The_ModeRazor said:
CorvinBlack said:
Pirates of course.
Ninja attacks with it's shinobigatana or Kyotetsu-shoge and Pirate shoots it dead. With a gun.
Ninja tries to sneak up on Pirate, Parrot warns Pirate, Pirate shoots Ninja. With a gun.
Ninja hide in Ryu of the clan, Pirate blasts clan away. With cannons. Ninja go boom.
Ninja hides in plain sight as a commoner. Pirates don't make social distiction and rape, plunder, rob and kill everybody. Ninja dies - or gets gangbanged and commits suicide.
Ninja gather all forces for a battle. Pirates outnumber then 10 to 1. And outgun them 10 to 0. Ninja get shot. With guns.
And on and on and on... Don't even try to cry about ninjas sneaking up on a pirate ship - only 1 ninja could try it - more would only hinder each other in the attempt, get cought and then shot. With a gun. And only 1 ninja couldn't do anything on a pirate ship. If he can evade the very smart parrot sentinels - he will still get cought - either by being the only one with wet clothing or the only on not stinking of rum. Then he gets shot. With a gun.
I'm fairly sure that in a plane of existence where there are guns, ninjas would definitely use them. Cheap insta-kill is definitely what ninjas are about.
Sorry, pirates are f*cked.
Nonsense. I tought we talked about traditional Ninjas and Pirates. If we take into account the Golden Age of piracy and Ninjas, it would overlap right about between 1550 - 1650. This would be the Sengoku period in Japan, just before the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate, which is also the time Japan was introduced to Firearms - the matchlock aquebus. So, traditinal Ninjas would have a chance to get some guns, although a very slim chance. Pirates were much better armed, they had way more experience with firearms, they know how to effectivly use them in battle (especially Spanish pirates as most served in Tercios before) and Pirates had access to technologically superior firearms. Ninjas, even if they had some, couldn't realy train in the use of firearms, without drawing attention, which defeats the purpose of Ninjas. So Pirates win.
But, if we want to use fantasy Pirates and Ninjas, then, both have a even chance - Ninjas with their immunity to death, gravity, fatigue and bullets, and Pirates with their awsomeness, magic, curses , will and romantic spirit - romantic heros always win. Pirates win again. Narrowly. But note that Pirates are not the heros portrayed in romantic novels. They would most likely stab the Ninja from behind. Then rape him. And still his stuff. While looking awsome. And suffering a terminal illness.