So by reading about a roller-coaster you now have all the knowledge about roller coasters? You only have second-hand knowledge, and still don't know how a roller coaster physically feels like, nor can you draw your own knowledge from the experience.Ultratwinkie said:Too bad we have access to knowledge. You don't need to experience an action to understand it.Ledan said:You are ignorant about death until you have personally killed something. Sure, you can think about it, but you won't know what it is until you've seen something die. Same as a roller coaster, you are ignorant about rollercoasters until you have ridden one.Ultratwinkie said:Sex isn't knowledge, its an action. To say a virgin is ignorant is to say a man is ignorant because he never killed someone.Murray Whitwell said:It depends on why they're a virgin. I find the whole abstaining until marriage or even treating virginity as something special to be extremely pretentious.
"It is the infantile superstition of man that virginity be seen a virtue rather than the barrier separating ignorance from knowledge" - François-Marie Arouet
For the sake of argument I've tried to refute that, but I can't think of a single thing that makes willed ignorance virtuous.
Same for sex. You are ignorant about sex until you've had it. And since sex is one of the underlying emotions and desires of people, you are slightly ignorant about people until you have had it.
Death: Depends on death. The poison of the horse shoe crab's eggs paralyzes the muscles, including lungs, which causes you to suffocate.
Roller coaster: The body excretes adrenaline that creates a temporary high in the individual.
Just because you didn't experience an action, doesn't mean you don't know about it. Science has brought us past that point.
By your "we have access to knowledge. You don't need to experience it", are you saying that you will understand karate without having done karate? Are you now a karate expert after having read a book about karate? Are you a military genius after having read "The art of War"? Can you dive or have any knowledge of what it feels like to be 20 meters under the water by reading a diving book?
There is a significant difference between theoretical knowledge and practical knowledge. And though theoretical knowledge is great, it does not trump practical knowledge. I theoretically know how to write programs, yet without ANY experience in programming I will be unable to use this theoretical knowledge until I have gained practical knowledge in the matter.