Poll: Sci-fi vs Fantasy RPGs?

Recommended Videos

DeadlyYellow

New member
Jun 18, 2008
5,141
0
0
Man this is getting bad. It's getting to the point I have to search for my own name just to make sure I haven't already replied to this topic.

But as I've said in the last ten, I have no preference. I play whatever happens to strike my fancy.
 

lonercs

New member
Jun 6, 2008
260
0
0
Jark212 said:
Sci-Fi, the future is fun...

By fun I mean it's full of war, genocide, and the awesomeness that is cross-species sexual encounters with curiously humanoid looking aliens...
So you favor an entire sub-genre because of 1 (ok 2) games? Both of with is in the same series?

Wow.
 

brown_coat

New member
Oct 5, 2009
21
0
0
I also have to add that JRPGs (ones released in US) also have one of 2 recipes

1. young protagonist
2. has a mentor
3. his world flipped upside down
4. becomes more self assured
5. falls in love with child hood sweet heart/ party member
6. heavy cutscenes

or

1. emo lone swordsmen
2. little known past
3. party member loves him he is too much of a empty shell to care
4. heavy cutscene
5. obvious twist
6. heavy cutscenes
 

Jark212

Certified Deviant
Jul 17, 2008
4,455
0
0
lonercs said:
Jark212 said:
Sci-Fi, the future is fun...

By fun I mean it's full of war, genocide, and the awesomeness that is cross-species sexual encounters with curiously humanoid looking aliens...
So you favor an entire sub-genre because of 1 (ok 2) games? Both of with is in the same series?

Wow.
What I was referring to is that a lot of sci-fi games have one or many of these traits like: Halo series, Fallout series, Bioshock series, Warhammer 40k, Destroy all Humans, Command & Conquer, S.T.A.L.K.E.R., DOOM, Gears of War, exc...
 

Duke Machine

New member
Aug 27, 2008
113
0
0
Sci-fi definitely, I enjoy a fantasy game every now and again (Dragon Age) but I just feel so pathetic when i play them...probably a hold over from those god forsaken runescape days
 

Dorian Cornelius Jasper

Space Robot From Outer Space
Apr 8, 2008
396
0
0
Jark212 said:
(so much snipping)
Actually, the other guy was talking specifically about RPGs since that's what the topic's about. And your comment pretty much singled out the Mass Effect series, since you'll not find a sexual encounter with aliens in the Capital Wasteland. Or in the deserts of Northern California, if you're old-school enough for a Fallout that isn't also a shooter.
 

DoctorNick

New member
Oct 31, 2007
881
0
0
ramik81 said:
Since every fantasy is trying to be a JRR fantasy, I've really gotten tired of them.

Right now Sci-fi just seems to have more freshness involved.
There are truth in this mans words.

I really do love both genres, flying around in space is just as cool to me as hacking apart foes with a broadsword.

Problem is it seems like ninety-nine percent of all fantasy games exhumed Tolkiens corpse just to see what else they could get out of his pockets and perhaps pull out his gold fillings while they're at it. I like games such as Oblivion and Dragon Age, but I like them in spite of them being full of orcs, elves, 'ye olde fantasy engrish' and the dwarves who hate the elves.[footnote]Oddly though despite the previous comment I do really like dwarves for some reason. A race of technically minded subterranean alcoholics appeals to me on some level.[/footnote]

As such, I've been having better luck with Sci-Fi games lately. They also have a lot of the same sort of dead-horse-tropes that also populate fantasy games, but at least the devs seem to be aware of this fact and actively try to be as unique as their risk-adverse corporate paymasters will let them.
 

Talvrae

The Purple Fairy
Dec 8, 2009
896
0
0
LordOfInsanity said:
I actually tend to be 50/50 in the regards to which I prefer. Some Sci-fi RPGs rock and others fail hard. Same goes wit fantasy. Though the number one fail fantasy RPG is Two Worlds currently.
^^This exactelly
 

Nomanslander

New member
Feb 21, 2009
2,963
0
0
lonercs said:
brown_coat said:
J. R. R. Tolkien is also the father of the fantasy genre.
He's left a lasting impression on fantasy in the past century, but I wouldn't go so far as to call him the father of the genre.

A lot of these stories about elves and dwarves go back a thousand years. Hell some anthropologist have theories that the stories of ogres and trolls originated from homo sapiens early encounters with Neanderthals, and they went extinct about 30,000 years ago...so can imagine just how old these stories might be.

JRR was still a new kid on the block when it comes to fantasy.
 

More Fun To Compute

New member
Nov 18, 2008
4,061
0
0
I prefer fantasy for RPGs.

I read more Science Fiction than Fantasy but there are some things about RPG games that do not work for Science Fiction while working for Fantasy. I would pick Science Fiction for adventure games.