Points where you've disagreed with Yahtzee

Recommended Videos

SharPhoe

The Nice-talgia Kerrick
Feb 28, 2009
2,617
0
0
Personally, I can't help but disagree on the notion that all fighters are button-mashing fests. Then again, I'm a fighting game junkie who hasn't mashed buttons since the age of 8, so I may be a little biased.
 

reincarN8ed

New member
Mar 11, 2009
104
0
0
I disagreed with him once....it was a moment of weakness!

But seriously, I don't agree with the guy 100% of the time, but the way he delivers his criticism is just so damn funny I can't help but laugh even as he bashes my favorite game into dust!

Yahtzee = Win!
 

Remleiz

New member
Jan 25, 2009
630
0
0
Personally i think he's starting to run out steam...bile..whatever with his shows. They seem very lackluster and predictable now.

but back on topic;

he claims he doesnt like QTEs yet he seemed to imply that DMC4s FMVs would be better with them :S

i dont understand that
 

EdgeyX

Realms of Randomness
Mar 18, 2009
97
0
0
he was going on about how half life was amazing when i dident realy like it that much
 

Arcane Azmadi

New member
Jan 23, 2009
1,232
0
0
Although I occasionally think he comes down a bit too hard on a game (or even blatantly misrepresents things) the only times I have openly disagreed with him have been his assertions that "if you claim to enjoy EVE Online you are provably wrong" and that Madworld would have worked better if it hadn't been a Wii game. In the first case it was simply arrogance of the highest caliber to declare that hundreds of thousands of players subscribed to one of the most sucessful (if niche) MMORPGs of all time could not possibly be having fun and in the second it's obvious he didn't consider what the game actually WOULD have been like if it had been dumped on the PS3 or Xbox360 i.e a boring 3rd person button basher, albeit with awesome cartoony graphics and an over-the-top style (it's the visceral physicality of the controls that actually make the repetative slaughter bearable).
 

Gerazzi

New member
Feb 18, 2009
1,734
0
0
The littlebigplanet review, because the Idea of sackboy falling when you shift between planes is just a downright lie
 

IamQ

New member
Mar 29, 2009
5,226
0
0
BolognaBaloney said:
iamq said:
When he said it was stupid to unclock characters in SSB I dissagree.
No I agree with him on this one, purely because it sucks to bring a game over to play at with friends, and you only have the few starting characters/maps/guns whatever it may be
Well, I don't care if you agree with him, you can't just say no to my oppinion.
 

LeonLethality

New member
Mar 10, 2009
5,810
0
0
StarStruckStrumpets said:
LeonHellsvite said:
Hmmm I see him as a humour kind of reviewer, I often can disagree and thats fine I also (about 70% of the time) agree with him, I dont agree how he hates JRPG's but someone doesnt like JRPG's what else is new?
This. I can't understand his/anyone's hate for J-RPG's. The only arguable points i've heard are:

1) Turn based combat sucks...
2) The character design makes them look too young.

Then there are the idiots who's only arguement is that it is Japanese. That's just un-justifyable prejudice. Aside from the rant...most J-RPG's I play don't have these faults.
Well I love turn based combat especialy eternal sonata's that was fun. and for charachter design yeah I gotta agree except when its ment to make them look young (but I got a hell of a suprise in ff6 to find locke was 25 o.o) but for the most part I understand preferences I'm not a big FPS fan, I still play them just dont like most of them, and I just dont like how jrpg haters bash jrpg fans
 

Quickening666

New member
May 7, 2008
150
0
0
Well like the AVGN, Yahtzee is trying to be entertaining so he'll rip into a game harder just for the sake of entertainment and he has even acknowledged that people prefer him not to like a game.
The one thing I really disagree with him on is The Witcher. It's an awesome game.
 

The Dr0w Ranger

New member
Jan 8, 2009
58
0
0
I Loved Butcher Bay, and hated Dark Athena.
That game is not simply a Jack-Off for Vin Diesel, it's an actual good stealth game.
 

fff555f4

New member
May 13, 2009
26
0
0
thats why i like him he will say stuff that just can piss people of like my freind was so pissed by what he said about killzone2 (he is a ps3 fanboy)
 

Crabid

New member
Feb 21, 2008
52
0
0
Only 2 games he reviewed I have cared about and disagreed with:

Farcry 2 - is a terrible game in every single way, on the hardest difficulty some guns jam after 21 shots! And the story and quests are totally abysmal, along with the suitcase of F*$K all diamonds at the end... I had more in my back pocket!

Crysis - got palmed off as a game that was just pretty. Imo the openworld gameplay aspects in crysis are simply unsurpassed, though delta difficulty is a little easy. That said the linear gameplay for the second half sucks hard, and the sequel can just go die somewhere.

Other than that I think he's too nice to all the console rubbish that keeps getting churned out.
 

BolognaBaloney

New member
Mar 17, 2009
2,672
0
0
iamq said:
BolognaBaloney said:
iamq said:
When he said it was stupid to unclock characters in SSB I dissagree.
No I agree with him on this one, purely because it sucks to bring a game over to play at with friends, and you only have the few starting characters/maps/guns whatever it may be
Well, I don't care if you agree with him, you can't just say no to my oppinion.
Your "oppinion" as you put it, is just that, yours, so I can in fact so no to it, as it is not the "oppinion" that I share.