Poll: If you were a superhero would you kill criminals?

Recommended Videos

Zykon TheLich

Extra Heretical!
Legacy
Jun 6, 2008
3,506
850
118
Country
UK
Mr. Squirrel said:
And you dare to call yourself the scum of society? Shame on you, real scum would rape every criminal then kill them and then rape their dead bodies again only then with a cucumber!
Well, when I say ignore non violent drug dealers, I actually mean help them spread the love.
 

PedroSteckecilo

Mexican Fugitive
Feb 7, 2008
6,732
0
0
scumofsociety said:
Mr. Squirrel said:
And you dare to call yourself the scum of society? Shame on you, real scum would rape every criminal then kill them and then rape their dead bodies again only then with a cucumber!
Well, when I say ignore non violent drug dealers, I actually mean help them spread the love.
In a super hero RP a friend of mine made a hero who would beat up and rob drug dealers and then resell their more harmless merchandise to college students.

He also had the worst super hero name ever...

He was Silver Jim, he looked like a man sized silver sphere with giant wings.
 

Vortex Traveller

New member
Sep 28, 2008
118
0
0
Only in extreme cases where its more or less unavoidable (eg: if its a case of I kill them or they kill me within the next five seconds). But I would do all I can to avoid having to kill anyone.
 

Rajin Cajun

New member
Sep 12, 2008
1,157
0
0
Vortex Traveller said:
Only in extreme cases where its more or less unavoidable (eg: if its a case of I kill them or they kill me within the next five seconds). But I would do all I can to avoid having to kill anyone.
Hmm that brought up a thought don't kill them instead purposefully maim them or cripple them that could be hysterical. Then torture them while they are down...or purposeful botch the kill so they suffer like a gutshot. You sir are evil. :p
 

Bourne Endeavor

New member
May 14, 2008
1,082
0
0
I would more then likely fall under the category of anti-hero then superhero, so I suppose like Frank Castle. Nevertheless with that power I would indeed kill rapists and murderers, they in my opinion have long since given up any rates and I do not believe imprisonment is enough considering those loathsome scum drain society by being kept alive. Petty crimes would result in necessary actions to fit the crime in my opinion (what jail should actually be for, solely.)

And before anyone states, no I do not agree with the current system nor how it is performed hence why I could deal my own from of justice.
 

Baonec

New member
Aug 20, 2008
409
0
0
rossatdi said:
Khell_Sennet said:
What about "Yes, even petty criminals"?
curlycrouton said:
What about, "Yes, indiscriminately?"
Rajin Cajun said:
I would kill criminals just like Frank Castle.
Jesus Christ this board is filled with psychos. What gives you the right? Who elected you? And how do you possible justify murdering a robber?
Depending on the powers I have I can do what the hell I like who's going to stop me, my morales sure as hell won't.
 

Lightknight

Mugwamp Supreme
Nov 26, 2008
4,860
0
0
It depends entirely on what our society is able to do with criminals I've captured and what they expect of me. If it's a villain that keeps getting out and slaughtering innocents, then I'd have to use lethal force. I wouldn't want to pull a Batman and realize years later that my greatest sin was not killing a man dressed in makeup and purple clothing.

But, if the villain could be successfully contained by the government, it'd be their problem.
 

_Janny_

New member
Mar 6, 2008
1,193
0
0
Hmm... I voted for "Yes - rapists, murders, drug dealers". If I can't be caught by the police when killing them, that is.. Those kind of people endanger the life of others, so what's the point of keeping them alive? I might be evil myself for thinking like this, but at least I'd be saving innocent people. This kinda starts to sound like Death Note...
 

Rajin Cajun

New member
Sep 12, 2008
1,157
0
0
Bourne said:
I would more then likely fall under the category of anti-hero then superhero, so I suppose like Frank Castle. Nevertheless with that power I would indeed kill rapists and murderers, they in my opinion have long since given up any rates and I do not believe imprisonment is enough considering those loathsome scum drain society by being kept alive. Petty crimes would result in necessary actions to fit the crime in my opinion (what jail should actually be for, solely.)

And before anyone states, no I do not agree with the current system nor how it is performed hence why I could deal my own from of justice.
I am glad to see more Frank Castle fans coming out of the woodwork keeps society honest. I say kill 'em all and let God sort 'em out! God knows his own! :p
 

Bourne Endeavor

New member
May 14, 2008
1,082
0
0
Rajin Cajun said:
Bourne said:
I would more then likely fall under the category of anti-hero then superhero, so I suppose like Frank Castle. Nevertheless with that power I would indeed kill rapists and murderers, they in my opinion have long since given up any rates and I do not believe imprisonment is enough considering those loathsome scum drain society by being kept alive. Petty crimes would result in necessary actions to fit the crime in my opinion (what jail should actually be for, solely.)

And before anyone states, no I do not agree with the current system nor how it is performed hence why I could deal my own from of justice.
I am glad to see more Frank Castle fans coming out of the woodwork keeps society honest. I say kill 'em all and let God sort 'em out! God knows his own! :p
Haha, truthfully I have read very little about Frank Castle, I just know of him. That last statement though reminds me of a quote I love when someone says we should forgive all.

"Forgiveness is between them and God, it is my job to arrange the meeting."
 

Rajin Cajun

New member
Sep 12, 2008
1,157
0
0
Bourne said:
Rajin Cajun said:
Bourne said:
I would more then likely fall under the category of anti-hero then superhero, so I suppose like Frank Castle. Nevertheless with that power I would indeed kill rapists and murderers, they in my opinion have long since given up any rates and I do not believe imprisonment is enough considering those loathsome scum drain society by being kept alive. Petty crimes would result in necessary actions to fit the crime in my opinion (what jail should actually be for, solely.)

And before anyone states, no I do not agree with the current system nor how it is performed hence why I could deal my own from of justice.
I am glad to see more Frank Castle fans coming out of the woodwork keeps society honest. I say kill 'em all and let God sort 'em out! God knows his own! :p
Haha, truthfully I have read very little about Frank Castle, I just know of him. That last statement though reminds me of a quote I love when someone says we should forgive all.

"Forgiveness is between them and God, it is my job to arrange the meeting."
Well if you are even mildly interested in the character The Punisher I would suggest Garth Ennis' Punisher MAX series from Marvel that shit is brilliant and ultraviolent.
 

Frizzle

New member
Nov 11, 2008
605
0
0
The drug dealer thing oculd go either way. If they were just selling weed, for example, i wouldn't kill them. That's just wrong. Many people that smoke that are extremely productive and helpful. Rapists and murderers? Yeah they'd probably go, depending on who they murdered and why. A lot of it would have to be on a case by case basis, unfortunately.

I've always wanted to creat a government sponsored job that let me go around killing idiots that cause havoc in our society. Like the people that spill coffee on them and try to sue McDonalds because it's hot. Those people need to go....
 

Sisyphus0

New member
Sep 10, 2008
60
0
0
I'd kill a 12 year old who stole a handbag from an old lady, then kill the old lady. Who wants to be a super 'hero' super-villains are where it's at. Oh and btw, why are drug dealers with murderers?
 

rossatdi

New member
Aug 27, 2008
2,542
0
0
I weep for society, I really do!

I'm glad I have Batman, Superman, Flash and Spiderman on my side. The Justice League would be very upset with the lot of you.

Where are your ideals? When did it become cool to be a murdering psychopath?
 

PedroSteckecilo

Mexican Fugitive
Feb 7, 2008
6,732
0
0
rossatdi said:
I weep for society, I really do!

I'm glad I have Batman, Superman, Flash and Spiderman on my side. The Justice League would be very upset with the lot of you.

Where are your ideals? When did it become cool to be a murdering psychopath?
Welcome to the GTA generation...

Personally I can't stand the Mark Millar, Frank Millar and to a lesser degree Garth Ennis world of comics right now. All the idealism and fun are gone from the mainstream and all has fallen into darkness and decay.
 

Rajin Cajun

New member
Sep 12, 2008
1,157
0
0
rossatdi said:
I weep for society, I really do!

I'm glad I have Batman, Superman, Flash and Spiderman on my side. The Justice League would be very upset with the lot of you.

Where are your ideals? When did it become cool to be a murdering psychopath?
Pfft Carebear. This is the first time I felt hope for humanity with enough like minded bloodthirsty vigilantes it could be possible to create a League of Vigilantes and let death sweep the land similar to Boondock Saints. A good rash of vigilantism could fix a shitload of problems in the Western World especially the corrupt and overbloated bureaucracy that makes up the majority of all Western Justice systems and that works hand in hand with organized crime.
 

rossatdi

New member
Aug 27, 2008
2,542
0
0
Rajin Cajun said:
rossatdi said:
I weep for society, I really do!

I'm glad I have Batman, Superman, Flash and Spiderman on my side. The Justice League would be very upset with the lot of you.

Where are your ideals? When did it become cool to be a murdering psychopath?
Pfft Carebear. This is the first time I felt hope for humanity with enough like minded bloodthirsty vigilantes it could be possible to create a League of Vigilantes and let death sweep the land similar to Boondock Saints. A good rash of vigilantism could fix a shitload of problems in the Western World especially the corrupt and overbloated bureaucracy that makes up the majority of all Western Justice systems and that works hand in hand with organized crime.
Violence only breeds violence. Assuming we were all super powered I'd fight against your League of Vigilantes till my last breath. Ours is a sacred responsibility, we should be the best humanity can be at that means exhibiting mercy and restraint along with strength and justice.

Me and the League of Guardians might lose, and the public might have thought we're too soft, but there will come a time when they realise your lack of restraint is a burden not a boon!