Poll: Professional Wrestling: Yay or Nay? (Or Abstai....n)

Recommended Videos

BigDeadMushy

New member
May 4, 2011
1,178
0
0
there's no denying the athleticism involved,but the entertainment side of the industry is a mere shadow of its former glory these days.I usedta watch it many years ago,the heyday of TLC matches and Mick Foley(in various guises).
the younger wrestlers just don't entertain me as well as the ones I usedta watch all those years ago.
 

Lilani

Sometimes known as CaitieLou
May 27, 2009
6,581
0
0
American Professional Wrestling? Like WWE Raw and all that? No. It's a soap opera starring a bunch of oiled-up, half-naked men. Even as a woman, no thanks. Too much testosterone and homoeroticism played perfectly straight for my tastes.

Now things where they actually compete, like boxing and whatnot, that's not so bad. But the other stuff is just...blech. I don't want to get within 30 feet of it.
 

R4ptur3

New member
Feb 21, 2010
581
0
0
I used to LOVE WWF in the 90's and early 2000's, but then for me it sort of got worse and worse. The rock left, then kane took his mask off and i was just like 'no soz'. Although i don't really watch wrestling now a days, i'm sure it's got less violent and there are more kids that actually go to the matches then there used to be, when it was jsut full of adults screaming at the camera.
 

Smooth Operator

New member
Oct 5, 2010
8,162
0
0
ReservoirAngel said:
I vote "yay" because I am a massive fan of pro wrestling and fuck anyone who rips on me for having such an interest.
Highly dramatic soap opera acted out by burly lubed half naked men... how can anyone blame you

OT: Watched as a kid until I someone explained it's all bullshit, back then they was more action and less soap
 

Robert Drapp

New member
Dec 21, 2010
32
0
0
I vote yay on the simple premise of fail. Yes, I know that they portray John Cena as the last son of Krypton. Yes, I know it true that their writing staff could be replaced by a room full of howler monkeys and I'm not sure anyone would notice. And yes, I understand that the Attitude Era made WWE great and that the watered-down version that we're fed ever week and in the PPVs is so weak that an arthritic geratric's breath could break it. But then again, I love Yathzee and I love hearing people rip on things so I can truely apreachate the good stuff.
 

Lilitu

New member
Feb 22, 2011
101
0
0
I like to watch wrestling. Eventough a lot of stuff in the ring just doesn't work without a little help from your opponent, it is still impressive, what most of these guys do in the ring. It's just a shame that so many women are reduced to their looks and they do stuff like mud-wrestling or championship-vs-hair-matches. That is so lame. A good lookig woman looks in a good match better than in a silly little joke of five minutes in the ring, shaking her booty and moaning like they want to dub an adult movie.

So yeah, wrestlers don't really fight but you have to bring a lot to the table to do, what they do in the ring.
And since they don't beat each other up every night, they get into a ring, I can watch every week some wrestling ;)
 

ChupathingyX

New member
Jun 8, 2010
3,716
0
0
I miss Kurt Angle...

Ever since he left, and now that Edge has left there really isn't any reason for me to watch WWE anymore.
 

SadakoMoose

Elite Member
Jun 10, 2009
1,200
0
41
Lilani said:
American Professional Wrestling? Like WWE Raw and all that? No. It's a soap opera starring a bunch of oiled-up, half-naked men. Even as a woman, no thanks. Too much testosterone and homoeroticism played perfectly straight for my tastes.

Now things where they actually compete, like boxing and whatnot, that's not so bad. But the other stuff is just...blech. I don't want to get within 30 feet of it.
Well, that's a bit of a generalization...
Professional Wrestling, while popular in the States, is very international in it's origins and current popularity.
I'm guess you've never heard of El Santo or Rikidozan...or Johnny Saint...
Anyway, just try this:
 

Sovvolf

New member
Mar 23, 2009
2,341
0
0
SaneAmongInsane said:
If MMA doesn't it's popularity will eventually fall into lackluster like todays Boxing.
As opposed to falling into the lackluster that is todays pro-wrestling? I mean, if it stays the way of Boxing at least it will remain a legitimate sport. Pro-wrestling these days isn't really popular... Maybe to kids and a couple adults... But its not all that popular anymore.

Boxings went down in popularity sure, mainly because MMA as taken the light and I also doubt that the sport will stay this popular forever however, at least it will remain a real and legitimate sport. People aren't going to stick their noses up at it and say "Pfft, its all fake".

That and if it did go the way of pro-wrestling, it would lose the entire target audience and most Pro-wrestling fans would probably reject it because of its origins and the rivalry the two fanbases seem to have... So, I think going the way of pro-wrestling isn't going to be that good of an idea.
 

loc978

New member
Sep 18, 2010
4,900
0
0
When I was a child, I watched the likes of Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage (RIP, and thanks for averting that Rapture. God must be pissed and sore from the cage match)... and I laughed at them back then. It's all just over-the-top entertainment. Nothing in particular wrong with that, just not my thing anymore.
I started liking UFC when it was just starting to get popular, but now the fighting is too clean. If you're going to have that many rules, there had better be an edged weapon involved. Classical rapier fencing to first blood sounds like a better sport, I say.
 

DudeistBelieve

TellEmSteveDave.com
Sep 9, 2010
4,771
1
0
Sovvolf said:
SaneAmongInsane said:
If MMA doesn't it's popularity will eventually fall into lackluster like todays Boxing.
As opposed to falling into the lackluster that is todays pro-wrestling? I mean, if it stays the way of Boxing at least it will remain a legitimate sport. Pro-wrestling these days isn't really popular... Maybe to kids and a couple adults... But its not all that popular anymore.

Boxings went down in popularity sure, mainly because MMA as taken the light and I also doubt that the sport will stay this popular forever however, at least it will remain a real and legitimate sport. People aren't going to stick their noses up at it and say "Pfft, its all fake".

That and if it did go the way of pro-wrestling, it would lose the entire target audience and most Pro-wrestling fans would probably reject it because of its origins and the rivalry the two fanbases seem to have... So, I think going the way of pro-wrestling isn't going to be that good of an idea.
If you note, the high point of wrestling's popularity was when it was still presented as real. The fact of it being fake wasn't revealed until the mid 90's with McMahon's steroid trial and wrestling got it's last boom thanks to some excellent draws. Since then, what with the WWF now the WWE, E for Entertainment and it's product being openly presented as fiction it's little wonder wonder it's dipped in popularity...

Well that and the fact that there is a basic monopoly in the industry with no true alternative, the product has become stagnant.

When, not if, MMA becomes staged fans won't know about it. It'll be a closely guarded secret, just like Pro-Wrestling's false hood was initially, and if the fighters are smart they'll learn from the mistakes of the past keep it that way.
 

AMX58

New member
Jan 27, 2010
432
0
0
its ok just like Orton more man but everybody in that business is trying push toward tv 14 exspecially Vince
 

Sassafrass

This is a placeholder
Legacy
Aug 24, 2009
51,250
1
3
Country
United Kingdom
ChupathingyX said:
I miss Kurt Angle....
Angle has moved to TNA/Impact Wrestling now, if you wanted to see him. Although lately he's not been doing much wrestling, just getting hung up on advancing a rivalry through shouting at people in the ring. :p
 

Sovvolf

New member
Mar 23, 2009
2,341
0
0
SaneAmongInsane said:
When, not if, MMA becomes staged fans won't know about it. It'll be a closely guarded secret, just like Pro-Wrestling's false hood was initially, and if the fighters are smart they'll learn from the mistakes of the past keep it that way.
You seem overly confident on the idea that MMA will go the way of Pro-wrestling. I don't think so but I wouldn't deal in absolutes.
 

Artina89

New member
Oct 27, 2008
3,624
0
0
I am not that into wrestling, but my brother loves it for the oot storylines, and terrible acting. I must admit that the guys are incredibly athletic but I don't see the appeal in watching two people pretend to beat each other up.
 

DudeistBelieve

TellEmSteveDave.com
Sep 9, 2010
4,771
1
0
Sovvolf said:
SaneAmongInsane said:
When, not if, MMA becomes staged fans won't know about it. It'll be a closely guarded secret, just like Pro-Wrestling's false hood was initially, and if the fighters are smart they'll learn from the mistakes of the past keep it that way.
You seem overly confident on the idea that MMA will go the way of Pro-wrestling. I don't think so but I wouldn't deal in absolutes.
History repeats. If it doesn't, it'll burn it's fanbase over time the same way boxing did.

Mind you I think the MMA candle has just begun to burn, so it'll be a while before this would happen... Hell it could be happening right now, in theory, how would we really know if the fights were fixed?
 

The Floating Nose

Senior Member
Dec 5, 2010
329
3
23
I really like pro wrestling (WWE) but i really don't watch it as often as before. The wrestlers are not as entertaining as before (seriously i can't believe that Randy Orton is where he is right now he sucks and his promos are DREADFUL, he's a unidimentional character. He wouldn't be able to be belivable as a face even if his life depended on it) but i like to watch some of my DVDs or VHS or even watch some matches on YOUTUBE once in a while. Why do i like it ? Well, im a HUGE movie fan (i want to be a film director) and i like sports and wrestling is like the best of both worlds. I know, most of the time, the wrestlers are HORRIBLE actors but that's funny sometimes.

I don't really watch independent promotions honestly and i watch japanese wrestling sometimes too and it is great.

As for TNA though, don't even get me started, that fucking promotion who spits in the face of their fans every single week. Yeah, they rename their show Impact Wrestling to have more focus on wrestling but they STILL have 20 minutes of ring action every week. You have a 2 hours WRESTLING show and you have 20 minutes of actual WRESTLING the rest is just some horrible storylines and pointless segments and most of the wrestling actions are either squash match (Match that ends in 2 minutes) or they finish with a run-in (another performer interferes in the match). Seriously, every fucking match that they have ends with a run-in even on PPV that's unbelivable. Fuck you Dixie Carter !

That's why i watch Botchamania on YOUTUBE to have a good laugh at this horrible company.
 

Sovvolf

New member
Mar 23, 2009
2,341
0
0
SaneAmongInsane said:
Sovvolf said:
SaneAmongInsane said:
When, not if, MMA becomes staged fans won't know about it. It'll be a closely guarded secret, just like Pro-Wrestling's false hood was initially, and if the fighters are smart they'll learn from the mistakes of the past keep it that way.
You seem overly confident on the idea that MMA will go the way of Pro-wrestling. I don't think so but I wouldn't deal in absolutes.
History repeats. If it doesn't, it'll burn it's fanbase over time the same way boxing did.

Mind you I think the MMA candle has just begun to burn, so it'll be a while before this would happen... Hell it could be happening right now, in theory, how would we really know if the fights were fixed?
it'd probably be much more obvious. Could in theory but I highly doubt it. You could say that for boxing and any other sporting event. How do we know Football isn't fixed? and such doesn't make it so, only the deeply paranoid would think so. Even before the whole scandal, many thought wrestling was fake, it did look heavily choreographed and such. Hell, even a joke is made in Rocky III with Hulk Hogan on the whole fake thing and that was back in 1982.
 

DudeistBelieve

TellEmSteveDave.com
Sep 9, 2010
4,771
1
0
Sovvolf said:
SaneAmongInsane said:
Sovvolf said:
SaneAmongInsane said:
When, not if, MMA becomes staged fans won't know about it. It'll be a closely guarded secret, just like Pro-Wrestling's false hood was initially, and if the fighters are smart they'll learn from the mistakes of the past keep it that way.
You seem overly confident on the idea that MMA will go the way of Pro-wrestling. I don't think so but I wouldn't deal in absolutes.
History repeats. If it doesn't, it'll burn it's fanbase over time the same way boxing did.

Mind you I think the MMA candle has just begun to burn, so it'll be a while before this would happen... Hell it could be happening right now, in theory, how would we really know if the fights were fixed?
it'd probably be much more obvious. Could in theory but I highly doubt it. You could say that for boxing and any other sporting event. How do we know Football isn't fixed? and such doesn't make it so, only the deeply paranoid would think so. Even before the whole scandal, many thought wrestling was fake, it did look heavily choreographed and such. Hell, even a joke is made in Rocky III with Hulk Hogan on the whole fake thing and that was back in 1982.
This is gonna take a bit of explaining, you may want to get yourself some snacks.

Because by then it slowly moved more towards entertainment from about the 1960's onward. Rumblings that it was fake really didn't come about till the 80's. For plenty of decades the entire thing was a charade and no one knew.

How do we know football isn't fake? Well for one thing, to many players. the more people in on the secret the harder it is to contain. Also generally it's relatively easy to get into the NFL, and I don't mean easy as in I could do it, but easy as in they're scouting for the best players not weeding out people that would blow the whistle on the scam. The fact that wrestling was fake use to be a carefully guarded secret, veterans training rookies would put their trainiees through absolute hell before letting them in on the secret. First day of training, Hulk Hogan's trainer broke his legs intentionally.

Boxing isn't something you rig easily either, because how could you throw fake punches for 12 rounds and not visibly show any damage to the face? That's why wrestlers tend to avoid punching to much. Now I know what your saying, that's a huge part of MMA too, but as it is the fans are more warmed up now to the ground work then they use to be. Also unlike boxing, their hands are free so it's very possible for them to conceal a blade for cutting their scalp like wrestlers do. There is also a significant advantage of the fact that MMA fighters actually have time off in beteewn fights, something that a wrestler that's on the road 320 days a year performing matches every night doesn't, so it's very possible they can take advantage of their bodies more and work rather stiff/snug (legit) and make the stuff look as real as possible while still avoiding major injury and putting on a good show and planning the outcome.

Also back when it was slowly becoming a "work" (I like this word better then fake, because I've bumped around a ring a little bit and if it was all fake it wouldn't hurt as much as it did.) It was more then likely that it was only the top guys that were in on the work. I believe, I'm going from memory here so I may be wrong, one of the first work contests was George Hackinschmidt agreeing to lose the first fall of a 2/3 fall match up with Ed "The Strangler" Lewis to make the fight more interesting and make some extra money. Ed was suppose to lose the second fall and they'd have a legit battle for the third fall... but Ed was an oppurtunist that took the first fall and then double cross Hackinschmidt and won the second fall and one the World title.

MMA is bassicaly the wrestling business at the turn of the century, it would make sense that everything would happen the same way eventually. The only thing I could imagine preventing this is the rise of the internet and technology, cell phone cameras being everywhere and what not, would expose it. But that's the only thing. I say MMA's gorgeous george is only 20 years away.

EDIT: Also if you asked a wrestler from that old time era if it was fake, something like this would happen...


And that was in 1997 dude!
 

Sovvolf

New member
Mar 23, 2009
2,341
0
0
SaneAmongInsane said:
An interesting theory. Good history work but I still don't buy it and I still don't think that MMA will go down that route. I've been to the gyms, (I do MMA, more of an hobby sport than pro but well I still train at it) I've seen the people training this. Its not a route I can see them going down, the fighters there, they get into it because its real, a lot to test themselves. There's not all that much money in MMA and for the little guys it cost more to train than they often earn from fighting.

Might be able to convince some of the higher guys to fix a fight. However to get the lot to do that? I can't see it happening. Besides, the top guys of the bigger promotions (Dana White and such) I can't see them wanting to fetch it in that direction.

Also boxing can and has been fixed before, people taking a dive here and there. The punching is very real but the result is rigged.

I just can't see it going down that road. Perhaps history will repeat itself, I just doubt it.

I think theres too much risk versus reward here to get it like that. You'd have to break your full roster for, meaning you'd have to get a bunch of people who can keep a secret, are willing to sell out on the sport and have enough pull to keep the audience interested. That and what about when they're dropped from the roster for say, bad behavior, poor popularity and such? Are these going to keep this secret? What about when they get to a new legit promotion. That and as said, with todays technology, I doubt it could work. Maybe back in the 80's without internet and such... Today I doubt it.