Hmm... I'm not sure I'm good-looking, exactly, but a little more so than the uncertainty in option 3 suggests.
Meh - rating your own appearance is hard. A guy who was trying to hit on me insisted I was 'very cute, and kinda hot', but 1)he was drunk, and 2) I'm a straight guy. So don't really know how to take that one... But it happens surprisingly often.
There's a photo in my profile, but it's not that great. And a quick check of facebook reveals that I'm slightly inebriated in most photos of me...
Sure, as it stands it wouldn't hurt me to lose a little weight, and I'm kinda short, but overall, meh. 6-7 out of 10. 7-8 on a good day.
Thisis up from the 3 I'd have given myself last year - turns out confidence can directly affect physical attractiveness! If you think you're good-looking-ish, so will other people