My selections are probably not really "old," though, by the changes during the past five to seven years, they aren't cutting edge anymore.
I've been bouncing around since I finished Mass Effect 3. Originally, I tried my hand at Fable: The Lost Chapters but wasn't really getting into it. I then started Star Ocean: The Last Hope and, while it took a while to realize it, started enjoying it. This weekend, after my fifth lock-up wasting an hour or so of my life each time, I decided it wasn't worth my efforts anymore.
FPSs aren't my thing, but I have begun a play-through of Halo: Combat Evolved (The original, not the anniversary edition). It's too early to tell how I feel about it.
PC-wise, I've got an ongoing play-though of Fallout on the back burner.