Poll: Do we nice guys still stand a chance?

Recommended Videos

Floppertje

New member
Nov 9, 2009
1,056
0
0
gamer_parent said:
snippity snip snip
helpful post is helpful, thanks bro. I think I've actually got most of it down. I think my biggest problem is that I'm really awful at reading women. when I'm talking to one at a party, I never know when to ask her to dance, when to get closer, when to kiss her (although the last bit went by itself the one time it happened)
also, I apparently think girls are interested too soon. there was this girl who asked me to go with her to the train station after a party, which I took to mean 'I don't want to say goodbye just yet', so the next time it happened I asked her out, and she was totally surprised (and, due to a personal crisis, panicked and gave the worst possible answer. EVER.). then there was this other girl who I could've sworn was flirting with me. except she was British and apparently flirting works differently there. who knew girls were wired by postal codes?
 

DeadeyeDuck89

New member
Sep 22, 2010
3
0
0
Hi all,

I'm a Brit, with (and I think this is a huge stroke of luck) a steady, attractive girlfriend.

However I do think there's something to this post. It does appear that all the girls are only really interested in the stereotypical "strong, sporty asshole". Now I won't for a minute pretend that I'm not an asshole sometimes, but then who isn't? The fact is I have tried for over 2o years to be as kind and considerate as I can, and has it gotten me anywhere (my girlfriend and I got together in August 2010)??

Like hell it has.
 

DeadeyeDuck89

New member
Sep 22, 2010
3
0
0
Selvec, you may have just hit the nail squarely on the head, as they say. But the problem, how do you go about "outing" the douchebag? Because in my experience (and I don't mean to generalise here) a startling percentage of women don't seem to see past the muscles/car/money until it's too late. And by then, it is just that, too late.

I maintain that do make an excellent point though.
 

irani_che

New member
Jan 28, 2010
630
0
0
guy here
there is one girl, i had a thing with here best freind, I didnt go for her at all and just talked to her like a friend, then, long after me and her friend broke up i asked her out just for the hell of it, she said "oh god yes" and she has been the closest girl i have ever been with, and possibly the only for now.

Moral: do not worry about girls, because indifference and irrence seem to attract them the best
 

Nickompoop

New member
Jan 23, 2011
495
0
0
This as probably already been said, but screw it, I'm saying it anyways.
It's not about niceness, it's about confidence. It's amazing how well women respond to confidence. Douchebags usually have huge amounts of confidence, often well within the realm of planet-sized egos. That's why they get all the chicks.
For the record, I'm a straight male.

EDIT:
Floppertje said:
I think my biggest problem is that I'm really awful at reading women. when I'm talking to one at a party, I never know when to ask her to dance, when to get closer, when to kiss her
This is my biggest problem. It is ridiculous how hard it is to read women.
 

Astoria

New member
Oct 25, 2010
1,887
0
0
Urgh I am really sick of hearing about this. No girls are not only atrracted to 'bad boys'. You only notice that because it they are the most noticable. A vast majority of us girls are just looking for someone who will love us for who we are and who we can love in return. Have you considered that maybe you are just going after the wrong kind of girls. There are just as many girls stuck in the 'friend zone' as there are guys. Both genders have their jerks and both genders have their nice guys and girls who get rejected for said jerks.
 

Black Phoenix

Iridescence
Sep 19, 2010
166
0
0
Ledan said:
Second, and most important to you I think, there is always someone who is interested. Seriously. You just need to start looking around, maybe at the girls you've never considered before. Most guys, me especially, are oblivious to the small signs girls give out when they have an attraction to someone.
Quite funny that you mention that, given that I'd just been thinking recently that in the 24 years I've been kicking around this planet, I've never met anyone who I'd have said was even vaguely interested in me.

Then again, I also know that the nearest to subtlety I can pick up on is a metaphorical sledgehammer to the face, so that might be part of my problem...
 

Doclector

New member
Aug 22, 2009
5,010
0
0
Mr S said:
OtherSideofSky said:
Not a girl but I would just like to say that I am rather distrustful of anyone claiming themselves to be "nice". A lot of them aren't. Just saying.

Also: The obligatory "Not this thread again."

On a bit of a tangent for anyone interested, however. I will say with relative authority (based on experience) that even mildly autistic people don't really have a snowball's chance in Hell, especially if crowds and loud noises throw them off (not uncommon). You would be amazed at what the medically certified inability to flirt, recognize flirting, consistently recognize emotions from facial expressions or pick up on any of the million social queues which apparently make up the bizarre cat-and-mouse game people have made out of relationships can do to hurt your chances. Being confident or outgoing simply fail to matter when you lack these basic abilities and can't do anything about it. This also has the unfortunate side effect of giving you a very good reason to fear other people (I've heard they can smell fear).

LiquidGrape said:
I'll just leave this here. [http://www.heartless-bitches.com/rants/niceguys/nice2.shtml]
Thank you so much for posting that. I've been trying to find it again for ages, but I couldn't remember the name.
Well ain't that just peachy. I AM mildly autistic and I have huge difficulty noticing if people are flirting back or whatever. Well since you've claimed.there's no hope for me anymore I'm just gonna go head and become a monk or whatever :(
Hey, me too! Maybe we should form the autistic alliance and protest for...well, I dunno, evil dead 4 or something.

What!? If we don't do it, who will?

I realise my aspergers ain't helping but I think the bigger problem may be that I'm more or less a completely useless Human being. A great filmmaker one day, maybe but as a person, I fail. I ain't attractive, I ain't good at anything interesting and I don't fit in with any established social group. Add in a considerable amount of instability due to severe bullying, and it becomes easy to see why people hate me.

But I guess my point is that autistic people do stand a chance, there just has to be enough of a person left.

And being attractive is a must. Im sure we all know how shallow most people are.
 

DanDeFool

Elite Member
Aug 19, 2009
1,891
0
41
A point that may not have been brought up yet.

The fact that girls seem to like jerks more than 'nice guys' might have a lot to do with dating being, in general, a numbers game.

What makes a 'jerk' such a jerk? A big part of it is probably that he doesn't seem to care about anybody but himself.

However, in the dating scene, that can work to your advantage. If you don't care about anybody but yourself, you're not worried about bothering or inconveniencing a woman you're interested in when you're trying to decide whether or not to talk to her. She's not even part of the equation. If you want to talk to her, you just do it. If she rejects you, whatever. Move on to the next one.

And of course, over time, guys who approach women over and over, even if they get shot down 80% to 90% of the time, will eventually start to figure out what works and what doesn't when it comes to sparking a woman's interest.

A lot of 'nice guys' I know hardly approach women at all. Because they hardly approach women at all, they have very little chance of finding a woman that's available and interested in a relationship (there's plenty of them out there, even if they make up a relatively small proportion of the female population), and even if they did find and approach one, they have so little experience that they just don't know what to do.

This is a big problem with 'nice guys'. They tend to put other people's interests before their own, all the time, even when it doesn't make sense for them to do so. Really, that's no way to go through life. It's okay to have wants and needs, and it's okay to go out into the world and get the things you want and need for yourself. It doesn't make you selfish, or a user (not necessarily).

So the next time you see an attractive young lady walking down the street, remember that she probably gets guys rolling up to her all the time. All. The. Time. So go ahead and start a conversation with her. See if you can get her number. If it doesn't work out, who cares? It's only a minor inconvenience to her, and for you, it's just one potential avenue that didn't work out out of THOUSANDS (tens of thousands, if you live in a big city). When it comes to dating, the individual encounter doesn't really matter. What matters is that you got some experience points. ;)
 

rutger5000

New member
Oct 19, 2010
1,052
0
0
Not to be arrogant: But I'm the nicest guy I know in my direct environment, I'm also Dutch and I have no problems with getting girls.Be confident and yourself, sure it's the most cliche advice there is, but if you truly follow it it works.
And yeah like some guy above me said. You do have to approach them and be prepared to be shot down 90% of the time. A friend of mine once told me he approaches women with the expectation that he is going to be shot down. Don't know if that really is a good idea, but it makes sense to me.
 

Eri

The Light of Dawn
Feb 21, 2009
3,626
0
0
It's funny how people say nice guys are the manipulative or have no confidence ones etc which is generalizing the entire nice guy group meanwhile they were basically bashing the "nice" guy for generalizing women as only dating jerks.

Yo dawg I heard you like generalizing so we put some generalizations in your generalizer so you can generalize while you generalize.
 

JoJo

and the Amazing Technicolour Dream Goat 🐐
Moderator
Legacy
Mar 31, 2010
7,170
143
68
Country
🇬🇧
Gender
♂
Doclector said:
And being attractive is a must. Im sure we all know how shallow most people are.
To an extent attractiveness is subjective depending on the person, I for example find women on the slightly overweight side very attractive, despite that not being the "norm" for attractiveness.

OT: Sure, nice guys stand a great chance, however it helps if you have other traits as well such as confidence. Don't give up, the perfect woman is out there somewhere!
 

rmb1983

I am the storm.
Mar 29, 2011
253
0
0
Mr S said:
This question is for all the ladies (especially the Dutch ones):
Are girls still interested in nice guys or is there really no more hope for us?

It has recently (past 17 years) come to my attention that a lot of men act like jerks in front of women, and the women seem to be enjoying it. Which leads me to think that women nowadays are attracted to complete douches.

(Un)fortunately, I don't belong to that specific group, and I consider myself to be a nice and confident guy.
In fact, my last date said it wasn't gonna work out because I was too nice.
Now I've tried to be a jerk, but I don't like myself anymore when I do that.
And neither do other people, so it would seem I am doing something terribly wrong.

Is there still any chance for us? We are just regular guys, except for that we aren't complete douches.

Also I've noticed that especially city girls are attracted to jerks, please comment on that too :)

Ok, I've read the replies and I'd like to delve deeper in the "some do like nice guys, some like jerks" thing. Now I believe that. Problem is I can't seem to find the ones that like nice guys. I just run into jerk-loving girls OR girls that already are in relations with other nice guys.
This is all superfluous. I'm quoting you to get your attention.
In addition, to everyone else in this thread, this is all complete and utter nonsense.

"Nice guys finish last...but we finish best."

Alternatively, stop angling for daft women.
 

gamer_parent

New member
Jul 7, 2010
611
0
0
Floppertje said:
gamer_parent said:
snippity snip snip
helpful post is helpful, thanks bro. I think I've actually got most of it down. I think my biggest problem is that I'm really awful at reading women. when I'm talking to one at a party, I never know when to ask her to dance, when to get closer, when to kiss her (although the last bit went by itself the one time it happened)
also, I apparently think girls are interested too soon. there was this girl who asked me to go with her to the train station after a party, which I took to mean 'I don't want to say goodbye just yet', so the next time it happened I asked her out, and she was totally surprised (and, due to a personal crisis, panicked and gave the worst possible answer. EVER.). then there was this other girl who I could've sworn was flirting with me. except she was British and apparently flirting works differently there. who knew girls were wired by postal codes?
"Wired by postal code" sounds like it could be an awesome song, just sayin'.

Glad to be of help. Well, there are a couple of things you when it comes to girl's receptiveness towards your advances, a lot of it you can get tail-tells from physical touch. Obviously, things like grabbing her hand while sitting there might be too much, but then things like just sitting there cuddling are way too vague. However, in MOST cases, there are little things you can try. i.e. if you're sitting across from her, touch the side of your foot to her foot, if she feels it, and immediately recoils, it's still too early. Apologize immediately about stepping on her foot, pretend you didn't mean to do it, and play it off.

another one is when you guys are trying to make it through a crowd. If YOU know where you're going, and she doesn't, just grab her hand and pull her along. It will look like you're just trying to make sure she doesn't lose you in the crowd. If she recoils right there, well, might as well give up there. But if she doesn't? well, still not a definite yet. But AFTER you guys are through, see what she does. If she let's go first, hmm... maybe too early. but it could also be TOTALLY natural for her too... in which case... something to think about.

the point is, you gotta know how to advance in small increments to test the waters. (if you're the sort who wants to play it cool) Now, if you're NOT the sort who is afraid of getting rejected, well, I've seen a guy walk up to a girl and say, "hey, you wanna get out of here?" as his opening line and get the girl. The guy in question was a friend of mine back in college, and he basically did a shotgun approach, doing this to easily over 20 girls that night. Can't say much for his character, but hey, the math works.

Now, there's a caveat to all of this. Some girls are NOT comfortable with physical contact, even if they have good feelings about a guy. My sister was like that growing up, which was why she pretty much never dated. In THOSE situations, well... this is where being the patient stoic helps. But that's a whole different thing all together.

Also, physical contact is also why I suggest guys who want to have an easier time dating take up dancing. I don't mean something like say, break dancing or some solo performance. there's nothing wrong with those kinds of dances, it's just that for the purpose of establishing physical contact, it's not as effective. No, I mean social dancing like say, ballroom or tango. Knowing how to do this is like having a cheat. Want to know more about a girl and her temperament without having to take timid steps around her? Salsa or Tango to the rescue! See here, you establish instant physical contact, and if you're any good, you make her feel AWESOME on the dance floor. Obviously, because we're talking about social dancing, certain conventions like how appropriate is it to grab a girl's hand right away are now gone. But here's the beauty of it: when you dance with a girl, you generally can get a very good feeling on how she feels about you. Physical chemistry is one of the most POWERFUL components of attraction. While there is no sure fire way of fostering physical chemistry (short of some voodoo PUA stuff), a dance is the ultimate litmus test of your physical chemistry together. If there is none, no sweat. You still got a dance out of her, and she might just be really cool. If she seems into you? JACKPOT!!
 

The Stonker

New member
Feb 26, 2009
1,557
0
0
First of all.


MAN UP!

Second of all.

WATCH MY LITTLE PONY!
Now back to the real points.

You see, this world is complex son, we have fat people,skinny people,wicked people and kind people.
But the thing is that if you want a woman then you have to do something more then just be "nice" trust me, you probably have some physical attributes and what the "nice guy" needs to do, is establish RIGHT IN THE BEGINNING, that there is chance for a romantic encounter(because being nice is more of a bonus then anything else and establishing something like that takes confidence).
I'm personally, a bit chubby, arrogant and cocky, but I still manage to get women.
How?
Well, I have something called being a gentleman and humor, dem bitches loooove humor.

But good luck man.
Btw. Self pity and depression HUGE turn-offs.