Uh... Halo 3 ODST? But even that wasn't bad, I beat it about four times (in the amount of time that it should take to beat one game, but I was having enough fun to beat it a bunch of times.)
I don't preorder many games. I preordered ODST and Reach, and I believe those are the only two games I have ever preordered.
Vault Girl said:
Fallout: New Vegas. I could have cried

at least i didn't go for the collector's edition like i planned
For what system? I recently picked up the 360 version and those infamous bugs are nowhere to be found for me. Maybe you should try updating it if you still have it? Or did you just not like the game?