You know what, if you're lucky enough to find a girl that is truly a virgin while you happen to be a virgin, Godspeed on your magical journey.
Seriously, the likelihood of finding an attractive girl who didn't lose it around 16 is so astronomically low that you deserve all the pleasure of breaking her in. Frankly, I don't go fishing around the kiddie pool so I'll leave this to the professionals.
So whether you like it or not, your first time is likely going to be with someone who has experience. Trust me though, this is ideal because you will be terrible. You can redeem yourself sure, but it is far better to disappoint someone who knows what to expect from a new sexual partner as opposed to someone who doesn't. You could effectively ruin a virgin's expectations of sex if her first wasn't with someone who had experience. She needs something to look forward to, after all.
And so do you. Girls with experience (for the most part) will treat you right and will tell you exactly what you need to do to get the most pleasure out of their bodies. Could be something as simple as kissing, touching certain erogenous zones, and whatever else gets their freak on. Then of course, the obvious intercourse stuff.
Being that you may have achieved some success with this partner, you take what you've learned and apply it to a new sexual partner. You may not get them off right away as all girls require a certain approach, but you won't be fishing in the dark. She might even call your amateur ass experienced if you play your cards right.
Now tell me, what sort of transferable knowledge what a virgin give you?
Probably next to nothing, assuming she speaks to you again. You made the poor thing cry, after all.