Toasty Virus said:
Your princess is in another stall.
Wow, I actually like that one.
I checked this thread, this is my fav so far. I can't believe it's the first one. It made me lol XP!
Otherwise, i personally think "the cake is a lie" is more iconic than cliché. its also really creepy, in whatever context you bring it up in. As pointed out by a previous poster, if done correctly, it is very effective. Writing it over and over with red crayon (or the sort), with increased speed and decreased strength would really creepy anyone out, whether they recognize it or not.
PS: the "FINISH HIM!" next to the flusher made me lol too. Unfortunately this one (and eventually the "princess" one) can easily become over-used. Unlike "the cake is a lie", which is more like a secret message slowly spreading across the world (today the toilet stalls, tommorow the world!)