I'm only saying Personality because it's the best way I can describe it, but personality is what attracts me most. There's a number of things that attract me to men/women (I'm not picky).
I'll admit, I can be shallow at first, picking someone for looks I find attractive. In my case it's usually someone slim, smiling (though nicely, not like a loony), generally nice to look at. Then things get a little deeper. I'll try to get to know them and when I learn certain things like what they do for fun, how they act in public and most importantly to me, their relationship with their family. No, I'm not talking about whether they're adopted or so. I mean that the thing that turns me off and pisses me off most is when someone does nothing but constantly fight with their parents. Siblings, not so bad. I have a sister and although we're close, we still fight a lot. My first two girlfriends were SO irritable towards their parents. Constantly fighting with them even over the smallest of things. Those relationships lasted all over 3 months at the most. My 3rd g/f as the most polite, loving person who was always happy around her parents. Helped out when asked, etc. We lasted 3 years together and even now (5 years since) I wish we hadn't broken up.
Anyway, I digress...
Basically, my order of attraction is:
*Appearance (what type of clothing, how much make-up/fake tan, etc. Anyone who thinks looking like a piece of sparkly, painted, leather is attractive will be shoved in the other direction.)
*Smile
*Personality
*Body (the more physical side of it all. For me, it's the geeky/nerdy look an no extremes. No anorexics or over-the-top body-builders for me thanks)