Poll: Superior Character: Batman or Superman

Recommended Videos

Yopaz

Sarcastic overlord
Jun 3, 2009
6,092
0
0
I like Batman the most because even though he got his wealth when his parents died he needed to work hard to get his skills. He uses his money in order to fight crime his way. Superman is a hero. Batman is more of a vigilante. It's easier to see a vigilante who defies the law in order to do his thing than one who is praised by everyone.

Also Superman's "disguise" is too silly for me to be able to take it seriously. "Hey, that looks like Clark Kent!" "Don't be silly, he uses glasses and Superman doesn't". Also The Incredibles taught me that you should never use a cape. EVER.
 

CODE-D

New member
Feb 6, 2011
1,966
0
0
McMarbles said:
To everyone saying Superman is boring, overpowered, has no peronality...

How many of you have actually sat down and read a Superman story?

Not a Batman story where Superman appears so he can get shown up by Batman, to show everyone how awesome and unbeatable Batman is.

Not a story where Batman and Superman ostensibly share billing, but Superman gets downplayed because the writer has a hardon for Batman.

An actual Superman story.
Its more about aesthetics than stories. (although batman does have better stories(to me))
Batman
Normal man
Superman
Alien
see right there you already have to suspend your belief with superman.

Origin
Batman
Wants to bring justice to the city he grew up in so trains himself physically(like a ninja/fighter) and mentally(like a detective/scientist) to bring this about, also dawns black cape and cowl
Superman
Yellow sun gives him power
Keeps normalcy of his life, his town and sometimes earth, sometimes space.

Villains
Batman
gangsters and psychopaths(whom we all love)


Superman
Lex
Aliens
robots
anybody who knows his weakness

Combat
Batman
Cool gadgets
multiple offensive styles
Planning ahead or if not, analyzing for weaknesses

Superman
Punch
Tackle
various special attacks(lasers, ice breath)
hes a fuckin pokemon

Identity
Batman
Bruce millionaire wayne

Superman
Kent I work at the news Clark
Whos disguise no person can believe works as popular as superman is in his universe.

Lookin at all that batmans just cooler in the long run.
 

Vern5

New member
Mar 3, 2011
1,633
0
0
Batman wins over Superman any day. Why? Adaptability.

Superman is mostly suited for using his considerable brawn to take on his enemies, maybe with some creative use of his other super powers. Still, Superman is all about overpowering his enemies.

Batman, while not being as powerful, more than makes up for this deficiency with creativity, resourcefulness, and a bit of diplomacy. Batman's approach to solving a problem is more strategic. He comes at a problem from several directions at once in an attempt to defuse the crisis rather than just crush it into dust. Because of this, Batman can naturally solve situations where force is not an option, whereas Superman would have to stretch his resources in order to achieve victory.

*I base this opinion solely upon watching Batman:TAS, Superman:TAS, Justice League & Justice League Unlimited.*
 

lRookiel

Lord of Infinite Grins
Jun 30, 2011
2,821
0
0
Batamn I'd say, he has a better story and gets to fight my favourite villian The Joker :3
 
Feb 13, 2008
19,430
0
0
Tricky one:

Mentally: Bats
Monetarily: Bats
Physically: Supes (by a long chalk)
Physically - with preparation time: Bats (He carries kryptonite and he has author powers)
Charisma: Supes
Characterwise: Supes - by a long shot: Batman has no real character.
Staminawise: Supes
Marysue Powers: Equally matched; both have done impossible things, have different coloured eyes, slept with lots of people.

Overall: Superman - because Bats has never died and come back again. He's been Bane-d, but it's not the same as Doomsday'd.
 
Feb 13, 2008
19,430
0
0
Spot1990 said:
Superman isn't just my favourite of the two, he's my favourite Superhero (Unless Constantine counts).
Now there's a battle royale:

Superman (all American Good Guy) versus Constantine (all British Bad Ass)

Especially given Supes is vulnerable to magic.

Constantine versus Bats would be over instantly. Probably with Bruce and John in bed.
 

Vausch

New member
Dec 7, 2009
1,476
0
0
It's really hard to say. I love both of them, but Yahtzee is right: Batman is the least interesting person in everything he's in. His villains are the interesting story. Under the Red Hood: Joker scared me almost as much as Heath Ledger's, Jason Todd finally went from being a whiny asshole to an interesting character I liked and felt a lot of sympathy for (not to mention the great idea the writers had to ditch the Superboy Prime Retcon Punch). Yes, he is great as a whole but in all honesty sometimes I feel like writers have to purposefully nerf other characters to make him usable. Sure, Batman is prepared for everything any time but still.

Superman is also great because, well, he's superman. He's an alien raised as a farmboy to be a good person all around and use his powers to make the world better for those around him. Heck, he even continues to tell people not to view him or anyone else as a god and find their own way despite him having the power to do almost anything he wanted. Heck in certain comics he even decides to do so and things turn out for the worst (Superman: Red Son).

It's hard to call, I don't want to imagine a world without either of them.
 

Vausch

New member
Dec 7, 2009
1,476
0
0
Melanie McGreevey said:
Batman, given enough prep time he can take down anyone and has. From what i understand all of the kryptonite has been gathered and destroyed (on earth) as well as Bats has some in his possession. Superman is a good person, and i doubt would kill batman, even if he wanted to, he's a boy scout. Batman, however, if it meant him or Clark, Clark's days would be numbered. He's brilliant, and can come up with something that could defeat supes.
Superman actually gave Batman the Kryptonite in case he ever needed it, should Superman become possessed or lose his way or something. Superman definitely does have a good sense of foresight, no denying that.

I'm not arguing Batman is worse, I can't pick between the two XD
 

Vausch

New member
Dec 7, 2009
1,476
0
0
The_root_of_all_evil said:
Tricky one:

Mentally: Bats
Monetarily: Bats
Physically: Supes (by a long chalk)
Physically - with preparation time: Bats (He carries kryptonite and he has author powers)
Charisma: Supes
Characterwise: Supes - by a long shot: Batman has no real character.
Staminawise: Supes
Marysue Powers: Equally matched; both have done impossible things, have different coloured eyes, slept with lots of people.

Overall: Superman - because Bats has never died and come back again. He's been Bane-d, but it's not the same as Doomsday'd.
Well... that's arguable because of Final Crisis. Batman didn't technically die, he went back in time and became a caveman, pirate, knight, etc.

Superman came back from the dead, Batman got cloned and the clone got killed almost instantaneously as Batman was sent back in time within the same instant and had to fight his way back through time to come back...

COMICS...ARE...WIEEERRRRD!
 

dickywebster

New member
Jul 11, 2011
497
0
0
Its batman, he probably has some krypotnite around somewhere and then he would use it to beat superman silly, like the majority of people have to do to even scratch superman.
But in terms of the person and story and villans, im still going batman, superman always seems kinda 2D to me.
 

SD-Fiend

Member
Legacy
Nov 24, 2009
2,075
0
1
Country
United States
remnant_phoenix said:
The Consequence said:
Alright. When it comes to fighting I am quite sure that Superman would punch a hole through Batman's face and that would be the end of it. Now it pains me to say that because I think as a whole Batman is a far better character than Superman. More interesting. His story lines are better, but, what do you guys think?
usmarine4160 said:
Superman for aforementioned face-hole punching
Wrong and wrong.

Batman has beaten Superman in the comics twice.

Batman always keeps a small stash of Kryptonite just in case Superman goes bad, and Batman always sees Superman's attacks coming because Superman is a meathead and Batman is a genius.
sorry but no. superman gave batman the kryptonite just in case one day he goes crazy or something. And calling superman a meat head? Now that's just unfair superman is still a genius and could do things that no mortal man's brain could whilst batman is just better at deductive reasoning (seeing as how he is a detective in most ways)
 

SD-Fiend

Member
Legacy
Nov 24, 2009
2,075
0
1
Country
United States
I'd say Superman. Why? because unlike batman he actually has a weakness and actually has to try
 

Thaluikhain

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 16, 2010
19,538
4,128
118
TheKasp said:
Yeah, when Darkseid, a god, kicks Sups ass it's rediculous... Superman fights entities stronger than him on a regular basis and even on earth are several people who can go toe on toe with him (Captain Marvel for example).
Well, it is still rather ridiculous though, you end up with a silly arms race/power creep thing going on, everything ends up OtT.

IMHO, they should ahve kept Batman and Superman seperate, they don't fucntion well in the same universe.
 

SycoMantis91

New member
Dec 21, 2011
343
0
0
Superman's definitely the more boring of the two. His character doesn't have the flurry of twists and turns that Batman does. And when he does, it needs to be manufactured around him as opposed to just being a part of his psyche. Though neither is my fav, I do enjoy watching/reading both, but Batman is the better.
 

WolfThomas

Man must have a code.
Dec 21, 2007
5,292
0
0
Yopaz said:
Also Superman's "disguise" is too silly for me to be able to take it seriously. "Hey, that looks like Clark Kent!" "Don't be silly, he uses glasses and Superman doesn't". Also The Incredibles taught me that you should never use a cape. EVER.
Well there's a lot of explanations for his disguise. The first is historic/cultural, if you've ever heard of the "grandfather clause", basically when you introduce a new rule it doesn't apply to stuf that predates it. So Superman was invented in the 30's, how superheroes hadn't been hammered out yet and it was a simpler time, technology of the time meant that it would be easier for someone to get around without a mask. If you introduce a new character without a mask, you'd have to deal with this issue, but in general Superman just gets a pass.

In universe there's lots of reasons why his disguise works, firstly a lot of people just assume Superman doesn't have a civillian identity, that he might have been a normal person originally but why would he hold down a day job? Then Superman can vibrate slightly ont he spot at superspeed so there's never any really good photographs of him to compare with. Then when it comes to Clark Kent his entire behaviour changes (he's meant to be a pheonomenal actor), his voice changes raises in pitch, his entire posture is much weaker, he makes less eye contact, this makes you less likely to notice Clark Kent, let alone ponder if he's Superman. Then Clark has a very generic face (some elseworlds have actually explain this as an effect of the spaceship/birthing module making his assilimilation into the human race easier, but that's not really canon), a lot of people probably look like Superman.

Then there's the glasses, they aren't just clear lens, Clark wears glasses with a very strong prescription, the sort that distort your face and eyes, and anyone who knows someone who wears glasses all the time has experienced the shock when seeing them without them, it's very different. Also finally Superman and Clark Kent have been in the same place several times, thanks to Batman and robot copies of Superman.

As for the cape, it's usually made out of Kryptonian cloth that is as tough as Superman, he can use it to wrap someone in when pulling them out of a burning building or similar circumstances and not one of the scenarios posed by Edna would happen to Superman, he couldn't be pulled into a turbine or dragged along by a rocket.
 

him over there

New member
Dec 17, 2011
1,728
0
0
Batman had two decent videogames, dare I say even great games that outdid most of the industry despite being licensed work.

Superman has this:
I believe the choice is pretty clear. Green lantern is superior to both though.
Yopaz said:
Also Superman's "disguise" is too silly for me to be able to take it seriously. "Hey, that looks like Clark Kent!" "Don't be silly, he uses glasses and Superman doesn't".
I challenge that good sir!
Yeah I know it's a pretty crappy anime but the point still stands.