you?ve gathered by now, Mass Effect is a big game - big in size, big in number of side-quests, and big in different ways to play the game. Big games usually get cut breaks when being graded on ?number of bugs? and ?graphical hic-ups?, and Mass Effect needs all the technical breaks in the world.

Now, to clarify, Mass Effect doesn?t get cut a break in the same way that some open-world games do. Some of the bigger games just don?t look very appealing? This is definitely not the case in Mass Effect.

The game looks fantastic for being so darn big. Distances look amazing, textures are sharp, the world is very detailed in populated areas, and lighting is used very well. The only complaints one could have with the presentation are in the frame-rate and loading time issues, because the sound is just as good as the look of the game.

With so, so many lines of text, I?d hate to have to count how many voice actors BioWare had to hire to keep things fresh ? and these aren?t just run-of-the-mill voice actors, either. This is an all-star cast, highlighted by such talent as Seth Green.

Now, about those pesky little bugs?

Mass Effect doesn?t have one or two little bugs ? this is a full-blown infestation.

And not just flies ? termites, too. Yup, you?re gonna have some serious structural damage...

[IMG_inline align="left" height="250" width="250" caption="Yup. I found him in the manual - the one place he thought he'd be safe..."]http://lamar.colostate.edu/~secarney/AntCourse/133-BIG_Bug.jpg[/IMG_inline]

?

Oh, sorry. Lost my train of thought.

Anyways, it?s a shame that Mass Effect has so many glitches. It?s the only clear-cut flaw in an otherwise brilliant game. I hate to be ?that guy?, but glitches really dampen the experience for me. Even one bug, and I begin to contemplate ?boycotting? the game. I?m not going to say that Mass Effect has the most bugs of this generation (STALKER, despite its awesomeness, wins that dubious honor), but it is pretty close to the top of the list ? really bringing down what I would score it.

Ya? know - if I was actually going to score it.

The XBox 360 has some very nice exclusive games, like Halo, Dead Rising, and Gears of War to name a few. Most of these exclusives are violence heavy, slugfests with no real thinking needed to get by in the game, yet still, bugs and all, Mass Effect manages to rise to the top. Mass Effect is the clear-cut best RPG for the XBox 360, if not the XBox 360?s very best offering and is the must-buy for any RPG fan or any person, for that matter.

If you don?t have it, get it.

Now.

Run.

Run to your local game store.

Or you could order online.

I don?t care.

Just get it.

Now.

Stop reading this drab and go get Mass Effect!
 

Random Argument Man

New member
May 21, 2008
6,011
0
0
It's Shepard, not Sheppard.

Good review. I got bored with Mass effect after a while. It had a corny story and they should had replaced the Alliance with the USA. It would fit the mentality of the Alliance. Yes, I said it. It had an american feeling to it. I didn't like the ending. (Except the elevator part, who woudn't like that?)
 

Fineldar

New member
Jun 8, 2008
214
0
0
I don't know why you're demanding us to go get it if it had those, not so tiny things you didn't like about it. I liked the review and I have about the same opinion, except that you need to go buy it. You could just watch someone play and have the same experience. That can be even better, you can skip the boring buts and loo at porn while they player is doing the "Progress Quest" stuff.
 

mjhhiv

New member
Jun 22, 2008
758
0
0
Fineldar post=326.73846.812080 said:
I don't know why you're demanding us to go get it if it had those, not so tiny things you didn't like about it. I liked the review and I have about the same opinion, except that you need to go buy it. You could just watch someone play and have the same experience. That can be even better, you can skip the boring buts and loo at porn while they player is doing the "Progress Quest" stuff.
Thanks for the compliment, but I'm failing to understand you.

Every game has its flaws, even the ones that are worth getting. Weird how that works.
 

Spartan Bannana

New member
Apr 27, 2008
3,032
0
0
Random argument man post=326.73846.812058 said:
It's Shepard, not Sheppard.

Good review. I got bored with Mass effect after a while. It had a corny story and they should had replaced the Alliance with the USA. It would fit the mentality of the Alliance. Yes, I said it. It had an american feeling to it. I didn't like the ending. (Except the elevator part, who woudn't like that?)
Woahwoahwoahwoahwoahwowahwowhaawhwoawhwhwhw...woah....woah.............woah...............................woah.

You thought Mass Effect had a corny story? I thought it rivaled Star Wars.

Nice Review, I didn't agree with everything you said, specifically the thing about it not intertwining the genres, I felt it did that well.
 

Fineldar

New member
Jun 8, 2008
214
0
0
It was a partial misread of what you said, and letting my view that any game that tests your boredom skills for more than a little bit doesn't mean you should run out of reading it, flow into yours. But that's just because I'm better than everyone and sometimes I forget that I have to remeber you peasants don't think the way I do.

Editz0r: Or my fabulous sentence structure.
 

WolfLordAndy

New member
Sep 19, 2008
776
0
0
I found Mass-Effect enjoyable, and as a bit of a bookworm/knowledge freak, every time my book of knowledge glowed I had to dive in and read every last tid-bit. My one major frustraction were the sand/ice worms. The combat with those was just... harsh. I won't say much more in case of spoilers, but I'm sure people who have played know what I mean.

I only got about 10% of the way through at uni on my friend's 360, so considering getting it through steam for PC. But so many games, so few hours.
 

Random Argument Man

New member
May 21, 2008
6,011
0
0
Spartan Bannana post=326.73846.812107 said:
Random argument man post=326.73846.812058 said:
It's Shepard, not Sheppard.

Good review. I got bored with Mass effect after a while. It had a corny story and they should had replaced the Alliance with the USA. It would fit the mentality of the Alliance. Yes, I said it. It had an american feeling to it. I didn't like the ending. (Except the elevator part, who woudn't like that?)
Woahwoahwoahwoahwoahwowahwowhaawhwoawhwhwhw...woah....woah.............woah...............................woah.

You thought Mass Effect had a corny story? I thought it rivaled Star Wars.

Nice Review, I didn't agree with everything you said, specifically the thing about it not intertwining the genres, I felt it did that well.
It was a mix of Star Wars+ The Matrix + American War Movies. Think about it.
 

Dapper Ninja

New member
Aug 13, 2008
778
0
0
Your review was good, but I don't have the same opinion that you and seemingly most people have toward this game. I thought the story was dull, the combat was poor, and it didn't feel like any of my choices made any difference (The morality system didn't seem to affect the game in the slightest).
 

Spartan Bannana

New member
Apr 27, 2008
3,032
0
0
Random argument man post=326.73846.812128 said:
Spartan Bannana post=326.73846.812107 said:
Random argument man post=326.73846.812058 said:
It's Shepard, not Sheppard.

Good review. I got bored with Mass effect after a while. It had a corny story and they should had replaced the Alliance with the USA. It would fit the mentality of the Alliance. Yes, I said it. It had an american feeling to it. I didn't like the ending. (Except the elevator part, who woudn't like that?)
Woahwoahwoahwoahwoahwowahwowhaawhwoawhwhwhw...woah....woah.............woah...............................woah.

You thought Mass Effect had a corny story? I thought it rivaled Star Wars.

Nice Review, I didn't agree with everything you said, specifically the thing about it not intertwining the genres, I felt it did that well.
It was a mix of Star Wars+ The Matrix + American War Movies. Think about it.
Seems like a good combination to me, only some American War movies are corny and the rest aren't
 

Typecast

New member
Jul 27, 2008
227
0
0
Mass effect wins for having Geth that stick to walls and crabwalk with their bellies to the floor.
Mass effect fails for not having enough Geth to shoot.
Driving sections got boring.
Story was clean; as in not original at all, but someone had given the cliches a few normal and specular maps.
I have it for PC, and I like the little hacking minigame, it adds to the twitch reflexes.
Shooting was good, but you are absolutely right; if you're not using the shotgun you're doing it wrong(unless in the extremely rare cases where you're at a range where the shotgun is ineffective).
I think the levels could have been more open and challenging, for example I liked that bit where you're on the broken highway suspended between skyscrapers.
For something that was supposed to deliver 'big' it certain had that postage stamp level feel of KotOR. A bit more GTA, hell if someone could come up with a GTA/MassEffect hybrid I'd buy it...probably... nah I'd just assume it was bad and not. :(
 

Eldritch Warlord

New member
Jun 6, 2008
2,901
0
0
Random argument man post=326.73846.812058 said:
It's Shepard, not Sheppard.
It's Shepherd, shortened from Sheepherd meaning 'sheep herder.' A very common English surname, taken from the profession of an ancestor.
 

shatnershaman

New member
May 8, 2008
2,627
0
0
Typecast post=326.73846.812185 said:
Shooting was good, but you are absolutely right; if you're not using the shotgun you're doing it wrong(unless in the extremely rare cases where you're at a range where the shotgun is ineffective).
My AR never overheats, perfect aim and kills every thing in 5 shots. Then again that wasn't during the first play through.

Great review keep them coming.
 

Random Argument Man

New member
May 21, 2008
6,011
0
0
Spartan Bannana post=326.73846.812176 said:
Random argument man post=326.73846.812128 said:
Spartan Bannana post=326.73846.812107 said:
Random argument man post=326.73846.812058 said:
It's Shepard, not Sheppard.

Good review. I got bored with Mass effect after a while. It had a corny story and they should had replaced the Alliance with the USA. It would fit the mentality of the Alliance. Yes, I said it. It had an american feeling to it. I didn't like the ending. (Except the elevator part, who woudn't like that?)
Woahwoahwoahwoahwoahwowahwowhaawhwoawhwhwhw...woah....woah.............woah...............................woah.

You thought Mass Effect had a corny story? I thought it rivaled Star Wars.

Nice Review, I didn't agree with everything you said, specifically the thing about it not intertwining the genres, I felt it did that well.
It was a mix of Star Wars+ The Matrix + American War Movies. Think about it.
Seems like a good combination to me, only some American War movies are corny and the rest aren't
Alright, I will correct things up.
Star wars for the sci-fi and psychic powers
Matrix for the life cycle that will end with some machine race that will enslave all living things and kill them for energy.
Corny American War movies for the corny parts....

Happy?
 

Novajam

New member
Apr 26, 2008
965
0
0
Hate... you... soooo much.

I've been writing a Mass Effect review of my own for the last week, and the second before I post it I find this?! AGH!

Nevermind. I disagreed with you about a lot of those things so it'll still be relevant.

Pretty good review. But I honestly think that if you had to grind in this game you were playing it wrong.

Eldritch Warlord post=326.73846.812200 said:
Random argument man post=326.73846.812058 said:
It's Shepard, not Sheppard.
It's Shepherd, shortened from Sheepherd meaning 'sheep herder.' A very common English surname, taken from the profession of an ancestor.
The back of the box says "Shepard".
 

searanox

New member
Sep 22, 2008
864
0
0
Not a bad review, but your structure is sloppy... and you misspelled the main character's name. Not an Xbox exclusive, either.

That said I do share some of your complaints. I love Mass Effect but it's a clear case of BioWare not having enough time to implement everything they wanted - the uncharted worlds might as well have been randomly generated, and while the Mako is fun, it's too awkward to drive and I've gotten stuck with it numerous times. The side-quests range from excellent to mediocre, sometimes with great and sometimes with awful writing. I think they wanted to do a lot more with the game, but I wouldn't be surprised if EA pressured them into an earlier release than they were comfortable with. If you've played the Bring Down the Sky expansion, you'll agree that that's the sort of thing all the game's side-quests should have been.

I have high hopes for the sequel, especially if they let you import your old save games, and beef up the RPG mechanics. The weapon upgrades in Mass Effect are cool, but the actual equipment basically just scales linearly from "gun 1" to "gun 2", etc. I'd also like to see the Renegade and Paragon branches fleshed out a bit more; Renegade is especially inconsistent, and seems to switch between "badass" and "petty thug" every other quest. I actually enjoy the petty thuggery, but they need to decide if Renegade means "hero who gets the job done no matter the cost" or "general jerk-off". Outcomes of situations depending on your selections are often too similar; I'd like at least once for a major "good" decision to result in failure, and a major "bad" one to result in success. I'd also prefer five or six really fleshed-out planets with lots of exploration and side-quests to thirty unique but barren worlds. Mass Effect is a decent-sized game, but the main story can be beaten in around eight hours the first time through, and most of the rest of the game consists of driving across empty planets and clearing out the same three bunkers over and over again. Compared to Knights of the Old Republic, it's suspiciously miniscule, which is again why I suspect EA's tampering got in the way.
 

Eldritch Warlord

New member
Jun 6, 2008
2,901
0
0
Novajam post=326.73846.812238 said:
Eldritch Warlord post=326.73846.812200 said:
Random argument man post=326.73846.812058 said:
It's Shepard, not Sheppard.
It's Shepherd, shortened from Sheepherd meaning 'sheep herder.' A very common English surname, taken from the profession of an ancestor.
The back of the box says "Shepard".
Indeed, I'm a bastard. *face palm*

I pretty much agree with this review. It's also well written, in-depth, and humorous; keep up the good work.
 

Flour

New member
Mar 20, 2008
1,868
0
0
I can't really comment about the review, but it doesn't read right. It switches from one point to another without a clear change and I expected it to be longer.

Typecast post=326.73846.812185 said:
Shooting was good, but you are absolutely right; if you're not using the shotgun you're doing it wrong(unless in the extremely rare cases where you're at a range where the shotgun is ineffective).
A shotgun is never ineffective. Range is only an excuse to shoot more.
 

mjhhiv

New member
Jun 22, 2008
758
0
0
Flour post=326.73846.812329 said:
I can't really comment about the review, but it doesn't read right. It switches from one point to another without a clear change and I expected it to be longer.

Typecast post=326.73846.812185 said:
Shooting was good, but you are absolutely right; if you're not using the shotgun you're doing it wrong(unless in the extremely rare cases where you're at a range where the shotgun is ineffective).
A shotgun is never ineffective. Range is only an excuse to shoot more.
I'm not sure what to say to that. I've been reading Escapist reviews/reviews in general for quite some time, and I think it's safe to say that this is actually far longer than the average review.

I guess I jump around a bit too much, but in my defense, Mass Effect has so many key points to get across about everything that I feared I'd drone on a bit too much about one specific thing.

-

Just to clarify some other things - Sorry about the "Sheppard" thing. I went with the most common spelling of Sheppard, because, in an act of foolishness, I hit the "correct all" button to save time.

And, as usual, thanks to everyone for the kind words.
 

Chimp

New member
Sep 5, 2008
13
0
0
Someone mentioned the Mako yet? It was not fun to drive at all. And the physics is totally ridiculous. Driving around with that thing in planet exploration almost made me quit playing the game.

The side-missions are also incredibly repetitive.