80Maxwell08 said:
Twilight_guy said:
Come on Escapist, one developer says he kind of thinking of doing something and all the sudden its a news story. The guy doesn't have a team, or rather the team that made the game, he's just one dude kicking around an idea. That doesn't mean anything. The guy probably has a dozen idea he's working with at any time and most never see the light of day. Why are people tripping over themselves to get behind this already. Gamers call the people who buy eery CoD or EA sport game a sheep and then they pay out the ass for any game that is a sequel to some old game they liked that got a kickstarter despite literally 0 evidence that it will be any good.
You do realize that the point of kickstarter isn't some glorified pre-order but to actually help fund it to get it off the ground in the first place? Just like people weren't just pre-ordering Double Fine Adventures, Wasteland 2, or Shadowrun but they were actually donating funds for it's full development. Also how is there no evidence that they can do a good job? Look at their past work for evidence.
Ohh, new quote button.... I like it.
Anyways, Just as almost every development studio has released crap games and good games despite having the same team, past experience does not mean that the result is going to be any good. I'm tired of people thinking 'It's from the guy who did X, it will be of the same quality/similar'. Yeah history is an indicator but people here treat it as if it's a be all end all. Oh, they did below there past standard, they must be sell-outs/incompetent/doomed, oh they made crap before, this new game is a fluke because its good, if this company made this game it would be just like this other game they made 20 years ago despite the fact that the dev team has all moved to other companies, oh this game must be bad, its from the people who made X. This kind of thinking really irks and it also strikes me in some instance as Nostalgia over logic. It bugs me and I'm going to post about it.
It also bothers me that this is a news story at all. Like I said, people kick around ideas all the time, most never get made. Are we going to post a news story every time a member of some development team on some old classic game thinks about maybe making another game? The Escapist would be posing a dozen stories a day on just that if they did. It seems like the guy just tossed out one of his ideas, one that he obviously doesn't have any plans of actually doing yet, and the Escapist published it because 'OMG, the people in the forums like Planescape right? They're read this!' despite it not really being anything that news worthy. I think that there must have been something more interesting that they could have written in place of this.