Need Some Advice on Some Anime.

Recommended Videos

RJ 17

The Sound of Silence
Nov 27, 2011
8,687
0
0
Yep, it's my turn to ask "what's a good anime to watch?"! But at least I've actually got a couple specific anime to ask about rather than just coming here and saying "THROW SOME ANIME TITLES AT ME, DAMNIT!"

Anywho, as you've probably guessed I'm looking for some new anime to get into, having watched the ever-loving shit out of my favorite anime (Rurouni Kenshin, Cowboy Bebop, Ghost in the Shell, and Bobobo) as well as a few others, now I'm looking to branch out and test the water with a couple new shows.

The first one I'm thinking of picking up is Soul Eater. Looks interesting, sounds interesting, do you have any general thoughts on it? Is it worth diving into or is it skippable?

The next would be the Fate series. From what I've heard (from a staggering TWO SOURCES!), Fate/Stay Night is kinda "meh", but Fate/Zero is supposed to be pretty damn good. Any advice on that series? More specifically, is it better to have watched Stay Night before watching Zero? Apparently Zero came second but is meant to be a prequel, so is there anything wrong with watching them out of order?

Annnnnnnd I suppose if you wanna throw some random anime titles at me anyways, I'll go ahead and at least look into them. My tastes are mainly actiony stories and I'd prefer if I could avoid anything involving characters even remotely involved with high school. Seriously...why is it that so damn many anime shows feature characters in high school? Just gets a bit old after a while. I'd say I'd like to get into some good comedy anime, but really the only comedy anime I've ever liked is Bobobo...so if you know anything that's like Bobobo, then by all means let me know, if not, then I think I'll pass.

Thanks for the recommendations/advice!
 

Queen Michael

has read 4,010 manga books
Jun 9, 2009
10,400
0
0
In my opinion, Soul Eater is a decent show. I didn't care much for the manga, but the anime is fine.
 

Little Woodsman

New member
Nov 11, 2012
1,057
0
0
Sorry to dodge commenting on the shows you specifically asked about (as I haven't seen those particular titles) but given the things you list as having watched and (I presume) liked I've got to say--watch Outlaw Star ASAP.
 

BQE

Posh Villainess
Jun 17, 2013
334
0
0
Soul Eater is a great show, all the adults in the show are actually very interesting and dynamic. The children bother me incessantly however. I would highly recommend the show though. This show takes place in an academy that teaches people to hunt monsters and take their corrupt souls to forge weapons for the Grim Reaper. I interpreted the show as working on two levels: the adults, whom bear strong personalities and motives and the impressionable and vigorous youths. It explores the interactions amongst these two entities and the growth of each. It also underlays some morbid themes and questions under a pleasant and cheerful facade.

Deadman Wonderland is also a mature show complete with violence and various breakdowns of the human psyche. It starts in a school....for about five minutes until everybody gets butchered. Not to spoil anything, but it leads to a place whhich harbors conditions that lead to some interesting and aberrant mutations of personality.

The first season of Darker than Black was incredible to me also. I thought it struck a great tenor between Soul Eater and D. Wonderland honestly. The central theme of the show is Contractors, who are people which are effectively mutants to the tune of X-men. It explores a world in which these people are attempted to be hidden by goverments while simultaneously used for nefarious purposes. It also raises questions regarding the rights of people who end up this way.

Trust me, I also share your distaste for schools as well, especially carbon copies of school. Once Bleach started taking less and less time in school it was great for me.

Also, if you're into the shows shown on Adult Swim, then you might like Trigun too, quite a few people love that show. If you like Kenshin you might want to look into Samurai X, which is more of a prequel to Kenshin, and goes into his origins and history as the Battosai.

I promise I'm actually very picky with Anime and find much of it rather noxious.

*Edited for a bit more descriptive analysis*
 

Keoul

New member
Apr 4, 2010
1,579
0
0
Try out Trigun and Berserk.
Both have similar artstyles to CowboyBebop and both are pretty actiony. I haven't watched much of Trigun though but I'd still recommend it. Berserk gets pretty strange in the last few episodes but hey at least it was interesting!
 

ShinyCharizard

New member
Oct 24, 2012
2,034
0
0
I found Soul Eater to be pretty good. It was never really compelling though.

Fate/Zero is pretty damn epic and you don't need to watch or play Fate/Stay Night. I never did.

Anyway I'd recommend:

Zetsuen No Tempest

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Samurai Champloo

Macross Frontier

Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom (this series is really, really good)

Steins;Gate

Welcome to the NHK

Gurren Lagann

Eureka Seven
 

sextus the crazy

New member
Oct 15, 2011
2,348
0
0
ShinyCharizard said:
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Samurai Champloo

Steins;Gate

Welcome to the NHK
Seconding these ones. I've seen 'em and they're good.

OT: So, have you seen Puella Magi Madoka Magica? No?

[HEADING=2]SEE IT.[/HEADING]
 

ShinyCharizard

New member
Oct 24, 2012
2,034
0
0
sextus the crazy said:
ShinyCharizard said:
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Samurai Champloo

Steins;Gate

Welcome to the NHK
Seconding these ones. I've seen 'em and they're good.

OT: So, have you seen Puella Magi Madoka Magica? No?

[HEADING=2]SEE IT.[/HEADING]
Yes this how did I forget.

[HEADING=2]SEE IT.[/HEADING]
 

RJ 17

The Sound of Silence
Nov 27, 2011
8,687
0
0
sextus the crazy said:
ShinyCharizard said:
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Samurai Champloo

Steins;Gate

Welcome to the NHK
Seconding these ones. I've seen 'em and they're good.

OT: So, have you seen Puella Magi Madoka Magica? No?

[HEADING=2]SEE IT.[/HEADING]
All those that you picked out from Charizard's list are ones that I've also thought about getting into (I saw the original Fullmetal Alchemist series and found it pretty enjoyable...dragged on a bit too long for my tastes, but wasn't too bad at all). I've seen Champloo, but I've heard good things about Steins;Gate and NHK.

But what's this Puella Magi Madoka Magica about? I've never even heard of this one.
 

VanQ

Casual Plebeian
Oct 23, 2009
2,729
0
0
Here's an updated list of shit I recommend. I second the people in this thread that recommend Steins;Gate and Madoka. When it comes to Nasuverse stuff, everything ranges from watchable to good with the exception of the Fate/Stay Night anime adaptation. Avoid that at all costs, though I recommend the VN if you don't mind reading.

Accel World [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=13857] - A good series based on a futuristic video game called The Accelerated World. It's pretty stylish all round. (Spiritual sequel to Sword Art Online)
Denpa Teki na Kanojo [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=10519] - Watch this. This show is excellent and outstanding in every way possible, an absolute must-watch in my opinion.
Eve no Jikan Gekijouban [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=11350] - See above.
Mardock Scramble [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=11338] - Also see above.
Fate/Zero [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=12376] - This is the Nasuverse done right. Try your best to track down the BD subs for this if you can, it's simply stunning both visually and storywise.
Fate/kaleid liner Prisma Illya [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=15245] - If you aren't allergic to Magical Girl anime, this is a really fun show with lots of great action based on Nasuverse stuff. It's not canon though.
Kara no Kyoukai [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=7472] - A 7 part movie series with more excellent Nasuverse stuff.
Golden Boy [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=373] - No need to analyze this. It speaks for itself.
Hataraku! Maou-sama! [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=14846] An evil lord flees from his home dimension into ours after his humiliating defeat at the hands of a hero and must acclimate to Japanese society while trying to plot his return to power.
Isekai no Seikishi Monogatari [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=10393] - Tenchi Muyo spinoff that's set in another world as the title implies. Yeah, this is a harem but it's great when a harem lead is not afraid of his own cock, he just has better things to do. Kinda gotta watch it to understand.
Magi- The Labyrinth of Magic [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=14395] - Pretty cool story set in a middle ages Arabian Nights setting where magical labyrinths appear around the world full of treasures and Djinn that would choose the next king.
Mouretsu Kaizoku [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=11399] - Also known as Bodacious Space Pirates. Don't expect One Piece, it's a show about strong and cute female characters and politics and insurance fraud. And a whole lot of Space Ship porn on the side. The soundtrack is also absolutely lovely.
Nazo no Kanojo X [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=13899] - It's honestly as weird as it sounds but it's a lovely story that's one of my all time favorites.
Shiki [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=11302] - Slow starter but an excellent vampire horror story set in modern Japan.
Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=14238] - An excellent RomCom that's as good as if not better than ToraDora!
Sword Art Online [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=13858] - Set in the world's first Full Dive MMO environment where 10, 000 players are locked into the game and will die in real life if they die in game. Excellent first cour but the second cour lacks the tension of the first. Hope to see a season two for Gun Gale Online.
The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=11120] - Yeah, it sucks that the TV show has such an awful fanbase and the Endless Eight sucked too but this movie is an objective masterpiece. And I do not use that term lightly. Make Sure you watch at least episode 1-5 in chronological order, Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody and at least the first two and last episode of Endless Eight for maximum effect. This is a movie that actually managed to turn 5 minutes of deep introspection into one of the most tense and watchable scenes of all time.
The iDOLM@STER [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=12436] - Based off an extremely popular Japanese video game series where you raise a group of 13 young, unknown girls to become top idols. Slow starter but it quickly picks up pace as the girls become more popular and it's worth watching for the performance scenes alone.
The iDOLM@STER: Xenoglossia [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=7442] - Ignore the relations it holds to The iDOLM@STER and you have a giant robot anime that's so bad it's good. It's like watching a car crash in slow motion, it's so horrifying that you can't look away. The first episode sucks pretty bad but I couldn't stop watching after episode two.
Tasogare Otome X Amnesia [http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=13892] - This is a pretty cool and interesting specimen. It's more or less a horror/romance story for girls but is extremely enjoyable nonetheless.
 

[Kira Must Die]

Incubator
Sep 30, 2009
2,537
0
0
I personally didn't like Soul Eater at all, but that was mostly due to it not really being my taste. The plot was a bit too Shounen-Jump-y for me, and I found most of the main characters really annoying.

As for the Fate series, I'd say either choice is fine. Fate/Zero, apart from being a prequel, is the far superior series, as the Fate/Stay Night anime, for me, was mearly mediocre, but at the same time it would be a good idea to go into Fate/Zero with some knowledge of the series. I will say that the F/SN anime does a decent job at establishing its setting, and like I said, it's watchable, not great but not awful, either. There's a chance you might come out liking it. And if you didn't, they're remaking it with the studio that worked on Fate/Zero set to release next year.

As for recommendations, like some above me mentioned, you can give Madoka Magica a try. It's one of my favorite anime, and it's from the same writer as Fate/Zero, so you can get an idea of his writing style.
 

BQE

Posh Villainess
Jun 17, 2013
334
0
0
VanQ said:
Here's an updated list of shit I recommend. I second the people in this thread that recommend Steins;Gate and Madoka. When it comes to Nasuverse stuff, everything ranges from watchable to good with the exception of the Fate/Stay Night anime adaptation. Avoid that at all costs, though I recommend the VN if you don't mind reading.

*Enormous list of Anime*
I particularly appreciate your efforts and this list, as I'm looking for more anime that I would enjoy. However, when I read things like:

VanQ said:
Watch this. This show is excellent and outstanding in every way possible, an absolute must-watch in my opinion.
After which I dutifully follow your link only to find a plot synopsis summed up thusly:

Juuzawa Juu is a delinquent high school boy who just wants to be left alone. One day, he is approached by Ochibana Ame, who claims that she knew him in a previous life, and now wants to serve him as his "knight". At first Juu wants nothing to do with Ame, but after a classmate is murdered, he accepts her help as he looks for the killer.
I'm honestly no better off or more interested in the offering you have discussed. As much as I adore seeing people's admiration for the things they love, and the delightful bias that is a result of that, it is a problematic way of recommending things. This is especially true if I have no idea who you are and would like some critical analysis.

That being said, and looking at my earlier post in this thread, this isn't something specific to you. I'll try and amend my entry with something a bit more clinical.

On a conclusory note, I do want to hear what you have to say my dear VanQ, I just want to be able to actually make sense of it, and use your thoughts as weight to my own opinions.

Villainously yours.
 

ShinyCharizard

New member
Oct 24, 2012
2,034
0
0
RJ 17 said:
sextus the crazy said:
ShinyCharizard said:
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Samurai Champloo

Steins;Gate

Welcome to the NHK
Seconding these ones. I've seen 'em and they're good.

OT: So, have you seen Puella Magi Madoka Magica? No?

[HEADING=2]SEE IT.[/HEADING]
All those that you picked out from Charizard's list are ones that I've also thought about getting into (I saw the original Fullmetal Alchemist series and found it pretty enjoyable...dragged on a bit too long for my tastes, but wasn't too bad at all). I've seen Champloo, but I've heard good things about Steins;Gate and NHK.

But what's this Puella Magi Madoka Magica about? I've never even heard of this one.
It's basically a magical girl series that subverts the genre. It's starts out all happy and then takes a dive into the deep end of "Holy Shit WTF". It's really very good.
 

VanQ

Casual Plebeian
Oct 23, 2009
2,729
0
0
BQE said:
VanQ said:
Here's an updated list of shit I recommend. I second the people in this thread that recommend Steins;Gate and Madoka. When it comes to Nasuverse stuff, everything ranges from watchable to good with the exception of the Fate/Stay Night anime adaptation. Avoid that at all costs, though I recommend the VN if you don't mind reading.

*Enormous list of Anime*
I particularly appreciate your efforts and this list, as I'm looking for more anime that I would enjoy. However, when I read things like:

VanQ said:
Watch this. This show is excellent and outstanding in every way possible, an absolute must-watch in my opinion.
After which I dutifully follow your link only to find a plot synopsis summed up thusly:

Juuzawa Juu is a delinquent high school boy who just wants to be left alone. One day, he is approached by Ochibana Ame, who claims that she knew him in a previous life, and now wants to serve him as his "knight". At first Juu wants nothing to do with Ame, but after a classmate is murdered, he accepts her help as he looks for the killer.
I'm honestly no better off or more interested in the offering you have discussed. As much as I adore seeing people's admiration for the things they love, and the delightful bias that is a result of that, it is a problematic way of recommending things. This is especially true if I have no idea who you are and would like some critical analysis.

That being said, and looking at my earlier post in this thread, this isn't something specific to you. I'll try and amend my entry with something a bit more clinical.

On a conclusory note, I do want to hear what you have to say my dear VanQ, I just want to be able to actually make sense of it, and use your thoughts as weight to my own opinions.

Villainously yours.
I honestly didn't expect much going into Denpa Teki na Kanojo. I thought it would be some silly high school drama or something but was very surprised at how its themes turned out to be quite intriguing if a bit disturbing. The main female protagonist, Ame, starts out by stalking Juu and saying some truly cringe-worthy things like "I am your servant." and stuff like that, but moves on to some really interesting plots involving the murder of a classmate and you get 2 well fleshed out stories about some of the strangest and most disturbed members of society.

Don't let the cringe-worthy things Ame says or the creepy behavior of hers in the first 15-20mins scare you off, because they most certainly have a reason and a damn good one that I can't get in to at risk of spoiling one of the most important parts of the show. You will seriously start off thinking she's insane but if you're anything like me she will win you over easily by the end of the second episode.

If there's one fault of Denpa Teki na Kanojo, it feels like it ends way too early, there are only two episodes and it absolutely leaves you wanting more at the end. The characters are well written, the stories excellently executed and the atmosphere will drag you into the more disturbing parts of society that exist in the shadows. And not in a "evil organizations" kinda way, in a "demented human beings" kinda way.

I don't say "absolute must watch" lightly, I truly recommend that everyone have the chance to see Denpa Teki na Kanojo. I hope I've been able to flesh out my recommendation some more.
 

sextus the crazy

New member
Oct 15, 2011
2,348
0
0
RJ 17 said:
But what's this Puella Magi Madoka Magica about? I've never even heard of this one.
It's a Magical Girl anime. It's really fucking good. As in, "I have no interest in the genre, yet this is my favorite anime by a long shot" good.

Go into the show completely blind. It's worth it. Also, watch it in sub (the dub is pretty meh).

Also, it's only 12 eps. long and has a complete story, so it's a good time investment.
 

BQE

Posh Villainess
Jun 17, 2013
334
0
0
VanQ said:
Sweet Sweet Redemption.
Very commendable, I thank you for the additive analysis. I now know the show is quite somber, and it's two episodes long. I'm sure I can manage that if it's dubbed (I don't watch subtitled anything). I might have to PM you to hear some more thoughts on that list.

Sadly, Mr. sextus the crazy follows up with this ambiguity:

sextus the crazy said:
It's a Magical Girl anime. It's really fucking good. As in, "I have no interest in the genre, yet this is my favorite anime by a long shot" good.

Go into the show completely blind. It's worth it. Also, watch it in sub (the dub is pretty meh).

Also, it's only 12 eps. long and has a complete story, so it's a good time investment.
A great way to illustrate how little words can mean is with an example. If we were to change a few words in that quote, it would be a near facsimile.

sextus the crazy said:
It's Monkeysauce. It's really fucking good. As in, "I have no interest in sauces, yet this is my favorite sauce by a long shot" good.

Go into the sauce completely blind. It's worth it. Also, eat it in the bathroom (the kitchen is pretty meh).

Also, it's only 12 ounces. bold and has a complete flavor, so it's a good time investment.
Please take note that I'm not doing this to insult you or be incendiary, just to demonstrate a point. As crude as this example is, it's a relatively clear of how impertinent this description is to the show itself.

For starters, I have no idea what a Magical Girl Anime is. There's always the possibility that BQE is so below the knowledge level that she can't see the light through the floorboards, or the odds that some people may have no idea what the phrase means. I promise you I'm no trying to be rude here, but if you were to try and sell something to someone (because essentially, that's what we're doing here), then would it not make more sense to use objective analysis rather than bias? While I understand you believe that one should watch the show with no prior information, some others may never agree with that particular sentiment and always seek to research at least some aspects. You could even spoil your analytical details so you wouldn't be hypocritical, I know I'd read them.

Of course, of course, there's always the possibility that I'm missing the mark here; and people watch or do things based on people saying "it's really really great". If such is the case, you have my sincerest apologies for wasting yours and everyone else's time.
 

Nouw

New member
Mar 18, 2009
15,615
0
0
I recently binge-watched Fate/Zero and can say without a doubt it is definitely worth watching. From the perspective of someone who didn't know much about the Nausverse, it felt like a solid and relatively self-contained anime. The universe completely new to me blew me away, not only for its concept but its execution. Fate/Zero's setting can be described as modern fantasy where the fantasy is hidden away and of course to hide it away are organizations such as the Mage's association. Seven people, they tend to be people capable with magic, fight a proxy war to win the Holy Grail. The Holy Grail is an omni-potent wish granting device as so elegantly described in the subtitles and this is the fourth war. The proxy war is fought with historical figures, brought back to life using a relic which serves as the catalyst. Called servants, they fight to defeat other servants and win the Holy Grail for their master. Featuring an ensemble cast, Fate/Zero did an excellent job of providing a balanced variety of interesting characters. Seven characters that are unlike in personality, social status, ideology and much more duke it out for an omnipotent wish-granting device. Think Game of Thrones.

How do they achieve this goal? What is their wish? Why do they want the Grail?

The servants aren't there just so we can oggle them during fights though, they are important characters as well which form bonds and relationships with other servants and masters. So not only do you have interactions between seven almost-completely different people, some are bound to overlap in some respects, you also have interactions between people from history I won't spoil. Fate/Zero has more than a handful of compelling characters with memorable relationships to boot and if that sounds appealing to you, check it out. Sounds good right? Well I haven't even mentioned the animation or fight scenes.

Enjoy.

This is the kind of anime you could write an essay on because there's so much you can analyse in terms of character and theme. Or you could enjoy it as just as an action-packed anime. What's great is that you can go as deep as you want so I can recommend this to a lot more people.

Take note that there is a fair bit of CG, sometimes done well and other times done IMO atrociously. It won't break the experience, I hope, but I'm just warning you that it's there in case you have a particular aversion for it.

As I mentioned before, I was unfamiliar with the Fate series before watching this and I'd like to reinforce that you don't need to watch or read Fate/Stay Night to read this BUT!, and it's a big but, like every prequel expect an ending which feels like it's missing a bit of closure. Once again, it won't break the experience but I just warn to you because it threw me off-guard when I expected something with all loose threads tied. And don't worry, there is nothing Highschool-related.
BQE said:
smack-downsnip
Is my recommendation in-depth enough oh knowledgeable one D: ??
 

Joccaren

Elite Member
Mar 29, 2011
2,601
3
43
RJ 17 said:
But what's this Puella Magi Madoka Magica about? I've never even heard of this one.
As the name - basically something along the lines of Magical Girl Madoka - would imply, its a show about magical girls. Nothing like Sailor Moon or Card Captors. It is an amazing show that I was glad I got into. It fairly quickly gets dark, and from then only darker. Saying much more would be spoilers, but its good. Nobody I have ever run into online or offline would say otherwise.

As for other suggestions in this thread, I'll only comment on what I've seen so far.

Darker than Black: Is great. A brief synopsis of lore, and not plot, is that... 40? years ago two 'gates' - areas of the world where physics ceased to work properly, put simply - opened. One in Brazil called Heaven's gate, and one in Tokyo called Hell's gate. Around this same time 'Contractors' and 'Dolls' began appearing. Contractors are granted superhuman powers in return for an obesience/renumeration - the exact translation I've found differs from translator to translator. But basically, they feel compelled to do something like smoke, drink, flip someone's shoes upside down, sleep, play chess - any random task - as if it were an addiction, near immediately after they use their power. Dolls are emotionless people with no personality, who obey their masters orders, and have the ability to send a spiritual scout out through a specific medium. The plot centres around a Contractor and Doll named Hei and Yin, and the politics of the world in which they live in regards to their existence. Season one feels like its just messing around for a bit with no plot, but at the end it all comes together in a pretty straightforward and understandable way, with a slight twist of course. Season 2... Watch the OVAs first, as they are intermediary and required to make sense of season 2. Even then the end is quite out there, with not a lot truly explained and largely left up to interpretation. It kinda foreshadows what's going to happen, then has it happen - but doesn't say exactly what happened. Its kinda annoying and a lot of guesswork, but its still possible to take a reasonable guess at most things.

Stein's Gate: Based of a visual novel of the same name, the story centres around the invention of a time machine by a rather odd group. This creation leads them to be hunted by another organisation trying to make a time machine. Saying much more would be spoilers. I found the first episode alright, then the next four or so really annoying, as the main character continually fails to arrive at the obvious conclusion that he has time travelled, and acts like a complete and utter blathering idiot. After that though it becomes good, as things take a more serious turn and the actual plot begins. Its worth watching the whole way through, not giving up near the start 'cause it doesn't seem great.

Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann: An entertaining anime for those that don't really want to put a ton of thought into things. Two main story arcs, but basically a mecha anime that is light hearted, funny, and empowering. Its also highly ridiculous and things get to a "So unreal its funny" stage near the end of the second half of the anime. Saying exactly what would ruin some awesome moments, but logic and seriousness fly out the window for this anime, but it does it well, and that makes it brilliant in its own way.

Accel World: Starts off fairly interesting. It kinda reverses the general dynamic whereby, in this anime, the hero and heroine are kinda the assholes of the story. The hero is also fat, short, and unattractive. Its interesting, and I like a lot of the ideas in the anime, and the technology, though it doesn't seem quite as polished {Maybe not the right word in this case, but it feels like its missing something} as the rest of them. Its a different kind of story. The second half of the season, however, reverts the original paradigm and the hero and heroine become the nice guys as opposed to the assholes. Kinda disappointing, but it works. Worth a watch, but if you get to four/five episodes in and don't enjoy it I'd probably stop.

Sword Art Online: The first half of the season is great. It deals with some serious themes, some not so serious themes too. It has happy moments, sad moments, glorious action moments, and peaceful everyday moments. Best way to describe it is "What if we lived in a videogame". The SECOND half of the season is utterly crap. I don't blame the author for this, as reading the light novels it was fairly decent - though it wasn't as good as the first half. The anime though... Rushes far too much. The first two episodes of the second half of the season are fine, but after that it skips a lot of the light novel to try and build up to the light novel's more epic moments, then gives the epic moment 2 minutes of screentime to build towards the next epic moment. Its a lot of buildup, and never any payoff. Its really disappointing, compared to the light novel where I jumped out of my seat screaming at some of the throwbacks to the first arc. Season two is set to be epic if they make it though.

Magi; The Labyrinth of Magic: In the end I'll say I liked it. Its different in feel to most other things I've watched. Its enjoyable, and largely light hearted - though there are some dark points too. I can't bring myself to wholeheartedly recommend it, but I can't say its bad either. I liked bits and pieces from it, and found other bits and pieces kind of boring, but overall I liked it and am awaiting 'Magi: The world of Magic' when it comes out.

Mouretsu Kaizoku: Not at all what the name would suggest. Translated to English its "Bodacious Space Pirates", making it sound kinda like Highschool DxD in space with some piracy on the side. Not at all what its about. Its a light hearted, well made story about a young group of girls who are originally part of a school yatch club [Only for the first few episodes, which are the less interesting of the anime], but a few of which come to man pirate vessels in a world where piracy isn't really piracy - its boarding a ship that has called you out to 'raid' it, putting on a show to act like pirates, being given willingly people's valuables, and then flying off whilst everything is replaced by an insurance company. Technically they're all privateers too, seeing as the main pirates have letters of marque, which are a major plotpoint in the series. True piracy comes in a lot later, and begins to expand the universe a lot more. I'm hoping for a sequel series. Its well made, light hearted and enjoyable, and not at all what the name may suggest. I'd put it as more shoujo that shounen anime, though its enjoyable for all IMO. Just... watch it. [BTW: Shounen = young boy, Shoujo = young girl]
 

Joccaren

Elite Member
Mar 29, 2011
2,601
3
43
BQE said:
For starters, I have no idea what a Magical Girl Anime is. There's always the possibility that BQE is so below the knowledge level that she can't see the light through the floorboards, or the odds that some people may have no idea what the phrase means. I promise you I'm no trying to be rude here, but if you were to try and sell something to someone (because essentially, that's what we're doing here), then would it not make more sense to use objective analysis rather than bias? While I understand you believe that one should watch the show with no prior information, some others may never agree with that particular sentiment and always seek to research at least some aspects. You could even spoil your analytical details so you wouldn't be hypocritical, I know I'd read them.
Well for starters I'll just say a more accurate thing between Subbed and Dubbed than bathroom and kitchen would be kitchen and dining room.
Subbed is the Kitchen. You're eating it where it was made, like it was made. Its the original product in the original packaging. It may be a bit annoying not having a pre-made table set down at, but you're generally guaranteed quality for what you've ordered.
Dubbed is the dining room. Its not the original packaging or place of the product, and a fair bit may be changed. The dining room may be high quality and expensive, but worth it and a better experience than eating in the kitchen, or it could just be a school cafeteria with a lot of exchangeable, discount 2-for-1 tables that don't really suit the gourment that you're eating.

Personally I've always found dubs horrible. I don't mind the ones for things like Neon Genesis: Evangelion, and have even met the dub actors for it, but a lot of them just turn any female into a whiny american teenage girl, and all the guys into... God knows. Whiny American teenage girls putting on a guy voice? Try-hard guys? Honestly I just hate a lot of dubs, and the translation differences piss me off so much. When I see an epic scene subbed, and run into it dubbed where its completely different and the whole context behind what is being said has changed because the dub company thought it would be cool to use teenage american slang, rather than the original script... I want to throw my screen out the window.
But that's beside the point =P

Anyway, Magic Girl anime... What it says on the tin. Really. Its anime about girls with magical powers. Generally light hearted and bright. Girls normally wear some really cute dress, have magical powers granted through some item, and have a mission to accomplish. I.E: Capture all the escaped monsters. Rarely, but occasionally, serious about things. Also generally focuses on the protagonist having to adapt to living their everyday life with these new magical powers. Additionally, LMGTFY. Not meaning to sound rude, but its the assumption on the Internet that if there's a phrase you don't understand, you'll Google it to understand it. Asking what it means, waiting for a response, and forcing someone else to type it out is harder than simply typing it into a search engine and clicking the wikipedia link. If there isn't one than it works, but generally its a good place to start.

As for Madoka Magica details... PM me if you want some. I'd rather not put it even in spoilers here incase someone wants to quote, whereby it'll reveal what is in the spoilers. Not that its necessarily something that I really don't want to spoil, but its the sort of thread where you're not necessarily certain you'll run into spoilers relevant to the larger plot, unlike others where its "Lets discuss this game's story" - where you pretty much know what you're getting into.
 

Arslan Aladeen

New member
Oct 9, 2012
371
0
0
I'm not to well versed in anime, but I did hear about Black Lagoon in one of these forums, checked it out and that thought it was pretty cool. Basically, its about a bunch of modern day pirates and the misadventures they go on. Not to make it sound cute or anything, basically everyone on the show is some shade of villain from terrorist, ex-soviet paratroopers, and triad gang members. As an advert says, it's kinda like a mix between John Woo and Tarantino. Much of the show takes place from the point of view of a Japanese business man nicknamed 'Rock' who gets taken prisoner by and eventually joins the pirate crew. And it also has one crazy gun toting lady named Revy featuring heavily in most of the action scenes.