Sexy Devil said:
I don't know why people were actually expecting a victory from the refusal ending. The whole game was spent building up the fact that the crucible is literally the only hope. They've said that subtle tactics just outright fail, and guerrilla tactics do way more damage to their side than they do to the Reapers. Everyone's been saying that if they go in there guns blazing without the crucible then they're going to flat out lose. Then everyone gets pissed when the "go in there guns blazing" option causes a flat out loss? Seriously, wat?
I had this argument on Kotaku back when the endings were released and they kept saying "Shepard should have done something!" What was Shepard supposed to have done? The only thing (s)he could have tried was shooting the starchild, which you could try; other than that (s)he was stranded on the platform and couldn't do anything. Doing anything else would have been the mother of all ass pulls - which was the problem with the original endings in the first place. And having guerrilla tactics work after three games of buildup saying that they wouldn't would have just been retarded.
The only way the galaxy was going to win in a direct confrontation was if one reaper tripped on a space rock, therefore falling and causing a domino effect of falling reapers while the benny hill theme played.
You're being a little misrepresentative of the quote I posted. The Refusal ending was only added as a "Fuck you" by Bioware, DESPITE it being the absolute only *logical* option and also the only option that a freedom-seeking Sheppard would pick.
As the quote I posted said, why would you even consider trusting a being that has killed literally quadrillions of sentient beings over the past billion years? Listening to the God-child and following one of his options is giving up the freedom that you've spent three entire games fighting for, the ability to pick your own destiny, consequences be damned.
I don't think people were expecting the refusal ending to actually succeed (though it'd be nice to have your EMS actually DO something), but they were at least expecting that option from the start rather than having it given to us as a kick in the gut like it is right now. It's clear they only added it in as salt in the wounds, when the option, dumb as it may be, should have been there from the start.