Poll: Breastfeeding in public

Recommended Videos

Dags90

New member
Oct 27, 2009
4,683
0
0
Flare Phoenix said:
Yeah I've never quite understood why the nipple is apparently the sexual part. Like you can show a picture of a completely topless woman and if the nipple is covered up that is apparently okay.
I asked, facetiously of course, if it would be OK to post pictures of topless women as long as I photoshopped a man's nipples over their obscene lady parts.

Also, someone above posted that men having nipples at all is a genetic defect, that's really sloppy terminology. It would be more appropriate to call them vestigial.
 

Nigh Invulnerable

New member
Jan 5, 2009
2,500
0
0
Xenetethrae said:
Arkhangelsk said:
Xenetethrae said:
blah blah blah blah blah blah
So you're saying that all mothers should be locked inside their house all their lives? As someone who knows a person who has to stay indoors 100% of her time, it's a fucking dreadful experience. If I personally couldn't leave the house, I'd probably off myself.

Geez, some people here seem to be looking at mothers like they're doing a disservice to humanity for raising a baby.
No. No one said that. Too much hate and not enough humor in this thread.

Mommy can fill up a bottle ahead of time if she's going out in public and is bringing her potentially hungry baby.
Filling a spare bottle or two is sometimes easier said than done. Not all women produce equal amounts of milk.
 

Ultrajoe

Omnichairman
Apr 24, 2008
4,719
0
0
dududf said:
Ultrajoe said:
How dare, how dare I say, that woman drag herself out of the house where she might inconvenience you with the sight of a perfectly natural phenomenon.

Come on, boyo, she went through nine months of relative hell and then squeezed a baby out of a hole severely undersized for the job. Now you want her to stay at home, too? Post-natal depression gets so many women in part because of the isolation you'd see mothers go through to prevent you seeing a nipple. You're perfectly justified in not wanting to see it, but she's also perfectly justified in wanting to go out on occasion. Babies get hungry at all hours, man, she's just got to go with the very literal flow.
Counter point, washrooms are relatively private areas, why can't they go to there? They are very literally all over the place, malls, stores, resteraunts, you name it and it probably has a washroom. The only inconvienance to the mother is probably about 20 steps, and it diminishes any awkwardness on either ends.

Not to say I'm against it as it doesn't bother me, but the opportunity is always there.
Except that implying it's socially wrong to be seen breastfeeding your child makes having one an effective taboo. The social isolation of mothers is already awful, and if you make it a social convention to think 'What I'm doing is awful to see', how do you think that makes them feel? Their boobs are spitting out dairy product, the last thing you want to do is insert the idea that this is somehow wrong. As I said, Post-natal depression can be triggered by feelings of oppression or rejection from the community (In conjunction with hormone imbalances of course). Do you really want to tell women that they can, out of politeness, take themselves and their baby to the toilet to eat?

I know you're not against public breastfeeding, but as an option; 'go to the toilet' is basically enforcing millenia of conditioning that says the female body is dirty. Let's not.
 

dududf

New member
Aug 31, 2009
4,072
0
0
Ultrajoe said:
Fair 'nuff regarding how the mother would feel and I agree on the point that the last thing you'd want mothers to feel is embarassment when they are already are ever so confined as they are.
 

TheLaofKazi

New member
Mar 20, 2010
840
0
0
There are at least a million things that deeply annoy me about people. I think it's a bit unreasonable to expect someone to stop doing something just because it annoys or disgusts you, even more so to want to make it illegal (not saying the OP said that). The moment we turn to inflexible laws to solve problems of simply dealing with people's tiny little things they do out in public is the moment, I think, when we've forgot how to be humans. Society is pretty much dealing with other people. You can have your opinions on what's appropriate and what's not, but what it comes down to is stuff like this simply doesn't matter.
 

WolfThomas

Man must have a code.
Dec 21, 2007
5,292
0
0
Well I personaly don't believe getting your breasts out in public should be a crime, even if not breastfeeding. Any situation where it's appropriate for a man to be topless, a woman should be able to be if she wants.

As for breast-feeding, I've got nothing wrong with that being done in public, it's an important part of child-raising and completely natural. That said I personally object to the minority of mothers who think it's acceptable to change a nappy/diaper in a public place, especially a restaurant. That's a health and safety issue, right there. Plus it's gross.
 

Johnnyallstar

New member
Feb 22, 2009
2,928
0
0
Amazing how something natural like that can be so reviled by people. It also amazes me how many people are so aghast at nudity. Of course, we are almost infantile about nudity anyways, because the vast majority of people anymore cannot appreciate nudity in art, but see it as only a means of perversion, not beauty.

I just wish people could be more mature about such things.
 

TheEldestScroll

New member
Feb 20, 2011
131
0
0
i'm for it. i mean why not?
its not like its a super common issue anyways.

but if i were a woman, i probably wouldn't want to expose my boobies in public, but thats just me. i've never been offended by boobies, so again, why not?
 

Rayne870

New member
Nov 28, 2010
1,250
0
0
it just bothers me because i dont know how to react to it. when we were more primitive and less prudish it wasnt a problem but now breasts are overly sexuallized and we dont know how to react to a woman pulling them out for a non sexual purpose.

if its someone a few tables away or something like that i can deal with it and just not look at it, i mean its not my business and staring at a woman without her boob out is awkward enough. i have had some experiences where it was extended family members during conversations and just pop out comes the boob up comes the baby and they keep talking like its nothing. i get it you're comfortable with breast feeding but i'm not really comfortable with it and i feel rude no matter what i do.

ive matured a lot lately with a lot of different perspectives on issues and this one still just sort of sits there smacking me in the back of the head.

tbh i think i just need to be told by the person how i should feel about it and i would probably be fine. and i guess im mostly scared about having a wandering eye or something.
 

Rayne870

New member
Nov 28, 2010
1,250
0
0
Marik2 said:
Well I dont know, Ive never seen a woman breastfeed in public so I cant really say if I would be against or for it.

You should put a I dont know option btw.

Edit: Ah heres a good vid on the subject
hey thanks for that video, it introduced me to a great series and i learned a lot about myself and, i think im a better person for having watched those experiments.
 

The Apothecarry

New member
Mar 6, 2011
1,051
0
0
While it's not exactly courteous to breastfeed in public, a crying child isn't pleasant to listen to either.

I suppose it depends on location. At a park, I could care less but if a woman is breastfeeding in a restaurant, I'll kindly look the other way but I won't deny feeling awkward about it.
 

iamthe1

New member
Mar 16, 2011
71
0
0
UUUUUUUUHHHHHHHHH............ get the fuck over it, dude.

Seriously? This is the most mind-fuckingly stupid thing I have ever read on this site. I think I just shat myself reading that.

How does this have 393 replies?
 

Womplord

New member
Feb 14, 2010
390
0
0
I don't see the big deal about breast feeding in public. You can't even see the nipple for a start, and it's perfectly natural (okay, I know a penis is perfectly natural, but it isn't necessary to pull it out and it's necessary to eat).
 

robincb

New member
Apr 23, 2008
54
0
0
Bakuryukun said:
also breastfeeding is shown to help the mother-child bonding process, if people have a problem with it, maybe THEY should leave. Also I don't really think breastfeeding counts as "public nudity" seeing as there's a large baby head in the way.
Yeah im going to wave my schlong around in your face, it has been proven to increase my masculinity, if someone has a problem with it maybe THEY should leave. i don't really think it counts as public nudity seeing as your face is in the way.


Carry on.
 

jack_hectic

New member
Dec 24, 2008
30
0
0
Galliam said:
I understand the desire to be free to feed your child, but I don't understand why Im such a terrible person for thinking that it should be a more private action.
i don't think you are such a terrible person. most people cannot tolerate those who disagree. it is a means of (re)enforcing their reality tunnel.

that being said, i think it is an awful pity that it happens around you so often that it affects your public dining experience, and an awful pity that you are unable to visually shrug it off.

DID YOU KNOW?
...that the human ear and audio processing centers of the brain are able to tune in and tune out audio? you are mentally able to mix the audio you are hearing. basically, if you don't like what you are hearing, and there is some other sound present, you can focus so completely on the second (less unpleasant) sound, that you become completely (consciously) unaware of that first, (more unpleasant) sound.

your ears and brain are set up to do this naturally! BUT you can also enhance this ability by training your mind.

you are essentially doing the same thing with your eyes when you stare at your food! maybe you can train your visual mind as well?
 

jack_hectic

New member
Dec 24, 2008
30
0
0
Caligulas.dog said:
Does anyone who's not an American actually give a damn about this topic? I am from Germany, have been to most countries in Europe, and I never ever found someone who was actually offended. But then again, on most of our beaches its allowed to take down your bra to sunbathe. Americans are strange.
i guess i am taking the European view on this "issue."

in public, i do look away from bare-breasts in general, simply for the courtesy; in this land, the "proud patriotic," "morally upstanding," "deeply faithful," and "tremendously thick" are still organized and (somehow) esteemed enough to have a voice in our government. so nudity is frowned upon, and if something like a gust of wind blows up a woman's skirt, it is also frowned upon to leer at them like they're a cheeseburger and you're a fatso (...yet if attractive young guys take off their shirts in public, i fully expect housewives and spinsters to blush, and start gossiping to close-by friends breathlessly, the stereotype goes). the whole attitude is generally of AVOIDANCE. "problems may arise with naked people around. so lets just nip them problems in the bud, mkay?"

if i remember correctly, in this country, the "7 deadly words you cannot say on television" were originally started because of an alabama PREACHER who wrote to his radio station to COMPLAIN because he did not like CERTAIN WORDS in the radio broadcast.

do take note, freedom of religion and freedom of speech were protected in the same amendment. maybe the infant government of this country perceived that attacks on speech would be made by religions, and decided to put them both in the same amendment so to attack one would shoot yourself in the foot.

did he own that radio station?

this is the whole point i am getting at. this preacher could have changed the station; took matters of what he was going to listen to on his radio into his own hands. but maybe im wrong! maybe every station was full of loud, profane, raunchy homosexual relations and jazz, and this guy had a long day of dealing with his parish' comparatively pale problems while he's wresting with things like "is it homophobia or latent homosexuality?" maybe it was raining out, and his candles got wet, so he could neither go for a walk nor read in silence. maybe his only choice for any kind of entertainment that evening besides silent meditation was the radio. and maybe that area had only one station, i bet radio was expensive back than.

but couldn't he just turn it off and go to bed early?

in any case im getting away from the issue and what i wanted to ask. i generally feel like most of american attitudes to sexuality and nudity are rather restrictive and sheltered. and yet, going to the beach i am still uncomfortable being naked around other people. for some reason its like theres less of their bodily fluids getting into the water as well when theyre clothed. and that nothing else in the ocean defecates and urinates and ejaculates in the water. theres lots of nonsensical beliefs like this in our stupid culture. so why couldnt i strip nude and hang out in water with a bunch of other nude primates?

that i dont know. wish i did. BUT, german fellow! question!

in your country, is it impolite to take a girl to the beach for a date? say you've only dated about a week, and you'd want to see her nude. or do you guys have that attitude to nudity? for that matter, whats your side of the world's attitude to pornography? would the girl just tell you to fuck off if you suggested a beach-date that early in the relationship? would she feel socially obligated to go since its only swimming, and not fucking?

i actually want to know the answers to this, if you feel you can provide them?