Poll: Best War Leader

Recommended Videos

KissofKetchup

New member
May 26, 2008
702
0
0
SckizoBoy said:
KissofKetchup said:
Aku_San said:
Gen. Robert E. Lee
I was starting to lose faith in this forum before I saw that you posted his name.

Without a doubt, one of the greatest military tacticians and strategists of all time.
I'm inclined to agree, but his military philosophy left a bit to be desired. Towards the end of the ACW, he kept seeking out a decisive battle and frittered away a fair bit of his army that by the time he got his battle, his troops were tired and quite the worse for wear. I'll have to check up on this...

Though people, tell me more about the American Civil War... as an Englishman, I remain sorely ignorant about it.
About what you said about him towards the end of the war, I would argue that he needed to do so because by that time his supply chain was considerably worse for wear (especially because it was horrible to begin with). Lee undoubtedly could not keep his army in a combat effective state for very much longer by that time and needed a decisive victory that could end the war.

And since you asked for it, the Civil War wasn't really started over the issue of slavery. It was started over the issue of states' rights versus the power of the federal government. However, President Lincoln effectively made the war about slavery with the Emancipation Proclamation.
 

KissofKetchup

New member
May 26, 2008
702
0
0
SckizoBoy said:
MrJKapowey said:
3. Bernard Montgommery - Beat the excellent Erwin Rommel - and my personal faviroute just because he was pretty unorthodox.
Grrr! Arg! [small]in the best spirit[/small] I'm going to have to check, but I'm fairly sure that the 15th & 21st PzDivs were single tank regiment divisions (and often under strength). Sure Monty won, but he kinda made a meal of it, and XXXCorps was much more powerful than AK. And I will forever rail at him for Op MarketGarden. Patton! You're up!
Agreed. Monty was pretty overrated.
 

Zyxzy

New member
Apr 16, 2009
343
0
0
I'll put forth Jan Zizka as one. Real innovator, never lost a battle.

KissofKetchup said:
SckizoBoy said:
MrJKapowey said:
3. Bernard Montgommery - Beat the excellent Erwin Rommel - and my personal faviroute just because he was pretty unorthodox.
Grrr! Arg! [small]in the best spirit[/small] I'm going to have to check, but I'm fairly sure that the 15th & 21st PzDivs were single tank regiment divisions (and often under strength). Sure Monty won, but he kinda made a meal of it, and XXXCorps was much more powerful than AK. And I will forever rail at him for Op MarketGarden. Patton! You're up!
Agreed. Monty was pretty overrated.
Hey, he put on a good show in the Ardennes.
 

Whoatemysupper

New member
Aug 20, 2010
285
0
0
rutger5000 said:
The champion by far, Rommel a.k.a The Dessert Fox. Greatest general of all time, had Hitler used him a little better we'd all be speaking German now.
Dessert Fox? Sounds tasty.