Non-sexual things you still inexplicably find sexy.

[EHKOS]

Boots. Like, combat boots. And grease/messed up hair from working on a car. I hate to admit it, but Amy from the NFS reboot was a reason I bought the game. I saw the first cutscene and it swayed me.
I also like that kind of awkward, quirky, Felicity Smoak thing. I realized it when I looked up the actress and realized it was her character I was into and not just her.

Oh yeah, and there was something about Piper from Fallout 4 that I STILL haven't been able to put my finger on.

 

[Zhukov]

- Freckles.
- Scarfs.

Spoiler

Don't say I never do anything nice for you.

Daaaayum.

Yeah. She... uh, yeah... that'll do.

And now I might have to add "grey eyes" to my list. Except I have grey eyes myself. Is that weird? I'm going to go ahead and assume that isn't weird.

Sorry to lessen your fun a bit here, but here's the unphotoshopped version of that pic:

Spoiler

The horror! She's repulsive!

Oh colour-correction, why have you forsaken me?!

 

[SilverLion]

Eyepatches. I don't know why, but something about an eyepatch just screams "wild and dangerous" and "I'm so fucking cool that not even losing my eye will slow me down in any way!" They're awesome, and I find that awesomeness strangely attractive
(I prefer Daryl to Uma, you can see)

 

[Extra-Ordinary]

Also, weirdly, short hair on girls.

Dude, no, you're not alone, I think pixie cuts are the best.
Anyway.
Not so much sexy as I find it adorable, and I'm not finding to many good examples without big fat watermarks in the way but girls in winter clothing, depending on the style.
They just look so snug and warm and I just wanna jump in there with them.

 

[Don Incognito]

Spoiler

Don't say I never do anything nice for you.

Mother of God.

Sorry to lessen your fun a bit here, but here's the unphotoshopped version of that pic:

Spoiler

I'm not seeing a problem here.

 

[Silk_Sk]

Hoodie wrapped around the waist.

 

[Shoggoth2588]

Socks, leggings, thigh-highs, fucking loose-socks...not sure what it is about those things especially since straight-up feet don't really do much for me. I do love legs though and when those legs are tightly wrapped in soft-soft cotton it's just...it's just fantastic. I also really love a woman who can sing well. In high school I had a huge crush on Sarah Brightman and Amy Lee...among...other people who I may or may not have gushed about...

I like short hair on girls too but it depends on the girl. Some girls definitely wear it better than others but there are some girls who just absolutely rock that pixie look.

 

[Beliyal]

Armor, helmets, weapons. But like, I prefer ancient armor, although I won't be picky; fantasy, Sci-Fi and modern will do fine as well. I don't know why helmets, as they usually obscure half of or the entire face, but I find them sexy. Damn. This is problematic because most people don't just casually own armor. Unfortunately. Very shameful of you, people.

 

[Blinktv]

Fire. Well, not fire itself but fireplay so I'm not sure if that counts or not.

Armpit hair. Yeah, I know for certain that this one isn't exactly popular.

I prefer more attracted to guys who are, appearance-wise, really feminine and women who are, appearance-wise, more tomboyish.

Staffs and polearms. Long, smooth shafts thats sometimes penetrate people as a way of exerting dominance? You don't have to be Freud to figure this out, folks.

As for clothing, weirdly, the less skin is showing the more attractive I'm probably going to find you, particularly when its in fewer separate pieces. A sleeved maxi dress with a scarf and/or choker? Yes please.

Fire. Well I like a little burn play, being warm is always nice.

I think it looks good on men.

And I 100% agree with this one, I have no idea why defying gender norms is so attractive.

You lost me a little bit with this one, but fuck it. The more Freudian images the better.

And once more, I agree with you.

 

[chiggerwood]

A girl with a close haircut wearing a three piece suit gets me worked up more than lingerie or nudity ever could. Seriously Annie Lennox in the sweet dreams video is the single hottest human being in existence. Hell Annie Lennox in general is hot as hell, but not in a 'jerk off to her' sort of way... I don't know how to explain it. Annie Lennox is hot to me, but I'd never jerk off to her. It'd be disrespectful. It'd feel like using the Mona Lisa as a skeet blanket.

 

[Erttheking]

Dyed hair.

Don't ask me why, I just really think on certain people it looks really attractive.

 

[AnthrSolidSnake]

Wearing something on your neck.
Seriously, just about anything really.
Probably my favorite is chokers. On a pale, thinner neck? Uunnnff...

Necklaces are a close second though. The shorter the better.
I might just have a thing for necks in general really.

Also, darker or tanned skinned people with light colored hair/eyes. Something that offsets their skin tone, but is pleasant in that regard.

One of Millia Rage's alternate color schemes from Guilty Gear Xrd is a good example of what I mean.

 

[Elvis Starburst]

Dyed hair for sure. Slightly "emo"/gothic clothing styles always looks rather nice. Full bodied stockings/yoga pants with a skirt on top is very, very nice as well. Always a fan of that style.

Honestly? Clothes themselves are just awesome. If done right (And not like... sexually right, just simple and well done), clothed women can look far sexier than any nude woman. I admit, I find clothes can emphasize someone's beauty quite a lot, and it doesn't have to be anything special or specified clothing meant for this either. I swear I would be part of REVOCS if it was real

 

[TheVampwizimp_v1legacy]

Tattoos are almost universally sexy on girls. Doesn't matter what of or where on the body, tats are just a big turn on, as long as they aren't just really bad or ugly ones.

Boots are sexy on girls, the heavier and tougher the better. I particularly like the ones with lots of extra buckles and straps. Not in a bdsm way, I dunno, just looks hot and hardcore. Although even just a modest girly-looking boot is nice too. I don't even like feet or anything, I like tough-looking footwear.

Some, not all, but some girls are just hot as hell with short hair. Even a completely shaved head can look great. Just a little stubble on a smooth, round head... Noice.

And I like women with black hair as well. I used to be more into blondes as a teenager, then I liked redheads, and for real, any hair color can look good depending on the person and the style. But something about pure black, raven hair is incredibly alluring. Especially in either a long, straight 'do, or, sexiest of all, shoulder-length and somewhat curly or wavy. Pitch-black hair with a mussed-up, wild look to it, MAN is that a turn on.

This may be getting a bit to enthusiastic...

 

[HybridChangeling]

Hoodie wrapped around the waist.

Is that gender specific or naw... because I do it all the time and I sometimes get weird looks.

For me? I dunno... movie and comic book debates? Nothing says romance then a 45 minute discussion on:

Spoiler

Which eye was fake in Cowboy Bebop. Seriously guys, which one. I still say the light brown one, because of the Pierrot episode.

Then again I'm not a romantic so eh.

 

[FPLOON]

Glasses
Laughter
The color Blue
Singing
Nails
AnimalsIt's more of a person-based list than anything else, I guess...

Other than that, cake... especially chocolate cake...

 

[cojo965]

Strapless/loose strap top. I love the shoulders on women.

 

[Ryallen]

Hm... I like colored hair, Like, hair that is a color that isn't natural, like blue or pink. Tattoos as well, but not too many. I can't really describe it. But I have always been a fan of long hair. Don't get me wrong. I think that short hair on girls is very cute when does well. I really do. But I've always loved girls with long hair. When I was younger, like a toddler, I would chew on my mom's hair when we were watching TV together.