Poll: RPG's: Old vs New

Recommended Videos

Treeinthewoods

New member
May 14, 2010
1,228
0
0
Where is my option to choose "Yes to both?" I love all kinds of RPG's.

Anybody who chooses one or the other is basically passing on an opportunity to enjoy the many great RPG's that have been released recently and many years ago. Am I the only gamer who likes to play practically everything as long as it's a game?
 

Jaranja

New member
Jul 16, 2009
3,275
0
0
Radeonx said:
What do you mean by old?
Because my favorite RPG was KotOR, which came out around 2003, but I don't consider 7 years old very old. Same with NWN and Baldur's Gate.
But I've liked Bioware games more than anything, so I guess I'll say newish?
This is EXACTLY what I was thinking.

Bioware RPG's (except Mass Effect 1) are amazing.

BG2
BG1
DA:O
ME2
SW: KOTOR

All of them are fucking well-made.

[sub]I didn't put them in order............ [/sarcasm][/sub]
 

Dexiro

New member
Dec 23, 2009
2,977
0
0
I don't think there's an age barrier. Older generations have good and bad RPG's, just as the newer generations do.
Although some people might prefer older RPG's because certain characteristics were more common in those generations.
 

Lightslei

New member
Feb 18, 2010
559
0
0
I prefer RPGs that are simplistic and don't require me to think immediately which is why I'm a large fan of TBC. Don't matter old or new.

Also if it's an FPS I hate it just because I find them extroadinarily boring. *Waits to be assaulted by every FPS fanboy ever*
 

Dragunai

New member
Feb 5, 2007
534
0
0
Humble85 said:
Dragunai said:
The formulaic rpgs to which you refer seem to be mostly cloning good games such as anything by bioware or blizzard in order to leech the success of those games to a rather easily amused generation of gamers and I am proud to stand up on my snobby old school gaming veteran soap box and shout that the modern age of the games industry is pandering big time to the casual era of uninteliigent cry babies who ***** if the game requires more effort or thinking than point crosshair press button which is why we have to suffer this bile churning insurgence of FPS games who in turn breed the notion that these immature self righteous dumbasses are somehow gaming gods while they flee from the challenge of RTS / RPG games which actually require you to think all the while shouting "it sucks, you suck, get a life you nerd" from their bedrooms because its after 8pm and their mommy wont let them out their room after curfew.
You took the term "zero punctuation" quite literally, didnt you? :) But I agree with you. Because, as for ...
Valkyrie101 said:
New ones [...] generally [have] better stories and more engaging characters/dialogue. O
... I have to ask:"Where? Show me!" I may have missed some games in the past. As for Fallout 2, i dont know how it was "amazingly" difficult, except that the first dungeon was a bit of a more challenge than the cave in 1.
Didnt take anything from zero, Just personal preference.
Ben is more into FPS games than RPGs while I fall into his catergory of loathing, the online rpg gamer ^_^ and yet despite his constant abuse I come back to his reviews each week haha.

Rewold said:
Dragunai said:
Rewold said:
I don't really know how to explain it but I think FF7(started replaying it yesterday) just has something I don't feel today's RPG's have.
A massive cult following of obsessive Cosplaying fanboys who refuse to let it go as a distinctly mediocre game with a predictable storyline and the least functional magic system in the series?
I thought FF7 had the best magic system in the series with FF9 close second...I guess our tastes are worlds apart.
FF7 didnt have a magic system, it had "take materia A, attach to Character B, Cast spell C"
FF9 actually had a functioning magic system. Vivi learnt dark spells from whatever was equipped then to use them along with the auto shizzle you had to spend those blue gems, Garnet, Aka Dagger, Aka Princess slutbag used white magic, Steiner used the magic sword system when combined with vivi in the party. It was genius, 7 just let you staple any spell, any skill to any character meaning each and every single character in 7 was interchangable and thus you could focus on just your fav 3 unlike 9 where each character had unique skills to offer from the ground up.

So yes Our tastes are very different. I like sophisticated depth and tactical arrangemnts of character combinations while any FF7 fan likes having a spikey haired emo run around with 2 interchangable B characters who have no unique traits outside their limit breaks and even those were of limited use beyond Climhazard.

Even Zidane in FF9 was a far superior character to Cloud because Zidane was a spunky fun loving rogue while Cloud just like squall was a standard issue print of an anti hero. Frankly in FF7/8 I loved the supporting characters like Quistis, Zell and selphie because they were fun and light hearted when Squall was off mopping somewhere, same in FF7 with Barret and Yuffie because they had personality.

Writing was better in 8 and 9 better enemies because in 8 you had Edea and Seifer for a big part of the story as the main enemy and my favourite FF badguy EVER! Kuja in FF9. Dude was mint in his inception, style and even his personal bg music was awesome.

Then you get Sephiroth, the most over hyped silver haired conceptualisation of anything that is considered "cool" in the cosplay world - long white / silver hair, big ass sword, black cloak / coat. The guy is such a sterotype it makes me wanna puke.

Hell Kuja even came in 2 flavours - vanilla and strawberry.

heres a link to his theme tune:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IkamgZq-wT8
(listen out for the drumline and piano fusion which makes it eerie)
 

Johnny Cain

New member
Apr 18, 2010
328
0
0
Humble85 said:
Johnny Cain said:
Shameful I know, but go try Fallout 2. It's amazingly difficult compared to the first.
What do you mean by that, exactly?
OT: Old. I have yet to see a current generation RPG with story/characters that even remotely compare to P:T, an atmospheres like Arcanums or the freedom of Fallout 1 and 2. Maybe its just me, but I have the feeling that the newer ones are just... too formulaic, idk.
Fallout 2 is freaking hard?

Fallout 1 was easy going and forgave you a little early on -encounters were easy to escape from if you got in over your head- but Fallout 2 punishes you to succeed from the off, pitting you solo against overwhelming odds. And with one key difference: You couldn't loot armour from enemies. Just popped that raider boss, fancy yourself his suit of Metal Armor? Tough Bananas, that's not how it works in THIS game!
It didn't make the game any less awesome however, and just made the successes all the sweeter.
 

Nwabudike Morgan

New member
Oct 25, 2009
713
0
0
I beat Fallout 2 on my jinxed/luck 10 playthrough because Frank Horrigan's gun exploded as he was taking his first shot at me, inflicting a critical hit, blowing him to pieces.
 

Candidus

New member
Dec 17, 2009
1,095
0
0
Baldur's Gate 2 is unsurpassed. I voted old, because in my view a corner in development style has definately been turned since the Forgotten Realms greats.
 

The Madman

New member
Dec 7, 2007
4,404
0
0
Oldish?

Most of my favorite RPG are within the 10 year range, and many others only slightly slightly before that. That's not really what I consider old.

I'm betting my favorite RPG, Baldur's Gate 2: Shadows of Amn is considered an oldie now though, which makes me in turn feel old, so I guess I'll vote that.

Baldur's Gate 2: Tens years running and still the best damn game I've ever played. Who'd have guessed?
 

thegrimfandango

New member
May 26, 2010
126
0
0
Honestly, I have a lot of love for both old and new. I just really like RPGs in general, it's my genre of choice.
 

likalaruku

New member
Nov 29, 2008
4,290
0
0
joe102 said:
I have been playing RPG's for as long as I can remember and I have to say older one's like neverwinter nights and baldurs gate really had me hooked but I found once I knew what would happen next started to lack the sense of mystery that I loved while new games like fallout 3 and mass effect 2 have more replay value but I dont have the will to explore that I had with older one's.

So I ask you which do you prefer and the games mentioned above are for example only this is more about the genre in genral.
Baldur's Gate & Neverwinter Nights are my absolute favorites. & Diablo & Dungeon Siege. Nostolgia has a strong set of teeth firmly gripped to my brain.
 

SUPA FRANKY

New member
Aug 18, 2009
1,889
0
0
Of course in game play and design, newer rpgs flat out pwn older games. But older games had this sense of adventure. Things didn't seem so planned out and it just felt more like you were in the game world on an adventure rather than following a linear storyline.

...Or it could just be my nostalgia kicking in.