Poll: Why the hate for Dragonforce?

Recommended Videos

VitalSigns

New member
May 20, 2009
835
0
0
8 minute songs with 4 minutes of nonsensical Speed soloing is the problem.
they are not a bad band, but Herman Lee is overhyped and an assumed Virtuoso because he can play arpeggios really fast. Power Metal as a whole is laughable and the only band I ever thought was good from the genre was Blind Guardian.
 

RavingLibDem

New member
Dec 20, 2008
350
0
0
crazyhaircut94 said:
I do get that some people think they're repetitive, but why does it call for hate and stupid profanity? Every DF video, 90% claim that they suck. When will people learn to be more respectful and less judgemental? Oh, and while I'm on it, a little survey on what the Escapists think of them.
Ah your falling for the idea that youtube comments are in some way reflective of any normal or informed opinion, I'm afraid to inform you that your wrong...
 

Kajt

New member
Feb 20, 2009
4,067
0
0
They're okay, not something I would put on my playlist though.
 

zerzxes

New member
Apr 14, 2009
399
0
0
they are bad, they ARE repative! the guitarplaing isn't impressive at all.

and they suck live, lok studioforce trying to impress by playing song they don't even know how to play!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YeqPBccra30
 

TheMushroomClub

New member
Aug 12, 2008
219
0
0
People only know them because of guitar hero. That's why I hate them. Seriously, would you know Dragonforce if it weren't for Guitar Hero???
 

Fingerprint

Elite Member
Oct 30, 2008
1,297
0
41
I'm indifferent. They can obviously play, there can be no denying that but its just not my taste in music.
 

Ethanor

New member
May 18, 2009
26
0
0
i think DF's awesome. all of the members are experts of their fields, high-pinch vocals, faaast guitar riffs ( i dont care that they cant do it live, then dont ****ing hear 'em live) awesome drums, strong bass and epic keys. i think we (DF and their fans) are just ahead of our time
 

Mezrev

New member
Apr 4, 2009
148
0
0
People take Dragonforce way too seriously, always makes me laugh when people are raging about them.

VitalSigns said:
8 minute songs with 4 minutes of nonsensical Speed soloing is the problem.
they are not a bad band, but Herman Lee is overhyped and an assumed Virtuoso because he can play arpeggios really fast. Power Metal as a whole is laughable and the only band I ever thought was good from the genre was Blind Guardian.
Must.. resist... the urge... to kill...

TheMushroomClub said:
People only know them because of guitar hero. That's why I hate them. Seriously, would you know Dragonforce if it weren't for Guitar Hero???
I knew about Dragonforce long before they were in Guitar Hero
 

Lexodus

New member
Apr 14, 2009
2,816
0
0
TheMushroomClub said:
People only know them because of guitar hero. That's why I hate them. Seriously, would you know Dragonforce if it weren't for Guitar Hero???
Yes.
 

Artemis923

New member
Dec 25, 2008
1,496
0
0
VitalSigns said:
8 minute songs with 4 minutes of nonsensical Speed soloing is the problem.
they are not a bad band, but Herman Lee is overhyped and an assumed Virtuoso because he can play arpeggios really fast. Power Metal as a whole is laughable and the only band I ever thought was good from the genre was Blind Guardian.
Ever hear te great and immortal Rhapsody?
 

CaptainCrunch

Imp-imation Department
Jul 21, 2008
711
0
0
I haven't decided which is worse: their music, or the fact that threads like this pop up entirely too often.

I believe all the specifics about why people don't like their music have been made clear by previous posters (highly technical playing with zero musical substance, etc). Far more annoying than being ear-raped is the fact that some fans won't just let the issue die. The debate has been going for several years, with no clear victor to date.

The worst thing (for me) about Dragonforce is that their fans are completely convinced of their awesomeness, and often (not always) take it to evangelistic levels of annoyingness. This doesn't mean that Dragonforce fans are wrong to believe such things, but rather they are wrong to "take it to the streets." Easily the most un-metal part of the Dragonforce craze is the overzealous fanboys.

To the Dragonforce fans: please, just let it go already. Some of us don't like the band, some of us don't like the fans. It's incredibly easy to fix one of these problems. It starts with not fighting over this anymore. When all the pointless debate is over, pick up some Dream Theater and see if you like it as much.

To my fellow haters: We stand little chance of converting Dragonforce fans by such meaningless pandering. Leave them alone, and maybe they'll just drop the issue once and for all. Perhaps recommend transitional bands instead of building a wall to keep them out of the "good metal".
 

Arkhangelsk

New member
Mar 1, 2009
7,702
0
0
-Orgasmatron- said:
crazyhaircut94 said:
I do get that some people think they're repetitive, but why does it call for hate and stupid profanity? Every DF video, 90% claim that they suck. When will people learn to be more respectful and less judgemental? Oh, and while I'm on it, a little survey on what the Escapists think of them.
They can't play as fast live as they do on albums.

They've also tricked alot of younger guitar players into thinking it's all about how fast you can play the same four notes over and over.
True, they've gone a bit in over their heads, but lately they've been cleaning up their act. Also, the young guitar player thing, they've never said that as I recall, it's just plain stupidity by the young lings. It's true, they play fast, but that's nothing to idealize above anything else.
 

Red Right Hand

Squatter
Feb 23, 2009
1,093
0
0
BonsaiK said:
They have their heads firmly lodged up their asses and are all the worse for it.
I hate them because they do't make good music. All they do is play really fast music, which quite frankly, I think sounds terrible. Plus being able to play live well is he sign of a good band for me, if they lack this then I have no interest in listening to them.
PS(I changed the quote but I don't know how you put the changes in bold, any help?)
 

BLS

New member
Apr 20, 2009
61
0
0
They're good, not great. Crazy sick solos for 4 minutes leaves me like okay... where did the song go. They're quite good songs but they seem to overstay their welcome for me. For those of you who think it's just insane power metal, listen to down over a new world, not the same as the rest, probably their best song and incidently their shortest. So overall, a good band but the solo's are too long and crazy.
 

Cowabungaa

New member
Feb 10, 2008
10,806
0
0
I used to listen to it, than I decided it was getting repetative and a bit too loud. I still recognise their solo's as being really badass, but since I probably heard them too much I can't be bothered to listen to them anymore. Been there, done that, time to move on. Nothing lasts forever.
 

Not Good

New member
Sep 17, 2008
934
0
0
Let me Count the ways

Boring Repetitive Riffs Ripped off of Iron Maiden
Singer Sounds like a schoolboy with no nads
Horrible live
OMG UNLIMITED TRACKS IN STUDIO SO I CANS ADD A BUNCH OF STUFFZ!!!!11!!one!!
Synth. Cheezy as shit synth (Keytuiar anyone?)

So 5.
 

Jerious1154

New member
Aug 18, 2008
547
0
0
Whether or not they speed up they're songs, I still believe that they are talented instrumentalists. However, that doesn't make them a good band. Their songs are not musically interesting, their lyrics are cliched, and they just don't have any substance underneath the ridiculous speed.