Poll: Favorite modern Doctor Who

[Zeromaeus]

They're all still blokes. Now, if we had a female Doctor...

Well, technically...

Oooh look, it has a vibrate setting...

Wait, what? You have used a quote. Quotes are my weakness. I never remember where they''re from. Explain. Now.

 

[The_root_of_all_evil]

Wait, what? You have used a quote. Quotes are my weakness. I never remember where they''re from. Explain. Now.

The Curse of the Fatal Death, of course.
Joanna Lumley : 13th Doctor.

 

[TimeLord]

I like all of them, but the 10th one just that little bit more

 

[Colour Scientist]

Tennant, I have a grudge against Smith for making everyone talk about how cool fezes are. I found it genius at first but now...eh.

 

[SL33TBL1ND]

This was a good one too...

Number four I do believe. Most of the Who fans of America don't know him though. I'm one of the few...

Tom Baker is the best all time Doctor, but the best modern is David Tenant by far.

 

[Dark2003]

I have to say Eleven. I just started watching Doctor Who this season so he was my first doctor. However, I have found reruns of the Tenth doctor and he's a close second.

i have to agree, i missed out on watching the tenth doctor in action and started with the eleventh doctor, and he slight above the tenth

 

[CrankyStorming]

Tennant has been the only really engaging one of those three, Smith is too childish and Eccleston was too much of an angry northerner.

 

[iFail69]

Matt Smith is the best one because he's funny and he wears a bow tie

although it's tough between him and Eccleston though because Eccleston just gave me good feelings.

I hate david tennant... I just hate him

 

[Rakkana]

I think the ninth one was the best when I think about it.

 

[Billska]

The tenth. He can save the universe with a kettle and some string, and look he's wearing a vegetable.

 

[Zaltias]

Tennant was my favourite by far. He brought a new vivacity to the character. Although Smith is quite good in his own regard -

"I'll do a thing."
"What thing?"
"I don't know, it's a thing in progress. Respect the thing!"

 

[BringBackBuck]

John Pertwee owns all these modern doctors.

 

[Liham]

Can you hold, i have to eat a biscut.
BEST LINE EVER.
(matt smith as the doctor)

 

[Technocrat]

Ecclestone was different and interesting, but I don't think he hung around long enough to be able to be my "favourite". Tennant was...well...I liked him at first, but then the scripts kind of started turning him into a Messiah-Sue who was known to everybody, which kind of defeated the point of Doctor Who. It was very modern, and very "Russell Davies", but kind of grating eventually.

Smith is my choice, because he's a lot more like the older Doctors - a daft old man, but in a young man's body. He conveys more of the impression of being hundreds of years old.

If you were to have asked me about the old ones though, Pertwee all the way. Sea Devils, Cybermen, Autons - he had to cope with the lot of them!

 

[JWRosser]

Tennant, I have a grudge against Smith for making everyone talk about how cool fezes are. I found it genius at first but now...eh.

It was absolutely hilarious in the episode, but it's been quoted way too much...like Little Britain or a really good song that suddenly everyone likes...

Though I think Matt Smith is my favourite JUST over David Tennant. Even though Tennant is a great actor and was magnificent as the Doctor, I love Smith's awkwardness and humour, but also the way he suddenly snaps every now and then.
Christopher Eccleston was decent (though he disliked playing the Doctor) but I think he was a little too bad-ass. Still, Captain Jack is my favourite character over all. But that may just be because I have a slight man crush on John Barrowman.

 

[Arkhangelsk]

Eccleston had a certain charm (mostly for the accent), but Tennant brought such a more lively and funny character, while still being able to be dramatic and serious. Oh, and Tennant is pure sexy with his sideburns.

 

[Lawyer105]

Definitely Eccleston for me. Tennant is good, but I liked Eccleston's verve. Tennant brought energy to The Doctor, but it was a manic sort of energy. Eccleston was like a kid on Christmas morning.

11 just sucks. I can't stand this incarnation of The Doctor.

 

[Vortex Traveller]

WHY, why make me choose *sob*

right lets see...

9th: The first Doctor I saw, his got a real edge to him, I wish we'd seen more but for a one season Doctor he was fantastic. Just a shame he stayed only one year.

10th: great overall but his last moments kind of dragged (The whole "Time Lord Victorious" bit in Waters of Mars was brilliant but his last wimpering line of "I don't wanna go" for me hurt my overall impression of him. Shame but overall great.

11th: Brillantly mad and Alien, great so far with no major errors, looking forward to seeing what his got.

Overall, I can't really choose between the three but if I had too

9th (for me he is MY Doctor)
11th (So far so great)
10th (Brilliant just a shame that he was ruined a bit at the end putting him bottom of the three)

 

[badpun]

I'd have to go with the 9th though he was only in for one season he left a damn good impression brought a more slightly dark angrier edge to the Doctor.

Second would have to be the 11th I like how Smith bring in a more 'human' approach how he doesn't seem to be any more superior than humans just well more wiser and quirky =P

I like the 10th a lot and Tennant's acting was great and i know the Doctor is supposed to over the top but it seem like he played that card too often and it got slightly on my nerves.