magicmonkeybars said:
If that was true then why didn't people vote "other" and explain that another video series could just as easily have drawn them to the site ?
1. Because people don't read and think that carefully before posting.
2. People DID explain just that in posts, en masse. The thread is littered with posts that say "ZP brought me here, other stuff made me stay". But they voted ZP anyways (this can be verified easily if you do the maths), because they simply reinterpreted the question to "Without which show would escapist be in deep trouble/be much less popular?".
What's going on really isn't rocket science: ZP right now gets the most newbies to the comm. People then decide that they like it here because of the rest. ZP attracts, other stuff keeps them. BUT: People leave all the time, for other reasons than ZP ... thats completely normal and applies to every community on the net. In every community, people constantly leave, and for activity to remain constant, new ones need to be attracted. THIS is why a show like ZP is relevant: Even if people do not leave because of no-ZP, they leave for other reasons, and thus unless there is something that attracts newbies, activity will go down.
ZP actually does this job so "well", that newbies sign up faster, than existing members leave - MUCH faster.... for my taste, currently faster than is healthy (i could now go into detail why, but that would lead kinda offtopic).