At least I acknowledged that I only voted slightly above average based upon my accomplishments in academia, as I assumed that is how many people would vote.Sabiancym said:Oh boy, here come the "I just scored 4000 on the IQ test at irsmarterer.com". Even though a lot of the critics (including myself) of the IQ test score high on it, it doesn't mean we don't recognize the cultural and regional bias of the IQ test. It's well documented. Plus intelligence has no one accepted definition.
I don't consider scholastic achievement and grades as any sort of representation of intelligence. All school teaches is how to memorize and take tests. So you know the atomic weight of cobalt? So what? That doesn't mean that you have the ability to apply that knowledge. I know it's cliche, but many of the greatest minds in the world did terrible in school.
True intelligence in my opinion involves taking full advantage of reason. Using fairly basic deduction and objective thinking to come to conclusions and solve problems.
I'll take the guy with 5 years experience in the field over the newly graduated bachelor degree wielding rookie any day.
I predict that this will be an ego thread. A thread with a ton of replies, but no one really reading what other people are saying. Just posting their thought, and dismissing everyone else.
That being said. Yes, I'm as arrogant as anyone when it comes to self valuation of intelligence. But that conclusions is not even close to unfounded or without merit.
Use of reason and deduction without specialist knowledge qualifies one only to be a philosopher... or a detective.Sabiancym said:True intelligence in my opinion involves taking full advantage of reason. Using fairly basic deduction and objective thinking to come to conclusions and solve problems.
So does everyone else, which is why a swathe of graduates is unemployed unless they have PhD's.I'll take the guy with 5 years experience in the field over the newly graduated bachelor degree wielding rookie any day.
Of course it is, do you think I've read anything else except my own haughty and pretentious post?!I predict that this will be an ego thread. A thread with a ton of replies, but no one really reading what other people are saying. Just posting their thought, and dismissing everyone else.
As is everyone else's...That being said. Yes, I'm as arrogant as anyone when it comes to self valuation of intelligence. But that conclusions is not even close to unfounded or without merit.