Poll: Tomb Raider reboot, what is your opinion on it now?

Recommended Videos

Erttheking

Member
Legacy
Oct 5, 2011
10,845
1
3
Country
United States
Blunderboy said:
Legion said:
m19 said:
No. And never was. Not even in the old days. Sexualized =/= sexist.
Exactly.

Sexism is about discrimination, not how attractive a fictional female character is. If the game developers had said "We made her hot because nobody would care otherwise" that'd be sexist. If they'd made her attractive because "It's not like girls play games, so who is going to complain" that'd be sexist.

Simply designing her to be physically attractive is not discrimination, and not sexism.
I will say that this is correct.
Also, THIS TOPIC HAS BEEN DONE A BAJILLION TIMES. Move on OP, move on.
You know, I could've sworn that I said that I wanted to get a perspective on people's opinion now that things have calmed down in the OP.
 

TehCookie

Elite Member
Sep 16, 2008
3,923
0
41
I find the new game to be way more sexist than the old ones. In the old ones she was sexy, I don't get how that is sexist. In the new ones she's unable to do anything on her own and you're suppose to be her helper and cheering her on. Having a game that you're not suppose to role-play/relate to her because she's a women and are suppose to watch over her instead is plain offensive to me.
 

m19

New member
Jun 13, 2012
283
0
0
TehCookie said:
I find the new game to be way more sexist than the old ones. In the old ones she was sexy, I don't get how that is sexist. In the new ones she's unable to do anything on her own and you're suppose to be her helper and cheering her on. Having a game that you're not suppose to role-play/relate to her because she's a women and are suppose to watch over her instead is plain offensive to me.
What could she do on her own in the old game?
 

00slash00

New member
Dec 29, 2009
2,321
0
0
erttheking said:
I might be poking the hornet's nest here, but what does everyone else think about the upcoming Tomb Raider reboot? Sexist or not? I'm curious to see what the popular opinion is now that we've had time to mull things over after the announcements and initial controversy.

I actually kinda like the concept of it, it's not like Other M where the main character has daddy issues like you wouldn't believe and has to have her ass saved and claims up in front of the dragon THAT SHE HAS KILLED ON NUMEROUS OCCASIONS!

It's a teenage girl trapped on an island with no combat experience, and it's about her stepping up to the challenge and overcoming the hardships put in front of her. She gets beaten up a lot? This may sounds cruel, but good, it builds character. I really don't see how someone getting beaten up a lot is sexist, no one said that Captain Walker getting half of his face burnt off in Spec Ops the line was torture porn. Come to think of it, I haven't played Far Cry 3, but I have read that there is some instances of the male protagonist being tortured, nearly dying in some very horrific scenes, losing a finger, and there is an ACTUAL instance of rape in Far Cry 3...and it's male on male. So yeah, just my opinion, but I really don't think that Tomb Raider is sexist, I don't think that the bad things that are going to happen to her are just because she's a girl, they're happening to her because they're a (very brutal) way to build character
the reason people have said the game is sexist isnt because theres an attempted rape scene, its because of how the games producer explained it. what is sexist is the quote, ?When people play Lara, they don?t really project themselves into the character. They?re more like ?I want to protect her.? There?s this sort of dynamic of ?I?m going to this adventure with her and trying to protect her.??

?She?s definitely the hero but? you?re kind of like her helper. When you see her have to face these challenges, you start to root for her in a way that you might not root for a male character.?
 

m19

New member
Jun 13, 2012
283
0
0
This is what I don't get about feminists. They will tell you that a woman lives in fear of assault and rape in much bigger measure than a man does because women are inherently more vulnerable to these things and then they'll turn around and be upset when a man thinks a female character is more vulnerable and hence you root for her differently.
 

Erttheking

Member
Legacy
Oct 5, 2011
10,845
1
3
Country
United States
TehCookie said:
I find the new game to be way more sexist than the old ones. In the old ones she was sexy, I don't get how that is sexist. In the new ones she's unable to do anything on her own and you're suppose to be her helper and cheering her on. Having a game that you're not suppose to role-play/relate to her because she's a women and are suppose to watch over her instead is plain offensive to me.
I can't help but feel like you're focusing less on the game and more on what one twat said. No offense.
 

TehCookie

Elite Member
Sep 16, 2008
3,923
0
41
m19 said:
TehCookie said:
I find the new game to be way more sexist than the old ones. In the old ones she was sexy, I don't get how that is sexist. In the new ones she's unable to do anything on her own and you're suppose to be her helper and cheering her on. Having a game that you're not suppose to role-play/relate to her because she's a women and are suppose to watch over her instead is plain offensive to me.
What could she do on her own in the old game?
She did everything on her own.
 

BrotherRool

New member
Oct 31, 2008
3,834
0
0
I'm glad you mentioned Far Cry, how come no actual rape at all gets a scandal and the game with real rape in it doesn't?

I've always been fine with the reboot. The original tomb raider was sexist. This is an undenyable fact. It's aim was to objectify a women for the pleasure of guys. There is a reason that many people have noticed that the character design seemed to..expand somewhat with time. There is a reason why they were busy touting the feature of Lara's clothes getting wet and it wasn't for the same reason Uncharted did it
 

m19

New member
Jun 13, 2012
283
0
0
TehCookie said:
She did everything on her own.
No... You did everything for her with a controller. How deeply you identified with her (or not) is a matter of your attitude, not the game's.

Which is what the guy was talking about, correctly or not. The new Lara does all those things "on her own", how you feel about her is on you. Everyone's relationship with a fictional protagonist is their own.
 

Erttheking

Member
Legacy
Oct 5, 2011
10,845
1
3
Country
United States
TehCookie said:
m19 said:
TehCookie said:
I find the new game to be way more sexist than the old ones. In the old ones she was sexy, I don't get how that is sexist. In the new ones she's unable to do anything on her own and you're suppose to be her helper and cheering her on. Having a game that you're not suppose to role-play/relate to her because she's a women and are suppose to watch over her instead is plain offensive to me.
What could she do on her own in the old game?
She did everything on her own.
If the new Lara couldn't do anything on her own, there would be another character constantly hovering around saving her every five minutes and doing all of the heavy lifting for her, and from what we've seen so far, she's going to be on her own for the majority of the time. The new Lara has to do everything on her own too.
 

TehCookie

Elite Member
Sep 16, 2008
3,923
0
41
erttheking said:
TehCookie said:
I find the new game to be way more sexist than the old ones. In the old ones she was sexy, I don't get how that is sexist. In the new ones she's unable to do anything on her own and you're suppose to be her helper and cheering her on. Having a game that you're not suppose to role-play/relate to her because she's a women and are suppose to watch over her instead is plain offensive to me.
I can't help but feel like you're focusing less on the game and more on what one twat said. No offense.
You've never read a review? He was talking about the game and what perspective it was from, and I dislike games written like that.
 

Erttheking

Member
Legacy
Oct 5, 2011
10,845
1
3
Country
United States
TehCookie said:
erttheking said:
TehCookie said:
I find the new game to be way more sexist than the old ones. In the old ones she was sexy, I don't get how that is sexist. In the new ones she's unable to do anything on her own and you're suppose to be her helper and cheering her on. Having a game that you're not suppose to role-play/relate to her because she's a women and are suppose to watch over her instead is plain offensive to me.
I can't help but feel like you're focusing less on the game and more on what one twat said. No offense.
You've never read a review? He was talking about the game and what perspective it was from, and I dislike games written like that.
And I couldn't help but recall that the entire rest of the development team went on to say that he was full of crap and that what he said didn't reflect the game that they were trying to make...then everyone accused them of backpedaling...you know, I like video games and I like writing, but I don't think I ever want to get a job as a writer in the game industry, it seems like a very thankless job.
 

TehCookie

Elite Member
Sep 16, 2008
3,923
0
41
m19 said:
TehCookie said:
She did everything on her own.
No... You did everything for her with a controller. How deeply you identified with her (or not) is a matter of your attitude, not the game's.

Which is what the guy was talking about, correctly or not. The new Lara does all those things "on her own", how you feel about her is on you. Everyone's relationship with a fictional protagonist is their own.
There's a different between character's you're suppose to role-play and pre-written characters you're suppose to empathize with. Wait you're not even suppose to empathize with Lara either, you're suppose to protect her.
 

Erttheking

Member
Legacy
Oct 5, 2011
10,845
1
3
Country
United States
TehCookie said:
m19 said:
TehCookie said:
She did everything on her own.
No... You did everything for her with a controller. How deeply you identified with her (or not) is a matter of your attitude, not the game's.

Which is what the guy was talking about, correctly or not. The new Lara does all those things "on her own", how you feel about her is on you. Everyone's relationship with a fictional protagonist is their own.
There's a different between character's you're suppose to role-play and pre-written characters you're suppose to empathize with. Wait you're not even suppose to empathize with Lara either, you're suppose to protect her.
Yeah, you're letting yourself get hung up on what that one guy said. Frankly I always have trouble role playing as a person with a name and personality, I feel more like I just control them for the action segments. I just play through the game and watch their character arcs, hoping to enjoy them. The only time I actually feel like I'm roleplaying as a character is when I play a game where I build my character from the group up, like Fallout or Dark Souls.
 

SonOfVoorhees

New member
Aug 3, 2011
3,509
0
0
Soxafloppin said:
Lara burst out of the Womb in a slow motion Leap, with a Pistol in each hand?
They should show that in the games cutscene. lol. I agree though this game takes her as a normal girl and shows how she got so good at killing and surviving. Once getting through this new game im sure anyone in that same situation would come out stronger.
 

TehCookie

Elite Member
Sep 16, 2008
3,923
0
41
erttheking said:
TehCookie said:
m19 said:
TehCookie said:
I find the new game to be way more sexist than the old ones. In the old ones she was sexy, I don't get how that is sexist. In the new ones she's unable to do anything on her own and you're suppose to be her helper and cheering her on. Having a game that you're not suppose to role-play/relate to her because she's a women and are suppose to watch over her instead is plain offensive to me.
What could she do on her own in the old game?
She did everything on her own.
If the new Lara couldn't do anything on her own, there would be another character constantly hovering around saving her every five minutes and doing all of the heavy lifting for her, and from what we've seen so far, she's going to be on her own for the majority of the time. The new Lara has to do everything on her own too.
You are suppose to be that character. In the old one you were Lara.
 

dyre

New member
Mar 30, 2011
2,178
0
0
The new Tomb Raider looks great. The old Lara annoyed the hell out of me; this one seems more like a relatable human being, with an initially low but ever increasing level of badassery. Plus, the old Tomb Raider games were pretty dull, imo. Besides the isometric one; that was pretty cool. A reboot of the character and the series is exactly what Tomb Raider needs.

m19 said:
This is what I don't get about feminists. They will tell you that a woman lives in fear of assault and rape in much bigger measure than a man does because women are inherently more vulnerable to these things and then they'll turn around and be upset when a man thinks a female character is more vulnerable and hence you root for her differently.
I'm pretty sure it's an even tinier vocal minority than usual on this topic. At least, I hope most of the feminists are focusing on actual issues like the wage gap or w/e.
 

Erttheking

Member
Legacy
Oct 5, 2011
10,845
1
3
Country
United States
TehCookie said:
erttheking said:
TehCookie said:
m19 said:
TehCookie said:
I find the new game to be way more sexist than the old ones. In the old ones she was sexy, I don't get how that is sexist. In the new ones she's unable to do anything on her own and you're suppose to be her helper and cheering her on. Having a game that you're not suppose to role-play/relate to her because she's a women and are suppose to watch over her instead is plain offensive to me.
What could she do on her own in the old game?
She did everything on her own.
If the new Lara couldn't do anything on her own, there would be another character constantly hovering around saving her every five minutes and doing all of the heavy lifting for her, and from what we've seen so far, she's going to be on her own for the majority of the time. The new Lara has to do everything on her own too.
You are suppose to be that character. In the old one you were Lara.
Yeah, well no offense, that's not how I play games. Like I said, I can't really role play as a pre-existing character, my mind just doesn't let me. I'm actually looking forward to the new Tomb Raider on account of me wanting to see Lara grow as a character, but not because I want to be her. I bought the new Halo for the same reason, because I wanted to see Chief grow as a character, but not because I wanted to be him.
 

lacktheknack

Je suis joined jewels.
Jan 19, 2009
19,316
0
0
Define sexist.

People keep saying that "sexism" is "drawing attention to the idea of gender". It's not, but if that's the new standard...