I thought it had been proven that Sonic '06 is objectively better than Portal [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.395876-Sonic-06-Objectively-Better-Than-Portal] going by modern standards. So the sheer amount of no votes, and the bias in number of no choices in comparison to yes choices is confusing to me.
Seriously though, I actually had moments and flickers of legitimate fun (as opposed to so bad, it's good fun), which is more I can say than some games I've played that are rated higher than it and it has a legitimately awesome soundtrack (like pretty much every Sonic game) so I voted yes.
It seems you've caught me in one of my moments where I actually look back somewhat fondly on the game XD
And finally, I'll post one of the pieces of music from that soundtrack I mentioned earlier.