Poll: My Love Triangle Help!!!

Recommended Videos

Sewblon

New member
Nov 5, 2008
3,107
0
0
ThrobbingEgo said:
Sewblon said:
Stay with your current girlfriend. When faced with two temptations, choose the safer one.
But is that love?
Define love. Love is the same word I use to describe chocolate and my computer so you need to be more specific.
 

ThrobbingEgo

New member
Nov 17, 2008
2,765
0
0
Sewblon said:
Define love. Love is the same word I use to describe chocolate and my computer.
Let's go with "a combination of passion, intimacy, and commitment - with a good helping of respect." I'm simplifying here but you also want to be, on an important level, equals with your significant other. That's why you call your romantic interests "partners" afterall.

I hope you can't say that for chocolate and your computer.
 

steveo_justice

New member
Apr 4, 2008
86
0
0
UpSkirtDistress said:
ThrobbingEgo said:
UpSkirtDistress said:
Is it not possible to consider i have feelings for both. I've said no to girl 2 before but she is still a really good friend so will be part of my life. She isn't exactly waiting around for me she lives her own life. She is an individual not my back up plan. I love my girlfriend ,really i do whether you believe it or not, but i just have feeling for this other girl. At this stage of my relationship i'm just beginning to think maybe there is more out there in the world but i'm afraid to do anything in case i lose her forever which is not what i want
It's possible you have feelings for both - but nothing as certain as love for either. Why? Because you're asking complete strangers for their opinion over whether you should dump your girlfriend or not. When you have to make a commitment, which way are you going to roll? You seem indifferent and unable to choose.

Do you "love" your girlfriend because of her, or because she's there?
You make a harsh but ascute point
That's "Astute."

I'm the kind of guy that sits in my underground doom bunker all day and thinks of survival plans while not installing miniguns and gas turbine engines into my car, so I'd pretend this is a choose your own adventure book and develop a contingency plan.

The worst choice here is to choose one definitively over the other, as you seem to suggest is the only option, as that would give you a 50/50 chance of hitting it off great or being all by your lonesome at square 1 if you botch anything. Breaking up with your current girl would produce this effect, as the rejection would ruin any future chance you have with her.

I would continue to see your original girl, and if it works out, then hey, you made the right choice. But it would also be wise to stay close to Girl #2, just close enough to keep her in a state of interest, so that if at any point you botch your relationship with Girl #1 you can fall back on #2.

Furthermore, if you later choose #2 over #1, you should be sure to break up with #1 under harsh, stressful circumstances not connected to your relationship, so that if you decide you want to to get back with #1 after hooking up with #2 you have some material to bullshit your way back into her life with. "I lost my job and my dog died and I was addicted to Heroine pity me!" will do a lot more for your chances than "Yeah so the sex got boring."

If you're really slick, you can just marry each one and then move to Indonesia.
 

ExaltedK9

New member
Apr 23, 2009
1,148
0
0
You could always just stop whoring yourself around. You can't just play both of them, that's jacked up. But, if you have a good thing going, than you shouldn't feel the need to pursue anybody else.

And you really should be glad that your girlfriend isn't an alchoholic party monster, she sounds pretty lenient to let you have such a close relationship with this other chick. If your so close to her and her family than why even consider doing this? You say that you're still very happy with the way things are between you and her, I know that people always expect something better is passing it by, but please just be rational in your decision....

I know whats best for you...
 

MystikMtnManaT

New member
Apr 8, 2009
84
0
0
I'm sorry but it seems if you even felt the need to post this that inside you know what you really want, I believe its the other girl. If you were truly happy with your current girlfriend there would be no trouble therefore no need to post. So I say give yourself a chance at a happier situation and take the leap.
 
May 17, 2007
879
0
0
300lb. Samoan said:
go see Two Lovers. Jaoquim Phoenix was in a similar spot, I think.
Or you can do what Jonathan Rhys Meyers did in Match Point...
Marry your girlfriend while secretly having an affair with the other woman, wait until the mistress is pregnant, promise to leave your girlfriend for her, but then murder her and make it look like a botched robbery. Flip a coin to see if you get away with it.
On second thoughts, go with the other guy's suggestion.
 

daegranos

New member
Dec 24, 2008
22
0
0
UpSkirtDistress said:
you don't love your current girlfriend, otherwise you wouldn't post something like this on the internet and you would certainly not be thinking of leaving her, moron!
dump your current girlfriend and get dumped by the other girl.
 

UpSkirtDistress

New member
Mar 2, 2009
272
0
0
steveo_justice said:
That's "Astute."

I'm the kind of guy that sits in my underground doom bunker all day and thinks of survival plans while not installing miniguns and gas turbine engines into my car, so I'd pretend this is a choose your own adventure book and develop a contingency plan.

The worst choice here is to choose one definitively over the other, as you seem to suggest is the only option, as that would give you a 50/50 chance of hitting it off great or being all by your lonesome at square 1 if you botch anything. Breaking up with your current girl would produce this effect, as the rejection would ruin any future chance you have with her.

I would continue to see your original girl, and if it works out, then hey, you made the right choice. But it would also be wise to stay close to Girl #2, just close enough to keep her in a state of interest, so that if at any point you botch your relationship with Girl #1 you can fall back on #2.

Furthermore, if you later choose #2 over #1, you should be sure to break up with #1 under harsh, stressful circumstances not connected to your relationship, so that if you decide you want to to get back with #1 after hooking up with #2 you have some material to bullshit your way back into her life with. "I lost my job and my dog died and I was addicted to Heroine pity me!" will do a lot more for your chances than "Yeah so the sex got boring."

If you're really slick, you can just marry each one and then move to Indonesia.
Your post is highly constructive and well thought out. (Beats the your an asshole posts,if someone knew the full story and wishes to say so that would be a different matter) I think your right i'm just feeling weird bout being in such a long relationship if its meant to be its meant to be only time will tell.
 

l33ticarus

New member
Aug 20, 2008
39
0
0
Stay with your current girlfriend... I had this same problem... And I ended up going with the other girl... those feelings I had for her... well she just wanted to see who she can date and who she can't date... The old girl I kinda with I could still have her now... I regret it everyday...
 

Marble Dragon

New member
Mar 11, 2009
352
0
0
ThrobbingEgo said:
Marble Dragon said:
Could you figure it out? Think of your current girlfriend. Picture her in your mind, in remarkable detail. Even put her normal outfit, jewelry, makeup, ect. onto that mental image. Now picture what she'll go through if out of the blue, you tell her that you've dumped her for some other girl that you met two years ago.
You think it's any better if you dump her for her? At least if you're leaving her, you're the douche. If you're dumping her for her - you're rejecting her. I'd argue that's much more painful - when the person who hurts you isn't the bad guy.
I suppose you have a point. Even if he had dumped her only because he knew that he was having thoughts about other girls and he didn't think that he could be good enough to her, it would seem like he was simply rejecting her.

Okay, that's one more hour I'm going to be sitting around, thinking about this thread.
 

ThrobbingEgo

New member
Nov 17, 2008
2,765
0
0
Marble Dragon said:
]I suppose you have a point. Even if he had dumped her only because he knew that he was having thoughts about other girls and he didn't think that he could be good enough to her, it would seem like he was simply rejecting her.

Okay, that's one more hour I'm going to be sitting around, thinking about this thread.
When I dumped my ex, for the right reasons, she still got hurt.
 

MBFCPresident

New member
May 15, 2009
149
0
0
Stick with your girlfriend, dude. You love her and she loves you and if you want it to stay that way, you're gonna have to forget about being with that other chick. Yes, she has qualities your girlfriend doesn't but that's not what love is about. It's not like you?re on a used car lot saying "Yeah, this car has great safety features, lots of room and is a great deal at this price, but I want that one with the flames!" If you love someone, you have to love everything about them. You can't have a perfect life; you have to take the bitter with the sweet. I don't know you, bro but I can tell you're a nice guy and you clearly want to do the right thing. But in order to do that, you have to think about everyone involved. Yes, this girl has feelings for you and you have feelings for her, but if you base your life solely on feelings hardly anything?s gonna work out. She's a great friend, and that's a role she can fill without compromising your relationship with your girlfriend. Not to mention that since you've been with this girl previously and it didn't work out exactly the way you wanted, there's no guarantee that it'll work this time. If you leave the woman you love you may never be able to retain a relationship with her as a friend. It takes more than duct tape to mend a broken heart. Leave your girlfriend and you'll be throwing away everything you two had. All the days spent sharing laughs will turn into empty "How you been?"s every time you see her, all the nights you fell asleep in each others arms will make your bed feel cold in the middle of summer, every single "I love you" will be remembered as nothing more than a hollow, cowardly lie. What I'm trying to say is could you live with yourself? Think about it.
 

Kinguendo

New member
Apr 10, 2009
4,267
0
0
Man, that was almost the weirdest thing I have ever read. The part where you are talking about being really close and in each others families and stuff... I had to do a double take... Probably my fault, its 4:00am and I am bloody tired!