Reviewing Escapist magazine

Recommended Videos

FDLinc

New member
May 8, 2011
37
0
0
Let's review the reviewers.
What do the readers like about the Escapist? What don't they like?
What would YOU want changed and what do YOU want left alone?
 

zehydra

New member
Oct 25, 2009
5,033
0
0
I like ZP, and Extra Credits.

But I mainly am here for the forums nowadays.

I don't really care what happens to anything, but please keep ZP and EC
 

FDLinc

New member
May 8, 2011
37
0
0
Kickin' things off, I have no idea why they had to change the links to the podcasts in the RSS feed into an undownloadable HTML file: I know you can copy and paste the link into iTunes, but my pc doesn't have iTunes, and why should I have to get one when the old method worked so well? Please change PLEASE!
 

KefkaCultist

New member
Jun 8, 2010
2,120
0
0
I like Extra Credits and everything done by the LRR crew. EDIT: Also I love Miracle of Sound's stuff.

I don't like that Doraleous and Associates and Top 5 With Lisa Foiles has been gone for so long and I don't like The Jimquisition (not disrespecting the show or anything, but it just isn't for me.)

I'd want to change the fact that Community tab rarely gets updated anymore if at all. The rest of the site can be pretty much left alone.
 

Marter

Elite Member
Legacy
Oct 27, 2009
14,276
19
43
FetsiveDays said:
Let's review the reviewers.
What do the readers like about the Escapist? What don't they like?
What would YOU want changed and what do YOU want left alone?
I like...well, I like the forums, and I like Zero Punctuation. I've got quite a few issues withe the videos, but without wanting to spoil a potential thing that I might or might not end up doing, I may be doing formal reviews of The Escapist's shows in the future. There are just certain things about most of the shows that turn me off from them.
 

King Toasty

New member
Oct 2, 2010
1,527
0
0
I like Extra Credits, anything by LoadingReadyRun, and Zero Punctuation. To an extent. Lately, Yahtzee's been a little... off.

A really, really good site though. Forums are great, content is great, news is timely and well-written. In my ever-so-humble-but-totally-right opinion, this is the best gaming site out there.

Keep it up, Escapist Team!
 

CrazyCapnMorgan

Is not insane, just crazy >:)
Jan 5, 2011
2,742
0
0
I like it. The community is OK and there's some really cool people as contributor's here. There are things that can be improved upon, IMO, but these things are minor at best and given that I'm not completely in the know about WTH goes on at Escapist HQ, not my area to complain about. All-in-all, it's a pretty happenin' place daddy-o complete with your usual people, your weird people, your stylin' people, your trollin' people and people you aren't completely sure that they're even people.

 

enzilewulf

New member
Jun 19, 2009
2,130
0
0
like how friendly and funny everything is yet I hate the grammar nazi's and the fact that if you like rap and don't believe in evolution your labeled a idiotic fuck up with no taste in music. At least from what I seen any ways. What ever though it beats /b/.

Yes I am aware that I didn't capitalize like and nazi. Don't really care mom.
 

ZiggyE

New member
Nov 13, 2010
502
0
0
enzilewulf said:
don't believe in evolution your labeled a idiotic fuck up
I wouldn't say 'idiotic fuck'. More, 'willfully ignorant'. I can't see how anyone in this day and age wouldn't believe in evolution unless they intentionally ignored all the evidence for it. Same with global warming.

But I'm going off on a tangent now.
 

zehydra

New member
Oct 25, 2009
5,033
0
0
ZiggyE said:
enzilewulf said:
don't believe in evolution your labeled a idiotic fuck up
I wouldn't say 'idiotic fuck'. More, 'willfully ignorant'. I can't see how anyone in this day and age wouldn't believe in evolution unless they intentionally ignored all the evidence for it. Same with global warming.

But I'm going off on a tangent now.
I think the issue is that most people just sort of go with what they're told in school, church, at home, whatever, and few people actually come up with evidence for or against evolution themselves
 

USSR

Probably your average communist.
Oct 4, 2008
2,367
0
0
I like the videos.
Extra Credits is very entertaining.
I miss Unforgotten Realms though |:

The forums- The community has gone to hell in my opinion.
And people still wonder why we have "Forum Health Bars."

EDIT: How could I forget, I adore Critical Miss and Stolen Pixels.
 

enzilewulf

New member
Jun 19, 2009
2,130
0
0
ZiggyE said:
enzilewulf said:
don't believe in evolution your labeled a idiotic fuck up
I wouldn't say 'idiotic fuck'. More, 'willfully ignorant'. I can't see how anyone in this day and age wouldn't believe in evolution unless they intentionally ignored all the evidence for it. Same with global warming.

But I'm going off on a tangent now.
well see for me that post was a rant because really its stupid how carried away people (like me) get when it comes to evolution. I do believe in it but I respect others views where other people on this forum get carried away and think your a idiot when mainly you probably don't wish to deal with the topic at all. I don't call that ignorance as much as "I don't want to seem like a dick about religion or evolution, so I choose to keep my believes to me and talk about sports or games with my mates other than talk and have a argument about evolution that will get us no where except to the land of smug" Just because they don't see what you see has no reason to go bad shit crazy on their ass. Yet maybe that's just me.
 

orangeapples

New member
Aug 1, 2009
1,836
0
0
Seems like a pretty nice place.

I always found it odd that the sources for many of the gaming news stuff tends to say it is from destructoid, 1up, IGN, kotaku. You know, other gaming news sites. It kinda feels like the news links should just send us to those sites instead of the copy paste we see here.

For the game reviews, I really like them. They do in depth about the games and point out flaws but always point out the merits of games they review. They are fair.

Entertainment stuff is entertaining. I love me some ZP, unskippable and other random things I feel like clicking that day.

Lots of Informational stuff I really like: Big Picture, Extra Credits, Jimquizition offer a really critical look at our culture.

Forums are a fair place. most people just like giving their opinions, but a few go into a "your ideas are different than mine? lets battle!" mindset.

note that I'm not a professional reviewer, so yeah... 8.5/10
 

LobsterFeng

New member
Apr 10, 2011
1,766
0
0
Zero Punctuation and Extra Credits are awesome. I like Moviebob too...sometimes.

But let's see if I can say this without being yelled at, everyone here is super pretentious. And I mean everyone, including the users. So yeah, I'm pretentious too.

Is being pretentious a bad thing? No that's how most critics are, but sometimes it's just annoying to see people act like they know everything. And yes I realize that I do that too.
 

manaman

New member
Sep 2, 2007
3,218
0
0
Been here a while. So you lot know that I must like at least one thing about the place to keep coming back. Mostly it's the forums. I think I might be addicted. Sometimes I even post from my phone, as annoying as doing that is sometimes I just have to.

ZiggyE said:
Get rid of the forums, keep everything else.
You know you don't have to post. Right? You do realize that? You also have enough self control not to post to forums you don't want to post to, right?

Crazy isn't it.
enzilewulf said:
ZiggyE said:
enzilewulf said:
don't believe in evolution your labeled a idiotic fuck up
I wouldn't say 'idiotic fuck'. More, 'willfully ignorant'. I can't see how anyone in this day and age wouldn't believe in evolution unless they intentionally ignored all the evidence for it. Same with global warming.

But I'm going off on a tangent now.
well see for me that post was a rant because really its stupid how carried away people (like me) get when it comes to evolution. I do believe in it but I respect others views where other people on this forum get carried away and think your a idiot when mainly you probably don't wish to deal with the topic at all. I don't call that ignorance as much as "I don't want to seem like a dick about religion or evolution, so I choose to keep my believes to me and talk about sports or games with my mates other than talk and have a argument about evolution that will get us no where except to the land of smug" Just because they don't see what you see has no reason to go bad shit crazy on their ass. Yet maybe that's just me.
To say evolution is a myth goes above and beyond the typical differences of opinion that I can respect.

Respect has to be earned, it's not something given. I don't have to respect an opinion that is so evidently wrong. Now that doesn't mean I can't still respect the person with that opinion, and by doing so not call them a jerk, and idiot, or any other choice name.
 

Mr Thin

New member
Apr 4, 2010
1,719
0
0
With regards to the forums; the moderation often seems a bit weird, and the sheer volume of repeat threads annoys the crap out of me. But this is the only website I'm an active member of, so perhaps this is the case all over the internets.

Content wise, I like pretty much everything. I read most of the news/articles, and watch most of the reviews/videos. I love all the comic strips on this site.

Haven't heard much from Shamus Young in a while, he's probably my second favourite thing on here (Yahtzee being the obvious favourite), and I'd like to see more of him; but that's him, not the site. And I still have his own website to enjoy.
 

Jordi

New member
Jun 6, 2009
812
0
0
I like Shamus Young, MovieBob, Yathzee, Jim Sterling and Extra Credits, and the stuff they contribute to the site. The forum community is fairly okay for the internet (although the repeat threads are getting annoying) and I like the strict moderation. The reviews are usually pretty good too, although I think it is a shame that they will use the console version of a game whenever possible, even though I think some games are far better on PC and I think the majority of people on the forums are PC gamers.

As for the negative: The news is absolutely fucking horrible, because it is so incredibly biased, almost always contains opinions of the news writer presented as fact and they use the most sensationalist and/or inflammatory headlines.
I also have the feeling that they are trying to bully people into becoming members of the pub club. I'm not having a lot of trouble with the ads, but a while back there were a lot of people who claimed they had problems. I don't get why we need to have the captchas and the age verification things for videos though. I'm already logged in, they know who I am (i.e. not a spammer) and what my birth date is.
 

enzilewulf

New member
Jun 19, 2009
2,130
0
0
manaman said:
Been here a while. So you lot know that I must like at least one thing about the place to keep coming back. Mostly it's the forums. I think I might be addicted. Sometimes I even post from my phone, as annoying as doing that is sometimes I just have to.

ZiggyE said:
Get rid of the forums, keep everything else.
You know you don't have to post. Right? You do realize that? You also have enough self control not to post to forums you don't want to post to, right?

Crazy isn't it.
enzilewulf said:
ZiggyE said:
enzilewulf said:
don't believe in evolution your labeled a idiotic fuck up
I wouldn't say 'idiotic fuck'. More, 'willfully ignorant'. I can't see how anyone in this day and age wouldn't believe in evolution unless they intentionally ignored all the evidence for it. Same with global warming.

But I'm going off on a tangent now.
well see for me that post was a rant because really its stupid how carried away people (like me) get when it comes to evolution. I do believe in it but I respect others views where other people on this forum get carried away and think your a idiot when mainly you probably don't wish to deal with the topic at all. I don't call that ignorance as much as "I don't want to seem like a dick about religion or evolution, so I choose to keep my believes to me and talk about sports or games with my mates other than talk and have a argument about evolution that will get us no where except to the land of smug" Just because they don't see what you see has no reason to go bad shit crazy on their ass. Yet maybe that's just me.
To say evolution is a myth goes above and beyond the typical differences of opinion that I can respect.

Respect has to be earned, it's not something given. I don't have to respect an opinion that is so evidently wrong. Now that doesn't mean I can't still respect the person with that opinion, and by doing so not call them a jerk, and idiot, or any other choice name.
Well see I am just curious as to why any body here really cares. I mean isn't this a place for video games and video game related news? Yet I meet such stuck up people on the whole evolution thing its really hard not to just post a simple "shut the fuck up". I mean I saw some one post that they wouldn't be friends with people who didn't believe in evolution and it only raises the question: Why? do you really crave to look like a intellectual dick that much that you wouldn't be friends with them? now if they are spraying some bible thumper bull shit and hating on your view then that's totally fine but for people who just practice their beliefs and don't really say anything on the subject to get that disrespected is just plane stupid.

(Also sorry I really didn't mean to make this into some stupid thing about Evolution vs the world this is just something that stops this place from being a kingdom to me.)