Not really. Having the other option being killing everyone ever except for one person doesn't really give much of a choice. You have "I die and everyone else lives" or "everyone else dies and I die shortly after because I can no longer get what I need to survive without other people." Not really much of a moral dilemma here.Womplord said:This topic isn't about finding flaws in my statement it's about finding how much people value their own life vs. the life of others.
That's completely avoiding the point of the question.C2Ultima said:Then again, why should I have to press either button? Can't I just say "fuck it" and walk away?
Even people in suffering often find some enjoyment in life - it's not nice, but at least many have someone to love whatever their life is like. Plus, there are many who are overall enjoying life. And I think you'll find only a small minority of this world actually want to be killed. Plus, you'd be killing the chance for us to stop as much suffering as possible, however small that chance is :/Epifols said:No, your option to save them is disgusting. How can you possibly justify the continuation of greed, hate, murder, exploitation, disease, overpopulation, starvation, corruption, and just overall suffering?LuckyClover95 said:I actually can't believe almost 20% of the people who voted would kill everybody else on this planet for the sake of themselves. To me this seems disgusting....
The only humane thing to do is to let them all die, and then live the rest of your life knowing that you solved all of those terrible problems.
I should think every parent on the planet would think so, too. So would I.mr-fix_it said:I think your parents really really really fucked up in raising you.
you will also note it doesn't say an eternity of suffering.Epifols said:The poll does not say that the earth will become a utopia the moment you die. Where are you getting this from?Ashtovo said:if it meant an eternity of happiness for the human race.
What would you do if everyone was dead?Womplord said:Okay, I don't know if this has been done but lets say that you are in a room with two buttons. One says that if you will press it the rest of the human race will be killed - instantly vanish into thin air dead. The other says that you die and life goes on for the rest of the humans. Somehow you know that the buttons are real, through magic.(magic? thats creative) Also, you have to choose RIGHT NOW, also because of magic.
Also, how about for the purposes of this thread we say the atheists are right? Otherwise religious people will die to go to heaven. Please don't turn this into a religious debate...
SO WHICH DO YOU CHOOSE ESCAPIST?
Personally, I would choose to live. Your existense isn't something to be objectively moral about, imo.
What kind of asshole would choose to let everyone else... oh.Womplord said:Okay, I don't know if this has been done but lets say that you are in a room with two buttons. One says that if you will press it the rest of the human race will be killed - instantly vanish into thin air dead. The other says that you die and life goes on for the rest of the humans. Somehow you know that the buttons are real, through magic.(magic? thats creative) Also, you have to choose RIGHT NOW, also because of magic.
Also, how about for the purposes of this thread we say the atheists are right? Otherwise religious people will die to go to heaven. Please don't turn this into a religious debate...
SO WHICH DO YOU CHOOSE ESCAPIST?
Personally, I would choose to live. Your existense isn't something to be objectively moral about, imo.
You know the way you snipped my post it looks like I'm directly insulting the OP :/ and since the said that he/she would kill of humanity I did indirectly insult them... FUCK! *runs from mods*Danny Ocean said:I should think every parent on the planet would think so, too. So would I.mr-fix_it said:I think your parents really really really fucked up in raising you.
Anyone who would rather save themselves is either naive, selfish enough to kill Jesus with a glance, or just plain crazy.