Goodman 528:
Let's be serious here.
As amusing as you might find it to imply that I am saying "America is the Master Race" it's ridiculous. The entire arguement for American supremacy is a cultural one specifically because America allows all Ethnicities to become part of the culture and live as equals. That sort of precludes any kind of master race idealogy.
At the worst I'm making a statement of cultural bigotry, as I'm rather clearly stating that a culture as tolerant as America is in a league of it's own, and above ANY achievement by any mono-ethnic culture, or even one that has attempted to do something similar on a lesser scale.
What's more when I read statements about how "Well China isn't racist, they're just like the Japanese before World War II" I can't help but wonder how serious you are trying to be. The Japanese being one of the most sadistic groups of racists to ever grace the planet, World War II having been a huge kick in the teeth for them. Even today you have them producing pop culture like Anime that has an underlying theme of misplaced national destiny. You've got guys in series like Gasaraki slicing their eyeballs out because they can't bear to see a world in which Japan is not ruling over everyone as nature intended. Then you have crud like Blue Seed where the same attitude is pretty much the honorable motive of the major bad guys, and one that is supposed to be "pure" enough in the context of the story to give the good guys pause (and that right there says something).
-
As far as the rest goes, China was making international newspapers by rounding up all of their "unsightly" elements and political dissidents before the Olympics. To say nothing of the forcible relocation of residents to make space for the facilities themselves. This stuff was all over the papers and had people going "WTF" since China hosting pretty much made a human rights tradgedy out of an event about global humanitarianism.
THEN it was all over the news that China cut a huge censorship deal with Google, so they could pretty much keep outside ideas about democracy and such off the Internet there. Now granted there are hackers and such who still access such things, but again this was a big deal, and had a lot of people calling Google a group of sell outs.
Also according to the few mentions I've seen about it, it's still illegal to be vocally democratic, something they are working to quash. This was a point of tension when we went to the Olympics not too long ago, and extra special effort was taken to ensure that there wasn't any... incidents... with visitors while they were in China's back yard.
What's more on a personal level, before I became disabled, I used to provide Casino security down here in Connecticut. We got a ton of traffic from between New York and Massachussets, iuncluding such a massive volume of Chinese we had specific departments to deal with them.
To be honest with you, I have never dealt with a ruder, more racist group of people. They stole, cheated, insulted people, and felt it was their right. I know this because I investigated the incidents, questioned people, and watched on cameras. I also had to deal with the employees like waitresses and such who were always complaining that they did not tip. This isn't even getting into all of the racial slurs thrown my way trying to do my job. This wasn't isolated incidents, this was part of my job.
The news, combined with my own experiences (and no, it wasn't me being a racist twit or anything, but a general situation affecting everyone) really paints a differant picture of China and the Chinese.
In general Americanized Chinese are okay (ie Chinese Ethnicity, but otherwise American) but those that hold onto the original culture and might not even speak english clearly... no.
If a bunch of guys from New York's Chinatown are like this, I can't imagine China is any better (especially going by what we hear).
On a final note, I once read a novel by a guy called Michael Slade (which is a pen name for a trio of writers from Canada), who claimed as facts in their novel that the Chinese in general are convinced of a divine destiny. A basical idealogy for a lot of them is that they are of divine lineage and China is like "The Middle Kingdom" because it's between heaven and earth, and the "celestrial people" are a step above all of us poor pathetic goobs with our purely mortal ancestory. This last bit isn't that reliable, and I never got the impression that it was claimed that everyone followed that idealogy, but apparently it's enough of a factory culturally that it makes me... wary... when it coems to any suggestions of China as a progressive culture.
Heck, for another fact SARS pretty much started in China because you had people living so close to their livestock and such.
-
As far as the number of empowered minorities in China, I'm going to call "BS" on that one. It IS true that there are a large number of differant ethnicities living in China that the rest of the world labels as "Chinese" though they might maintain a distinction within China and have it be obvious to someone who lives there. But as far as Blacks, Whites, Latinos, etc... no. There are some, but nothing like what we're talking about.
... and I'm sorry, if you can't even Google freely, then I'm not buying anyone down there has the requisite freedom to even begin to compare to America. Once you have America's level of freedom, then it becomes a question of whether you maintain that level of freedom within a society that has all ethnicities living as equals, OR if your by and large a mono-ethnic society.
Honestly if I went down to say Beijing right now and looked around I'd think I'd be hard pressed to find a white person or a black person. Even if I did, I doubt I'd find them in any numbers compared to the rest of the country. In the US on the otherhand if I go to DC I'm going to see people of all kinds of differant ethnicities all over the place.