Poll: Do You Think A Game With A Homosexual Lead Could Survive?

Recommended Videos

Svenparty

New member
Jan 13, 2009
1,346
0
0
I cannot see how it would tie into things...yeah Alyx Vance could have been Alex Vance "dick in pants". But it would offend more people if you put gay themes in a game for no other reason than to show support.

Personally I'm still waiting for Oscar Wilde:The Videogame to provide Me with Rentboys and Absinthe Parties.
 

Syphous

New member
Apr 6, 2009
833
0
0
Who cares? Why would this even come up in the game your playing? Does your character have to collect as many dicks as possible or something?
 

FredFredburgur

New member
Apr 13, 2009
206
0
0
It doesn't matter if they are gay, straight, black, white, human, monster, or anything, as long as the game itself is good people are gonna enjoy it, however not to be rude I wouldn't be surprised if that had a minority as the lead
(are homosexuals considered a minority? I'm not really sure I don't mean to offend, but I also want to include other minorities, sorry if that is politically incorrect)
and was not a good game or received success would have some people blame the fact of the main character.
 

Thanatos34

New member
Mar 31, 2009
389
0
0
If the lead character is gay, then I don't think I would relate to him nearly as much as if he was not. I most likely would not buy the game. Plus, I would think any kiss/sex scenes were gross. (I think homosexuality is fine, but, tbh, I still get a sick feeling when I see it being practiced, because I am not attracted to guys.)

I think having the option there is fine, but if it is forced, then that would seriously hurt the game's sales, because only around 3-4% of the population are gay/lesbian, and of the other 96-97%, a lot of them would not "get" it, and many would be repulsed by it.

It might be able to survive, but the game's sales would be hurt, and thus it would be a strange company that would make a game knowing it's sales will be hurt, not because of how good the game is, but because of what content is in it.

Now if you are asking if it could survive if it is an option, then of course it could survive, other games already have done so.
 

Abedeus

New member
Sep 14, 2008
7,412
0
0
TheTygerfire said:
The DSM said:
Mass Effect kinda did, the blue alien is what I would consider to be female and there is the option to do the sub-plot with it , and as long as its a good game id buy it.
The blue alien IS female....
No. They don't have genders. They only look female to other races. That's why they can reproduct with anyone.
 

Simalacrum

Resident Juggler
Apr 17, 2008
5,204
0
0
if it was criticised then anyone who tried to do so would be ritually sacrificed by gay-rights campaigners

edit: even if it was a shit game
 

man-man

Senior Member
Jan 21, 2008
163
0
21
FredFredburgur said:
are homosexuals considered a minority?
Well... statistically speaking yes, they are a smaller component of the population than heterosexuals. I don't know if they would be called "a minority" in the same way as certain ethnic groups are, but they are in the minority as far as numbers go.

As for the question at hand, I think it comes down to how the lead being gay has an effect on the game. If it's entirely irrelevant because the game has nothing to do with their sexuality, then it's an interesting footnote that people may or may not even notice. If the game is full of sex and hence full of homosexual sex... well people might be a tad uncomfortable with playing that, especially if they aren't gay themselves. People freak out enough when there's hetero sex in a game.

It might pick up some support from the gay gamers out there, if it has lesbians then yes, nerds are painfully predictable, but I'd guess you'd probably lose more people than you gain most of the time... population statistics again. Although saying that, 'minority' protagonists of the other kinds of minority don't put people off... so who knows. The difference I suppose being that having a character be black or asian or whatever 'minority' you want to pick is just another character point, you wouldn't expect it to affect the gameplay or the story unduly.
 

Yorkshire_matt

New member
Apr 7, 2009
97
0
0
Thanatos34 said:
If the lead character is gay, then I don't think I would relate to him nearly as much as if he was not. I most likely would not buy the game. Plus, I would think any kiss/sex scenes were gross. (I think homosexuality is fine, but, tbh, I still get a sick feeling when I see it being practiced, because I am not attracted to guys.)

I think having the option there is fine, but if it is forced, then that would seriously hurt the game's sales, because only around 3-4% of the population are gay/lesbian, and of the other 96-97%, a lot of them would not "get" it, and many would be repulsed by it.

It might be able to survive, but the game's sales would be hurt, and thus it would be a strange company that would make a game knowing it's sales will be hurt, not because of how good the game is, but because of what content is in it.

Now if you are asking if it could survive if it is an option, then of course it could survive, other games already have done so.
what kind of moron do you have to be to buy a game based on the sexuality of the main character!!!! I buy a game because A. i like the idea that the story is based on, B. The game looks like it will be good.

when i go out to buy a game the last thing i think about is will the main character have homosexual conitations
 

TxMxRonin

New member
Jan 1, 2009
690
0
0
Sure, I think a homosexual lead character would be a game I'd play, but developers tend to go with a hollow character that's a vehicle for the player's perception, such as Master Chief or the DOOM marine.
 

lokust2001

New member
Mar 4, 2008
68
0
0
cball11 said:
I wouldn't play it. Nothing against gay people, I just wouldn't be able to feel comfortable playing the part of a gay man. It would ruin the game for me.
Do you ever play games where you kill lots of people?
 

jebussaves88

New member
May 4, 2008
1,395
0
0
I don't see why it's needed. The only reason the characters sexuality would need to be known was if the gameplay or plot involved a relationship. I get the the feeling any game that gets a gay character plastered in will go down as another Brokeback Mountain, except not critically acclaimed (It'll be "that gay FPS")
 

FredFredburgur

New member
Apr 13, 2009
206
0
0
man-man said:
FredFredburgur said:
are homosexuals considered a minority?
Well... statistically speaking yes, they are a smaller component of the population than heterosexuals. I don't know if they would be called "a minority" in the same way as certain ethnic groups are, but they are in the minority as far as numbers go.
Thank you, I just wanted to make sure I wasn't offending anyone or anything like that.
 

vamp rocks

New member
Aug 27, 2008
990
0
0
ehh, i dont think there would be too much aggrovation.. although if the underlying message was like "everyone should be gay" then the conservatives would be upset, and if the character was so flamboyant that it seemed as if they were poking fun at him *cough* florian from GTA IV *cough* then the gay community would be in uproar, so you cannot win in these situations...]

but personally, im gay so i think it would be a good idea, so that it shows kids growing up that homosexuality is more normal and accepted (and if the kid did turn out to be gay then s/he would be more comfortable with themselves) as opposed to every single movie, film, game, etc having heterosexual love lifes and emphasizing everything else is weird..
 

MiracleOfSound

Fight like a Krogan
Jan 3, 2009
17,776
0
0
vamp rocks said:
ehh, i dont think there would be too much aggrovation.. although if the underlying message was like "everyone should be gay" then the conservatives would be upset, and if the character was so flamboyant that it seemed as if they were poking fun at him *cough* florian from GTA IV *cough* then the gay community would be in uproar, so you cannot win in these situations...]

but personally, im gay so i think it would be a good idea, so that it shows kids growing up that homosexuality is more normal and accepted (and if the kid did turn out to be gay then s/he would be more comfortable with themselves) as opposed to every single movie, film, game, etc having heterosexual love lifes and emphasizing everything else is weird..
Florian was indeed a horribly cliched flaming queen, but then again at least it's a step up from the blatant homophobia in San Andreas.

Though watching him jogging through the park did make me laugh... and everyone in GTA games is a stereotype anyway (packie mcreery... jesus christ)
 

Thanatos34

New member
Mar 31, 2009
389
0
0
Yorkshire_matt said:
Thanatos34 said:
If the lead character is gay, then I don't think I would relate to him nearly as much as if he was not. I most likely would not buy the game. Plus, I would think any kiss/sex scenes were gross. (I think homosexuality is fine, but, tbh, I still get a sick feeling when I see it being practiced, because I am not attracted to guys.)

I think having the option there is fine, but if it is forced, then that would seriously hurt the game's sales, because only around 3-4% of the population are gay/lesbian, and of the other 96-97%, a lot of them would not "get" it, and many would be repulsed by it.

It might be able to survive, but the game's sales would be hurt, and thus it would be a strange company that would make a game knowing it's sales will be hurt, not because of how good the game is, but because of what content is in it.

Now if you are asking if it could survive if it is an option, then of course it could survive, other games already have done so.
what kind of moron do you have to be to buy a game based on the sexuality of the main character!!!! I buy a game because A. i like the idea that the story is based on, B. The game looks like it will be good.

when i go out to buy a game the last thing i think about is will the main character have homosexual conitations

*Sigh* I didn't say I would not buy the game. I said I would most likely not buy the game, as I do not relate to the main character. If the game deals with sexuality, then of course that's going to be a reason whether I do or do not buy the game. If it doesn't deal with sexuality, then I won't consider that in my calculations of whether or not to buy it, obviously.

For an example, let's take a game like The Witcher. If Geralt is gay, I would most certainly not buy the game, because sexuality is such a key part of the storyline, and thus a key part of the storyline would gross me out. If you want to spend your money on that, then go ahead, but some of us have a limited source of income, and thus must use a little judgment beyond, "I LIKE I LIKE I WANT I WANT!" when buying games. It must be worth it.

If you only buy a game because it looks like it will be good, and you like the idea that it is based on, then I'm glad that you can get enjoyment out of games like that, (and that you can somehow afford it.) However, I tend to make a much more... researched decision on whether or not to buy the game, consisting of at least the following:

1. Price of the game, (Which you did not mention at all.)
2. How Violence is done. (Tastefully, Realistically. Not where it is gratuitious and unnecessary, but realistic, if it has a lot of violence in it.)
3. How Sex is done within the game. (Same reasoning as violence.)
4. What my Friends say about the game.
5. Whether I have liked other games by that company.
6. Whether I can play the game well, (judging by its requirements- I only use my PC to play games).
7. What the gameplay is like.
8. What the storyline is like. (Especially if it is based on some book.)
9. What the demo plays like, if there is one. If there is not, then the chances of me buying the game just went way down.
10. What the dialogue is like, (generally this can only be known from the demo, and this lead to probably my most-regretted purchase of all time: Two Worlds.)
11. What the voice acting is like.

These are all equally weighed, with perhaps my friend's opinion and my own, formed from the demo, coming out on top.

I see no reason to spend my hard-earned money on a game where I do not relate to the lead character. Games are for enjoyment, MY enjoyment if they are my games, and if I am cringing at half the dialogue, then I am not enjoying myself. Thus, I most likely wouldn't buy it.
 

vamp rocks

New member
Aug 27, 2008
990
0
0
miracleofsound said:
Florian was indeed a horribly cliched flaming queen, but then again at least it's a step up from the blatant homophobia in San Andreas.

Though watching him jogging through the park did make me laugh... and everyone in GTA games is a stereotype anyway (packie mcreery... jesus christ)
yeah i know, they do take things to the extreme..

lol i have a friend whos part irish and he reminds me so much of Packie, except... well.. you know... less guns.. lol
 

bjj hero

New member
Feb 4, 2009
3,180
0
0
Its been done already. Marcus from Gears of War is obviously gay. He tries way to hard and has a blatant crush on Santiago.