CyberSinner said:
The Gameplay is Good
The Story is Bad
Thus it is a Bad game. I cannot even finish the game because of the story. I returned L.A Noire because of its story. Story is just as important.
Then simply get out of gaming and pick up books and movies. Games aren't meant for stories, unless you're playing niche interactive story games, like Heavy Rain or The Walking Dead.
Games with bad gameplay and okay-good stories don't pass in the gaming society as good. Look at Neverdead or Final Fantasy 13. They're bad games through and through. Their only redeeming factors are looking at a few cut scenes now and again, but that's not enough to save them from being absolutely mind numbingly shit.
However, games with GOOD gameplay and bad stories are the foundation of game design. Games with no stories have been the pioneers of game development and most genres exist because of them. The reason those games are so great is because the developers focused on gameplay with little regards for story.
Saying that story is as important in a game as gameplay is a toxic opinion that eventually leads to the degradation of game quality, so if you don't like games, then don't play games. Don't try and pick out certain titles simply for BEING games and tell others they're bad.