I can't honestly answer this poll.
On the one hand, I absolutely love KotOR. I've played it so many times, and I still go back to it every so often. Yeah, it's glitchy and Mission's VA is bad and it's starting to show its age and some of the puzzles are annoying, but it's still one of my top 10 favourite games.
On the other hand, KotORII is a whole lot harder to describe. The characters in KotORII are far more interesting. Atton and Kreia alone beat out pretty much all the characters from KotOR combined (except maybe Revan). The deeper item customization and random loot thing was a step in the right direction, and the darker atmosphere was great.
But KotORII was horribly unfinished, had some pretty bad slowdown rates, and was just pathetic in the AI department, not mention that there were still serious glitches. I guess if you took the sum total of my feelings for KotORII, you'd get a "meh".
But anyhow... who's looking forward to Star Wars: The Old Republic?