Piracy...can it kill PC gaming?

Recommended Videos

MercurySteam

Tastes Like Chicken!
Legacy
Apr 11, 2008
4,950
2
43
IBlackKiteI said:
It could severely cripple the industry even more than it is now but it won't outright kill the PC.

The real danger to PC gaming is consoles.
PC gamers have been laughing in the faces of console gamers for the longest time. Their persistence keeps them alive. Not to say that one's better than the other but consoles aren't a threat, just a different choice.
 

Aureliano

New member
Mar 5, 2009
604
0
0
I prefer to think that console piracy will win out as the biggest threat to game sales over PC piracy when your average console user gets more tech-savvy, and then the PC as a gaming platform will rise again.
 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
Om Nom Nom said:
V8 Ninja said:
The real question is if piracy is going to kill big-budget games being made for the PC.
Considering the big studios' mentality of "make something better by throwing ridiculous amounts of money at it instead of just damn well making a good game" is that really a bad thing?

Case in point; Fallout New Vegas. I played it, and throughout I was just thinking; "this is fucking Fo3 with mods built in". It's a pure copypasta of Fo3 with a new story and world tacked on top. At most it qualifies as an expansion or DLC, not a damned full price sequel. Contrast to Minecraft, which is almost painfully addictive and actually treads some new - and very fun - ground (something the larger studios seem to have a phobia of).

But no, unfortunately, AAA developers are never going to stop producing shovelware/games for PCs. Even with rampant piracy, they still make profit off the platform.
Weather or not you think new veags was jsut a glorified expansion pack is subjective, I loved that game and thourght it improved upon fallout 3 in every way

alot of good games are big releases, such as anyhting from bioware or valve, I like flashy graphics epic cutscnenes and lots of voice acting (if the game is good anyway) and I wil go to console if all I can ever play is minescraft or MMO's

and isnt AAA the oposite of shovelware? like that stuff you get on the wii
 

electric method

New member
Jul 20, 2010
208
0
0
Piracy could kill PC gaming. Will it? Maybe, maybe not. What is more likely in my opinion is that we'll see more and more intrusive DRM and other anti-piracy measures. As a result of that prices for games will go up even further even for non AAA releases. From there it's not all that much of a stretch to realize that the cost of gaming and games will more than likely be the undoing of the gaming industry.
 

Veylon

New member
Aug 15, 2008
1,626
0
0
Piracy can hurt PC gaming. A little. But it can't kill it.

It could, theoretically, drive away big developers like EA, Activision, and so on. But there are many thousands of smaller individuals that don't need over a hundred thousand sales to break even. You'd be saying goodbye to the huge budgets and vast quantities of content, but gaming would go on without them. Games would become more niche as the remaining companies sought out blocks of loyal and dependable customers.

I don't think this scenario is too likely, I think we'll just continue to see the big boys punch their customers in the face with unnecessary DRM in the vain hope that someday they'll actually hit a pirate. Prices will continue to go up to produce ever more impressive graphics for the CG-worshipping public. At some point, they're simply going to price themselves out of the market, but not for a little while yet. And that will hurt more than all the pirates ever born.
 

stiffy

New member
Mar 23, 2010
73
0
0
Aren't Wii and DS games super easy to crack? (I dont have either) I never hear that piracy will be the downfall of those systems.

DRM (at it's least obtrusive) winds up being like seeing the "you wouldn't steal a car..." PSAs they used to put on DVD's (remember those). The studios know it wont help the issue, but put it there as a glorified legal disclaimer. Like "hey we gave it our best shot, now please don't rip this"
 

ZippyDSMlee

New member
Sep 1, 2007
3,959
0
0
Its easier to to play day one 360 games than day one PC games, so no.
File sharing is generally a moot issue as you can not easily make something from nothing and that is what a copy is.
 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
stiffy said:
Aren't Wii and DS games super easy to crack? (I dont have either) I never hear that piracy will be the downfall of those systems.
I think the issue with PC is its easyer to pirate all you really need is an internet connection

anyway when I say PC gaming I don't mean WOW or farmville, games like that are a given, Im more worried about other genres like RPG's or action games or even FPS
 

Twilight_guy

Sight, Sound, and Mind
Nov 24, 2008
7,131
0
0
I think people will still develop for the PC. At some point, the internet will be so pervasive that requiring internet access is going to be like requiring hands. Nobody will care and the continuous internet checks will help prevent piracy (it will still get cracked but its an ongoing process not a stagnate goal).
 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
Twilight_guy said:
I think people will still develop for the PC. At some point, the internet will be so pervasive that requiring internet access is going to be like requiring hands. Nobody will care and the continuous internet checks will help prevent piracy (it will still get cracked but its an ongoing process not a stagnate goal).
in the mean time internet is still an issue for people like me but yes I do see things heading that way in the future

I hope Australia gets in new broadband thing into action, we are still stuck in the dark ageis (ok some of us are.....well I am)
 

stiffy

New member
Mar 23, 2010
73
0
0
Vault101 said:
when I say PC gaming I don't mean WOW or farmville, games like that are a given, I'm more worried about other genres like RPG's or action games or even FPS
That's a valid point. I always worry when a new title is released if I'll get a simultaneous PC release. AAA titles seem to be 'more of a hassle' to get released consistently on PC (Alan Wake, Gears2, AssCreed: Brotherhood, Deadspace 2 dlc, RED DEAD!!!!) I believe the motivation for developers is and always will be money. They simply sell more units on consoles. Their excuse is that the PC wont sell as much because of piracy is a cop out.
 

zsewq55912

New member
Feb 12, 2011
2
0
0
well yes in a way, but if your like thos ppl like me that play video games form the old days where you can't get it anyway, well i use ebay, by thos developers that or long died go for it, i think same body made a video heres the linkhttp://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/extra-credits/2653-Piracy
 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
stiffy said:
Vault101 said:
when I say PC gaming I don't mean WOW or farmville, games like that are a given, I'm more worried about other genres like RPG's or action games or even FPS
That's a valid point. I always worry when a new title is released if I'll get a simultaneous PC release. AAA titles seem to be 'more of a hassle' to get released consistently on PC (Alan Wake, Gears2, AssCreed: Brotherhood, Deadspace 2 dlc, RED DEAD!!!!) I believe the motivation for developers is and always will be money. They simply sell more units on consoles. Their excuse is that the PC wont sell as much because of piracy is a cop out.
agreed though Im pretty sure Assins creed brotherhood is coming to PC eventually

as for the Dead space DLC theres a bit of confusion there...but wasnt it actually on the disk? therefore technically with a bit of know-how possible to access? because DLC thats technically already there is a rip-off anyway

aIve always wanted ot play gears of war but its not worth getting an xbox...
 

viranimus

Thread killer
Nov 20, 2009
4,952
0
0
Honestly if anything is "killing" PC gaming... its PC gamers. I think it does a lot to put off people to have this constant superiority complex when it comes to PCs. People get this misconception that you have to have a 1000$ + gaming rig to even scratch min specs on games which is almost always false.

In a way devs want to kill it because of the misconceptions of Piracy on the PC. Also DRM techniques like Steam are not the solution because steam games are just as pirated as non steam games. Hell even VALVE games are pirated.

Could it happen? No. Not directly. The only way Piracy could kill PC gaming is if Devs just out and out refuse to develop for the platform. (which honestly seems silly, considering how most titles that come to release on PC are either piracy protected MMOs, or ports of existing console titles that 8/10 were initially developed on PC in order to create console versions.

I dunno, I see this as the merging of two obnoxious concepts that keep popping up individually, is PC gaming dying, and Piracy R bad.
 

Lordmarkus

New member
Jun 6, 2009
1,384
0
0
Well, it certainly has scared of triple A developers doing PC-centric games.

Will it kill of the PC gaming as a whole? No. Will it scare of more Triple A studios? Maybe, though it feels like we already hit the bottom.
 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
viranimus said:
Honestly if anything is "killing" PC gaming... its PC gamers. I think it does a lot to put off people to have this constant superiority complex when it comes to PCs. People get this misconception that you have to have a 1000$ + gaming rig to even scratch min specs on games which is almost always false.

In a way devs want to kill it because of the misconceptions of Piracy on the PC. Also DRM techniques like Steam are not the solution because steam games are just as pirated as non steam games. Hell even VALVE games are pirated.

Could it happen? No. Not directly. The only way Piracy could kill PC gaming is if Devs just out and out refuse to develop for the platform. (which honestly seems silly, considering how most titles that come to release on PC are either piracy protected MMOs, or ports of existing console titles that 8/10 were initially developed on PC in order to create console versions.

I dunno, I see this as the merging of two obnoxious concepts that keep popping up individually, is PC gaming dying, and Piracy R bad.
agreed and to be honest I can cope with ports..even bad ones just as long as I am able to play most games that come out Im happy

there are only two games I can think of off the top of my head the are PC exclusive and not MMO's

The witcher- which was boring as hell but Mbaye I should give it a secodn chance, plus if youre into that kind of thing more power to you

Starcraft- actually looks pretty cool and I havnt any RTS for a while though Im not sure the songle player holds up on its own
 

Lordmarkus

New member
Jun 6, 2009
1,384
0
0
Souplex said:
Vault101 said:
Souplex said:
It's already mortally wounded it, there's no way it can survive another half-decade against the various natural predators out there.
Arcade people were convinced arcades weren't going anywhere when they died.
PC game sales make up aboot 7% of the market, and that figure is shrinking.
I dont know if those figure factor in digital distribution...because if steam sales are anything to go by then there are still alot of people buying PC games
I got that figure from Michael Pachter, he keeps up to date on things like steam.

Steam users are a loud minority. If you shout loud enough, people will pay attention no matter what.
No, Mr. Pachter don't keep tabs on Steam. No one but Valve themselves keep tabs on the Steam sales and they never release salesnumbers. Thus making your argument invalid.

Though counting in digital distribution I don't think PC-game sales are over 20 % anyways.
 

TimeLord

For the Emperor!
Legacy
Aug 15, 2008
7,508
3
43
Not as long as my bank account stays linked to the TF2 Store it won't....