Well, I don't think the problem is so much that he's terrible at what he does. I think it's that he and Platinum Dunes have a tendency towards taking famous franchises and "dirtying" them in the eyes of the fans of said franchises. If he stuck to his own work, people probably wouldn't hate him so much. Same with Boll.ethaninja said:Didn't he do The Rock? That was one of my favourites. Granted the rest of his movies are shit. I ain't defending the dickmuncher, but I guess he isn't a TOTAL fail in some ways.
I'm gonna go further out on this limb and suggest (though I don't think I was even born when most of the horror classics first debuted) that this whole thing may even be a case of the "lost in imitation" trope.